The Settlers Inn
The Chestnut Tavern offers guests a more casual atmosphere. The wine program is an integral part of the dining experience. Our wine list has received an award of excellence by Wine Spectator for thirteen years.
Brunch: Saturday - Sunday: 11:00am - 2:15pm
Dinner: Sunday - Thursday: 5:30pm - 8:15, Friday - Saturday: 5:30pm - 9:15pm
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun - Fri 5:30PM - 5:45PM
Sat 5:30PM - 5:45PM 9:00PM - 9:15PM
Overall amazing experience. The food was absolutely delicious. No complaints. We will be back.
We spent our 23rd Wedding Anniversary at the Settlers in for Dinner. The staff could not have been any friendlier and the restaurant was all decked out with Holiday decor, just adorable. My only complaint was portion size for a few of the selections but the food was flavorful.
Whenever I visit my father, who lives in the area, this is our go-to special night out. The service is always excellent and the food doesn't disappoint (love their french onion soup!). I love the seasonal desserts, drinks, and menu. During this last visit they had a fantastic special that included any starter, a glass of wine, a prime rib and lobster tail entree, and a dessert for $49. You just can't beat it! I look forward to my next visit!
First time visit to Settler's Inn was first rate. Excellent attention to detail. Food was exceptional and the choices were eclectic and contemporary, while still unpretentious. Will certainly return!
I really dig this place. Nothing out of this world but i have been here many times and i have always left satisfied.
Great selection of craft beers which i personally enjoy. The food options offer a good variety of very well prepared comfort foods.
Coming for dinner is always a nice experience, quiet and cozy, it will help set the mood for that romantic evening with your significant other.
A true gem of a restaurant. Food was both unique and delicious, very fresh, with good visual appeal.
We were a party of 4 adults and all agreed the food was spectacular.
We thoroughly enjoyed an exceptional meal together with terrific service. My filet mignon was one of the best ever! I most eagerly recommend this to anyone desiring fine dining. We will certain return whenever we are in the area!
The Settlers Inn is a wonderful place to stay and the cuisine is fantastic.I had the scallops and a carrot puree and beets and it was delicious. Also had a goat cheese appetizer and no room for dessert. Our waitress was knowledgeable, attentive and friendly.
The breakfast is also delicious all farm fresh.
Loved the food...except the amuse bouchée. We’ve dined here before and the amuse bouchée is hit or miss. Loved the Cabernet wine tasting and the dessert wine tasting. Dessert was apple upside down cake with pistachio ice cream and it was delicious! Overall, Settlers Inn is fantastic. If you need a place for a romantic dinner or a special occasion....this is your place.
our first time at Settlers Inn was a pleasant surprise. It was lovely and the food was wonderful. Will definitely go back.
This is my go-to place for brunch with the girls - it never disappoints. Impeccable service & presentation of the food and the food itself is amazing. Consistently good!
Food was outstanding. Great ambiance. Dessert portions we're very small.
great atmosphere, excellent food, excellent service
On a Saturday night at 7:30, the place was hopping. It was a little too loud in the dining room to hold an intimate conversation with my date. However, the food was very good, fresh and so unique! We had a little bump with the service in that I was brought the incorrect soup, and the salad I ordered never came. Overall we had a very pleasant experience and are looking forward to returning over the holidays!
Always a fantastic meal with attentive staff. Cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. The duck is fantastic
The service was outstanding the food was wonderful. We have been going for the past 3 years to celebrate our anniversary every year is better and better. Cant wait til next year.❤
definitely one of our all time favorites places to enjoy a gourmet, casual, intimate dinner with excellent friendly service, a warm inviting setting that changes with the seasons and a varied menu with very fine wine selections. This last visit was to celebrate our anniversary and we felt that our experience was even more special with the sincere congratulations offered by the Settlers Inn hosts.
Always reliable for excellent food, service and ambiance. They decorate beautifully for every holiday or season. Simply a pleasure to go here
Simply amazing!!!! Been wanting to try this place for a year. Finally went and was blown away by the food! Ambiance was cozy and warm, reminiscent pf a quaint Vermont Inn. Staff and service was excellent. Above and beyond what we were expecting to find in NEPA. A true gem!
We love the food....
We had an excellent dinner here.
The atmosphere is beautiful: this is an Arts and Crafts style building, with great attention to detail.
The craft beer list is outstanding. We had the mussels appetizer: they were fresh and plump, in a great sauce. This was a special, not always on the menu.
The bread is homemade, and delicious: it arrived hot from the oven. My husband had the duck, which was very good. I had the vegetarian meatballs; the tomato sauce was outstanding.
Lovely atmosphere as always, but service was very slow and crepes and omelets were underwhelming.
