The Settlers Inn
While the world has changed over the past few months we maintain our commitment to your safety and well being.
Our Chefs are busy creating delicious farm to table dishes for your dining experience. Our bartenders are anxious to craft you your favorite cocktail.Our waitstaff is eager to suggest their favorite dish and our Sommelier is ready to pair the perfect wine to compliment your selection.
As we move through this phase of recovery all dining will be al fresco. Please dress for the weather as we can have very warm or sometimes chilly nights.
We are looking forward to serving you this summer season and every season.
The Settlers Inn team
The service, food Settlers Inn wine, ambience and the covid readiness was perfection. We had not been out to a restaurant in months except for takeout and we had a wonderful anniversary celebration. We cannot wait to go back to the Settlers Inn soon....very soon!
Great place to eat indoors or outside. Friendly waiters attentive service
Lovely dining experience. Wonderful outdoor seating !
Absolutely wonderful dinner
Staff very friendly and attentive to our needs
I was impressed with the procedure in place during COVID
We felt very safe dining here
It was very good from the time we walked in to the time we were going. We will be going back again
The omelet was not very fluffy. It was more like a pan fried egg turned over. The portions were a nice size though.
This was our first meal out since the pandemic hit in early March. The staff took great care in being careful and cautious. The tables set very far apart from eachother. All staff had masks on the entire time.
Our waitress(I can’t remember her name but young black long hair and vegetarian) was wonderful. The food was delicious.
A very enjoyable evening out and more importantly felt very safe in the environment.
Pleasant setting, excellent food and service!
Delightful and unique menu. Kitchen accommodating to substitution and omissions.
Excellent service and very good food, but the ambience is so dark and dreary. Everything is brown -- the walls, the ceiling and the carpet. There is ZERO light in this dining room. For some reason, the owners of the Inn have decided to allow vines to grow over the beautiful bay window of the restaurant, so there is no natural light that enters -- even eating here for breakfast, you are in darkness. The artificial light is very minimal. It's just really dark, dreary, and feels like you are eating in a basement. This is SUCH a shame as the wait staff is wonderful and the food is so fresh and local, plus carefully prepared. Please, please repaint this space with decorator white ceilings and eggshell/cream walls. Lighten it up a little. The owners have gone overboard on the "arts & crafts" theme, so that they have more faux arts & crafts than authentic.
A beautiful place to dine! We ate under the tent outside due to COVID. The view of the gardens was delightful. Our server, Irene, was attentive, friendly, and efficient. We loved the food and drinks. The toffee pudding was amazing!
Terrace seating overlooking garden was perfect. Tempura zucchini flowers were unique and delicious. Excellent pork tenderloin. Don’t overlook this place.
Very nice place to eat. High quality food, good service and nice atmosphere.
We ate at the Settlers Inn on July 31st celebrating a family birthday. The quality, taste, portion sizes were very good. Unfortunately the service was not what we have come to expect. For starters, I had reserved a table two weeks prior and requested patio dining. Unfortunately the hostess couldn’t accommodate us, said “many people request the patio” and proceeded with seating us inside. The table was fine, but she seemed to care less. The other issue was our server Deborah wasn’t very attentive. She brought my son the wrong entree. She offered to get him what he had ordered, but my wife and I already had our entrees. The same thing happened to another table near us, however Deborah made amends by bringing a small carafe of wine to that table. We received nothing, no comps on the dessert we ordered, nothing. She also never corrected the bill until we pointed it out to her. Not a good experience. We would go back, but probably not for awhile. Again the food and atmosphere were positives.
Outstanding meal. Last time was there it wasn’t stellar. This time they exceeded expectations. Will definitely be back ASAP
Excellent service and great food, always consistent.
For my 50th bday we can where as a family! We had a very socially distant table in the back rented garden area. It felt safe with wait staff in masks, paper menus, etc. Drinks were a great size, definitely recommend the octopus and Mac & Cheese apps, and all of our dinners were delicious. Our waitress was so friendly. Great experience! Thank you Settler’s Inn.
This was the first restaurant I have been to since Valentines Day 2020! We ate on the outdoor porch and with the tables spaced apart very generously and few patrons I felt at ease and safe. We ate from the limited brunch menu and it was superb. Service was excellent!
We ate on the patio and it was lovely. The garden is magnificent. What a pleasure to look out on it as we dined. The menu choices were interesting and the food was delicious.
Steven was very attentive and accommodating. Can’t wait to go back!
We had the most delicious surf and turf (prime rib and lobster tail). Cooked to perfection. First time I ever tried a zucchini blossom. Delicious!! We sat out back looking at the beautiful gardens and wild bunnies running around. Servers were very attentive, polite, and helpful. Can’t wait to go back.
Food was ok!
Excellent experience all around.
The service was very nice and the atmosphere in the garden was so tranquil and beautiful. All of the dishes were outstanding.
We loved it....Beautiful and Fantastic....Food was absolutely delicious! Can’t wait to go back!!
Food was great, drinks were phenomenal. Will be back
My husband, daughter, son in law and I had a lovely dinner at Settler's Inn. The food was delicious and everyone was quite attentive in maintaining social distancing. It was a lovely evening.
Never a disappointment! Even with Covid-19 restrictions the dining experience was exceptional.
The Settler's Inn has a lovely Arts & Crafts theme going on. The setting is very nice, especially out back. The food was quite good---a filet, pork chop and skillet steak for our party. The only negative I would say was the maitre-d----was a bit off-putting when we walked in. Told us we'd have to wait until the wait staff came in, then seated others before us.
Food was excellent !
Our dinner was phenomenal. The grilled octopus appetizer was amazing - we will definitely be back!
The food is always outstanding and the service is impeccable.
Our meal at Settler's Inn occurred on the last night of our week-long vacation in Hawley. This meal was the best one out of all restaurants where we dined! We sat outside and enjoyed overlooking the beauty of the property.
I went two nights. The first night the food was decent and the atmosphere in the yard lovely. The second night I dined inside and the food was absolutely horrible. The meat was tough and the mash potatoes were bland and cold. When asked how it was, I said it was not very good in a very soft way. I received a bland nod and that was it.
Other hotel guests had the same experience.
Best Burger and Brew deal!! Always delicious. The outside eating area and deck lovely.
We have dined at the Settlers Inn many times and they never disappoint us. The extra precautions in place for Covid-19 has slowed service a little, but that is to be expected. The food was amazing...freshly prepared and very tasty.
Well organized in terms of Covid; calm and efficient.
Nice quiet dining room with prompt service. Limited menu but everything we had tasted great!
Love the food and presentation. Grounds are beautiful. Had to sit outside due to covid. Too many ants unfortunately.
The Settlers Inn offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (570) 226-2993.
The Settlers Inn is rated 4.7 stars by 1573 OpenTable diners.
The Settlers Inn does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://thesettlersinn.com.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.