Outstanding from start to finish. One of the most extensive wine lists I’ve seen in a long time. Definitely going back!

What a wonderful dining experience! The Pluckemin Inn will exceed all of your expectations- I highly recommended!

Food, service and ambiance are all excellant. As always, a great experience!!!

Always exceptional food in a great location for business meals. Appreciate the attentive staff especially the managers and tavern area service. A great spot for lunch or dinner - business or pleasure.

Terrific service and amazing food.

Food was excellent and the 50% off the wine on Fridays was a great plus.

Superb, as always. The service is beyond reproach.

Fantastic. I consider The Plucky as the best restaurant in NJ!

Loved the food and the service! Extensive wine list! I will be back!

Food and service are excellent, always a great place.

Terrific food, ambience. Worth another visit.

Incredible experience, first time and definitely planning on returning soon. Been to many other very nice restaurants but the Pluckemin Inn is top notch!!

Lunch is very good here. Has interesting choices and good cocktails; try the "plucky". Tuna Tartar is amazing and the Gyro perfectly seasoned. Brisket and rigatoni was also very good.

Very good food and service, the wine is very good too, a little bit of too pricey.

We had a lovely experience dining here for my wife's 50th birthday. We thoroughly enjoyed the tasting menu and the wine pairing took the guess work out of selecting. Our server J described each wine with enthusiasm and each one was as he said. We appreciated the chocolate birthday plate to cap off a perfect evening. We will certainly return.

As usual, the restaurant was superb. Food, service, ambience excellent. Never been disappointed. Our friends loved it.

I am always pleased with the food and service at the Pluckemin Inn. It is one of my favorite restaurants for special occasions.

Excellent wine list; delicious food, and gracious service. A treat for a special occasion or just a night out. The fireplaces add a touch of romance and comfort.

Delightful evening. There were four of us. We were seated at a perfectly lit table, lots of room, service very well paced. Food delicious. We had a driven an hour+ and felt it was worth every mile.

Favorite place. Great food, service. Unbelievable wine list.

On many visits, the food, service and ambiance has always been 5 stars all the way. Not inexpensive, but worth every penny. Will be back many more times in the future.

Dinner options are excellent. Choose from the Tasting Menu or A La Carte. Wine list is impressive with the top 200 offering reasonable priced selection. Octopus and sea bass was perfectly cooked. Cinnamon and apple dessert to die for. Service was great.

Very enjoyable and relaxing dinner, excellently prepared and professionally served. A true American classic dining experience you don’t find much anymore. It’s expensive but you get what you pay for: excellent ingredients skillfully prepared with a lovely atmosphere to truly enjoy your dining experience. Come to relax and enjoy the “ride” at your leisure.

Great for relaxing night out with family and friends

It's always a wonderful dining experience here at the inn.

The food was innovative and delicious. The Salmon was cooked perfectly.

Food and service always great here. Such a nice atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Unparalleled quality of food The selections were enticing and absolutely not mundane!
Service and ambience make this venue a dining experience.
Can't wait to return.

I took someone very special to dinner the day after Valentine's Day to enjoy a more peaceful, charming evening together. We enjoyed the ambiance of this quaint, charming restaurant. The service from the minute we stepped into the Inn until we left was superb; friendly, helpful but not overbearing. The food was prepared, presented & served at high standard.
We were first presented with a complimentary amuse-bouche that was creative & delicious. I ordered the raw oysters, a ragu fazzoletti & the NY strip steak. All were delicious!
Most of the restaurants I go to leave me wanting, or just plain forgetful. We left that evening with smiles on our faces, full bellies & a promise to return soon.

The food and service was great, wonderful wine selection and tasting menu is good if you don't know what to order. I went for a business dinner and the staff was very attentive and this is a great place to introduce yourself to a client.

I am a frequent diner at the Plucky. It never disappoints. The service and food are always exceptional as is their cocktails and wines.

Wonderful!

Fabulous wine list and that is the main reason to visit. The Pluckemin 200 is a list of wines that cost less than $75. And there are many great options. There is a separate list for those who can afford more. The food is well cooked and classic. Not much pushing of boundaries here but well executed. Staff are knowledgeable and appropriately attentive. The crowd here is typically 50 plus (in my experience). Roaring fire, French Syrah and good food. 2 thins up.

It was great we had a very helpful waitress and a seating by the fire..it was perfect..food was excellent..everyone had a great time

Overall experience was lovely - however, for price and current reviews, the dinner did not meet my expectation. Our table was very nice and what I requested, near the fireplace on second floor. The service was attentive, but not super. Wait staff did not know answers to menu questions and it was not consistent. Appetizers were highlight of dinner and they were excellent - grilled octopus tender and flavorful, winter salad beautiful presentation and again great flavors. Entrees were lacking in flavor - especially the winter risotto - bland and portion size extremely small - for "requested entree". Desserts good - especially the cheesecake, fluffy, great flavor and perfect size.

We went for the first time and don't know why we waited so long. It's fine dining in a comfortable, classy setting. Our waitress was very knowledgable on the menu. Two of the small plates with a small order of fish was perfect for one person. The beef tartar was decadent. The octopus was tender. Everything was delicious. Can't wait for our next special occasion to make another visit!

We had a wonderful time. Beautiful, romantic atmosphere . The food was outstanding from the appetizers to dessert. Our server Renee was lovely. Overall this restaurant is a standout in the area. We will definitely be back.

Food was excellent. Impeccable service. Great wine list. One of best restaurants in the area.

The only reason for the poor review was the price of the food for the value received.
The service and atmosphere were outstanding

Pleasantly surprised. I expected good, but this place was awesome. The service had it's flaws, but overall was good. The food was remarkable. The various tables were not too close to one another. They were able to accommodate my vegetarian wife and she is the tends to have difficulties. I had the pork and king crab salad. Left satiated even after dessert. Truly a gem and I will certainly return!