We’ve always loved the Settlers Inn, but when we stopped in with our daughters for brunch, we were dismayed with the service. We payed 39.00 per adult...was to include an amuse bouche of mini pancakes, which we never received, bottomless mimosas (of which we mostly saw the bottom), and dessert, for which we had to track down the manager to find out our choices. The food was good, but not excellent. Our server, while extremely friendly, was MIA. Not what I remembered about our trips to Settlers over 10 years ago. We should have chosen the Tavern. Way too expensive for the experience. Quite disappointed.
Settlers Inn is a long standing family favorite...But halibut was very dry, no sommelier was on hand, and band thumping noise from below, unacceptable. Will hesitate to return at your prices. Server was great, however, did her best with wine list and very attentive, though obviously extremely busy.
The food is outstanding. I don't think we've ever had a bad meal there. I like that the food is "farm to table." Everything is always fresh and prepared just a little differently than usual, but the end result is always delicious. We've been going to Settlers Inn for years; our daughter had her wedding there. Everything from the food, wine and service is always outstanding. It's nice to get dressed to go out for dinner. Settlers Inn is special and a meal there is always a treat.
Foodie Weekend - Went to the Settlers for dinner with my wife. Service was outstanding. Being after the "season", much more relaxed and comfortable atmosphere.
I had the Lamb shank and my wife had the Duck. Both were prepared and presented nicely. The wine list is quite extensive. Great selections of both white and red.
Overall dinner was very good.
We have dined at Settlers at least 40 times in the 30 years since we built our "weekend" house nearby. Might be closer to 50 times. Tuesdays were described to us as a midwinter stimulus that has blossomed into an institution. Very good burger and a decent beer for $10? Great brainstorm and let's hope it continues.
Only problem was that one of the decent brews on tap was Guinness and they were out of it at 6:45 last night. No, no, no, guys - got to plan ahead better than that!
Thankfully the loud party near our table allowed us the chance to speak normally with each other after about 30 minutes of yelling on their part by exiting. Of course they had finished and then stuck around over empty glasses for at least 20 minutes. Rude.
I'm a regular customer - and more than happy to bring friends, family, and business guests, knowing the service will be great, the meal memorable, and the atmosphere very accommodating to a pleasant evening and conversation.
food is always good. Was seated 15 minutes later than our reservation AND the noise level was so high that my spouse and I could barely hear above the packed restaurant and piano player. We've been there before on a weekend, but the restaurant has never been this noisy and distracting.
It was an absolute delight eating here. Food and service were amazing.
My husband and I celebrated our 33rd anniversary and our dinner was fantastic. We loved the atmosphere which was very romantic. We also received a free glass of wine to celebrate. Thanks for making our evening special.
Our second trip to this rustic, fabulous restaurant. We shared fois gras bites, that were mouthwateringly sweet and smooth. The smoked trout, which we had had the previous time, was tough and over smoked this time, but we still got a few good bites.
Had the lemon chicken thighs with risotto, and it was crispy and lemony. Very good. Also had the pork tenderloin special with a fruit salsa which was good, but not as good as the chicken.
Had the same waiter, Sean, as last time, and he was knowledgeable and smooth as before. The dining room is lodgey/ Tudor, a lovely room. However, many guests were eating out on the terrace, despite the warm humid air.
This a is a beautiful place, with great plantings and landscaping, and old fashioned luxury inside. Worth a trip.
Beautiful, historic Inn - wonderful setting with nice outdoor deck and gardens. Food was excellent - had the lamb shank, it was great. Service was mediocre - but it was Labor Day weekend and crowded. We would definitely go back
Special dinner on Labor Day Weekend.
We love to visit the Hawley area with its quaint shops and wonderful dining experiences. The Settlers Inn is the flagship of a great family run business.
Great service, wonderful food and an interesting and value packed wine list!
We celebrated our 45th wedding anniversary with family, all were impressed with food, service and drinks. We will come back.
We always come here when we want a special evening, never disappointed.
My third time dining at the Settlers Inn as a detour on the way back from the Adirondacks. Once again, a stunning, award-winning wine list and well-prepared, locally sourced food. The outdoor porch is idyllic in the right weather. Discreet, intelligent service.
We have been frequent diners for over 30 years. We have never been disappointed.
My friend and I live in Shohola Twp. and look for good places to eat. There are many in the area that we have enjoyed, and this will be on the top of our list. We will be back in the near future.
As always, our dinner was different, exiting and delicious. We had the red snapper special for two that was perfectly done with no bones and beautifully presented. The red sauce that surrounded the fish was exceptional. The piano player played songs that we knew and at a perfect sound level so as not to interrupt our conversation. It was a perfect evening.