The Pluckemin Inn
castle valley polenta, collards, maitake, tasso ham
bacon, cheddar, LTO, pickles, fries
12oz NY Strip Steak
Cod was excellent crisp in outside juicy inside. Also had the 16 KC dry aged steak and it was unimpressive for the price.
The Pluckemin Inn is my go-to favorite for lunch or dinner, with friends or a romantic evening. The ambience is serene and elegant, the menu varied, and food truly delicious and memorable. Risotto creamy, pork entree tender, fish chips the best ever and I lived on Cape Cod! The staff is well-trained and attentive. Now if only I could replicate the brioche bread pudding at home! Ah, but I know where to go for it!
Beautiful day with my beautiful friend! Our first Day off together from our hectic nursing schedules! The ambiance was great! Service was spectacular! Food was delicious! We will be back!
Andres was spectacular as always. The Plucky
Congratulations for another wonderful dinner
Great service and food!
Excellent dining as always. The Pluckemin Inn never lets you down
Thank you again for a wonderful evening !
This restaurant never disappoints! The food, service, ambiance and wine are always on point.
Food was excellent as was the service. Tables were placed far apart and we felt very safe with all the Covid precautions.
Disappointed that there were no tasting menu options and we have enjoyed in the past. Food and service was good but not the experience we had expected from previous experiences at Pluckemin.
Another wonderful meal, enhanced by the usual excellent service that we always receive at the Pluckemin. Attentive, without being over-bearing ! Thank you !
The food and cocktails were very good. Shrimp appetizer and cauliflower steaks were delicious.
We ate inside although they have a nice outside dining area as well.. The restaurant is open now at 50% capacity so it was not overly busy, but to our disappointment, the service was poor. The waiter was inattentive, took long time to take our order, never checked to see how things were once served or if we needed anything.
To summarize, the food was very good but the service was not. And for the prices charged, both should be very good .
Dining on the new terrace was wonderful on a warm Thursday evening. About 1/2 - 2/3 of the tables outside were occupied, so clearly folks are enjoying the newly reopened outdoor dining option here. The food, as always, was very good. The Angus porterhouse, a special of the day, was so good - better than going to any steakhouse in the area by far. Service was excellent and though the dinner wasn't inexpensive, it was worth it and we can't wait to be back!
The food was OUTSTANDING! The service was not great. They seev
The only bad aspect of this meal was that it will be the last one I will have at the plucky for some time, as I was en route to the airport. Returning to Boston after visiting family for the holiday, we stopped to take advantage of the perfect early spring evening. We ate outside, and the setting was perfect with all tables adequately distanced. Our waiter, Luis, did a fantastic job attending to our table, and made sure that everything came out in a timely manner. Pictured here is my appetizer risotto with peas- a lovely spring dish that paired great with a glass of Sancerre. My family also had great things to say about the swordfish entree and the Plucky burger. It was such a lovely way to relax and spend time together as a family to cap off a wonderful holiday weekend. Thank you Pluckemin Inn, I can’t wait to be back on my next visit home!
Always a favorite place to dine. Service and food is excellent! We drive 45 minutes and well worth the drive!
The food was amazing and unique. The ambiance and service was perfect. I highly recommend the Pluckmin Inn.
Great meal & service
The food is excellent. Top notch.
Food was delicious. Service felt a bit rushed but was very professional.
Superior restaurant with great food and service. Highly recommend.
We had a wonderful evening, to celebrate our 30th anniversary. The staff was attentive and our meals were excellent. We will be visiting this lovely restaurant again soon. I highly recommend it. The Chef and staff get high marks in our book.
As always, the food at the Pluckemin Inn was outstanding and service was perfect: attentive but not hovering. We love that they try to use local ingredients as much as possible.
Very friendly and reliable staff. Food itself is absolutely phenomenal. Pluckemin Inn never fails to impress!
Celebrated a birthday and it could not have been a better evening.
As always the food and service are impeccable. We did not want the evening to end.
Thanks to all who made this a very special occasion.
Fantastic food in a wonderful environment, staff is attentive but not intrusive.
Outstanding food, presented and served with the excellence we always know we will receive at “The Plucky”. Thank you as always !
Excellent evening of dining. The food, drink and service were all fantastic.
Comprehensive safety protocols in place.
Good food, good service, beautiful presentation. Nice for special occasions
Delicious food and wonderful service.
Delicious as always
Food was Excellent. Service was great and ambience was warm and inviting. Will definitely recommend and go back!
Very great restaurant for a quiet, delicious, dinner with perfect “date night” ambiance
Outstanding meal to celebrate my husband’s birthday. The wine list is fabulous, something for every taste; and largely without the typical restaurant markup. Service was impeccable— available, attentive but not remotely intrusive. Delightful from start to finish. I highly recommend this restaurant (especially if you are a wine lover!!)
We found the perfect place to go and celebrate birthday! A beautiful place with the most impressive wine cellar. Everything from the ambiance to the food was perfect! Really tasty well prepared dishes served with love! The Silver cutlery was beautiful, the only point I will make is, when drinking a $250 wine, it don’t deserve the too small glasses! We will definitely come back!!
Always a favorite of ours! Great food, great service, and most of all great atmosphere.
As per ususal, wonderful experience. The service was outstanding as was the food Plating was appetizing and the dishes were outstanding. Flavorful and incredible tastes.
We have been going for years. It's the best in N.J.
Wonderful early Valentine's date night at the Plucky. Great service. Cozy atmoshpere. Fantastic wine and very good food.
The Pluckemin Inn is a beautiful and charming restaurant. The decor reminds us of restaurants in Nantucket. We sat near the fireplace, which was great. We had the tuna poke appetizer I had the salmon for dinner and my husband had the swordfish. Both dishes were delicious. The service was very attentive. We look forward to dining there again.
The service was impeccable, the food was delicious & the drinks were awesome. Really enjoyed a cozy dinner with my husband right by the fire place in the beautiful restaurant. Will definitely be returning soon!
The Pluckemin Inn offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (908) 658-9292.
The Pluckemin Inn is rated 4.8 stars by 1626 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.