The Saddle River Inn

Valentines day

Excellent dinner, service and ambience. Can’t wait to go back soon.

Love everything about this restaurant. Food , service, and romance. It has everything I was looking for.

Awesome as always !

The Inn never disappoints- Anthony is always on top of his game with taking care of all the dinners and the staff is always attentive to your needs. Jamie runs a fantastic classy restaurant- it is our favorite restaurant. Going again Friday and have two more scheduled in March.

Always wonderful, we’ve been going for years.

However this was the first time that our service was marginal. We had to finally ask for bread after our second glass of wine and prior to our order. We had to physically get up and find a waiter to bring our second bottle of wine and again physically get up to find a waiter to fill our water

Regardless, we love the food and restaurant and plan to dine there for many more years!

It was my wife’s and I first time here and it was by far one of my best dining experiences I’ve had in a while. Food, service everything was phenomenal will definitely be back

Family occasion

This is one of several places we go for special occasions. We don't get here that often because I never remember to call 30 days ahead of time to get a table. The cleaned up décor is nice, but I do still miss the "old" Saddle River Inn. We never seem to get waiters who know wines - example - you can pour a white down to the bottom (99% of the time anyway). Waiter walked away with wine left in the bottle. Red's need to be checked to make sure where the sediment is so you don't pour over it. But moving on from that - the food is very good. I had the crab cake, full of real crab meat pieces, not ground. My husband had the tuna which had just the right amount of jalepeno. He had the venison special and cleaned his plate. I had the lamb chops, which were cooked perfectly. We added the spatzle (yummy and crisp) and I asked for the potato gratin that is mentioned on the Filet. I just had ice cream for desert, which was a soothing finish to a rich, but good meal. We'll be back....if I can just remember to make the reservations in time......

We went for my husbands birthday. The barn is lovely and had a great comfy feel to it. We asked for a table by the window and we were seated right by the water! Perfect! Food was small portions but good
Bread was offered only once with a small portion of butter for true foodies!

As always everything was wonderful. The foie gras was as good as I’ve ever eaten. Every course was wonderfully prepared. The service was a little rushed.

So overrated.

Amazing food, wonderful, cozy ambiance, just right attentive service

We were seated, and waited for a waiter to come to our table. Three parties who entered after us were served bread and water, so we finally caught the attention of a waiter, and asked who our waiter was. Once we had a server, the rest of the dinner went smoothly. We had the chef's tasting menu, which was fun to experience.

We had a lovely evening celebrating our daughter’s birthday.

The food was outstanding along with the service and ambiance. I can't wait to go back!

Dining at The Saddle River Inn never disappoints. From the service to the food and overall ambience is exceptional. Will return again and again!

Always the best!!

fabulous as always! ❤️

This is a great restaurant.

The new caviar is spectacular.

Beautiful place in a beautiful setting. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a great place for a date or just getting together with a few friends. Very nice!

Hands down the single best restaurant in the Garden State and ranks up there with the finest of Manhattan eateries

Amazing!!!!!! This is my favorite restaurant by far. I make reservation a month in advance because i love it so much

Thank you so much for such a fabulous dinner, by far the best service, we were very impressed with the details and teamwork all of the staff. Amazing food. Brought my girlfriends for her birthday and I have to say you guys really made us feel special.
Thank you, thank you, wow, thank you!

Everything from service to ambience to food was fantastic

My sisters birthday. We had Andrew as our server. He was super. The food was amazing as always. I had the sirloin,Sue had the maribar we shared the Brussel sprouts which were amazing. The best we have ever had. We wanted the recipe but that was not going to happen. Thanks for a fabulous dinner

We had a wonderful time!

Great food, great service!!

Always a great experience. BYOB so don’t forget wine.

As always food and service are outstanding. as good as any Manhattan restaurant

Wanted to dine here for a long time with good friends. Unfortunately, we were all very disappointed. Service was just okay. Food is extremely over priced for quality and quantity. The BLT salad had literally 3 tablespoons of wanted to go here for a long time with good friends. Service was okay. Food is extremely overpriced for quality and quantity. The BLT lettuce salad was literally 3 tablespoons of lettuce. The duck breast was okay with 2 small pieces of bok choy. Bread pudding dessert was also a joke- 2 tiny squares of pudding. Are you kidding? Save your time and money and go to Cafe Panache!!

Really enjoyed a beautiful evening at The Saddle River Inn. Great meal and experience for my birthday.

Ambiance of restaurant and outstanding food always make for a special dinning experience. Our favorite restaurant to dine at on a special occasion.

The Saddle River Inn is my favorite place! Never disappoints! Food and service was truly outstanding...

Perfection!Food, ambiance and service were excellent! A bit shocked at some of the prices but a wonderful dining experience, especially for special occasions.

This was my wife and I's 1st time here and we will definitely be going back. My wife had the "Maribar" and she loved it. I had the crab cake app and the Halibut and they were both delicious. For dessert, she had the Warm Chocolate Cake and I had the Peanut Butter Mousse and they were amazing.

This was my 2nd visit to Saddle River Inn. The food and service are exceptional. Unfortunately, I forgot it was BYOB so I wasn't prepared. I wish this was indicated in the opentable confirmation emails.

Fantastic dishes. Very simple yet tasteful .
We been returning here whenever we can get a reservation .

Great experience...will be back again soon.