Awesome, as always!
Request Murph as your waiter!!!!
Best prime rib in Naples, along with a fresh, variety filled salad bar.
I'm looking forward to their upcoming move to a new location.
First time to this restaurant. Had heard and so many great things about the food, especially the steaks and prime rib. Decided to go for my birthday. Arrived on time for our reservation. Hostess was surely and we were told there would be a wait because there were no tables available. Hostess did not seem to care whether we stayed or left. Once seated, it was another wait for a server to come to take a drink order. We ordered. I had the prime rib, supposedly a house specialty, and my wife the roasted chicken. We went to the famous salad bar which was a disappointment. Better salad bar at Ruby Tuesday. My wife’s roasted chicken was good, well prepared and tasty but the prime rib was another story. Came properly cooked at medium rare but had absolutely no flavor. Worst prime rib I’ve ever eaten. This place is expensive and certainly the food doesn’t merit the price. First and last visit.
Prime Rib and Syrip with Angel Hair Pasta were well prepared and ejoyed.
One of our favorite places. Sorry they are closing this location. Hope the new one works in a place where restaurants have not done well.
Despite it's reputation as a prime rib/steak house I foolishly ordered halibut and my husband ordered salmon. Both were specials. Both were slightly overcooked. My cut of fish wasn't thick enough though taste was fine. We'll try again and concentrate on beef. Salad bar is nothing special.
Would love back extended for waterfront outside dining
Every year we go to the Pewter mug for our anniversary , this year we hit our 35th anniversary and when I made the reservation I told them it was our anniversary , I was pretty disappointed when it wasn't even acknowledged.
Service was terrible, food took forever to receive, waitress attitude was unacceptable, salad bar was only half stocked entire evening. Will never return.
Prime rib was really good - very tender. Would come back for it and hope it was always that good. Waitress was really pleasant.
Reminds us of our favorite comfortable
"supper clubs" in Wisconsin. NOT an elitist place - just lots of good food, service and value.
Our entrees were delicious! The prime rib never disappoints. The chef's red snapper special was extraordinary. Service was perfect. Altogether wonderful experience!
Have been going back the last three years. I use to visit in the 80’s and have rediscovered with my family. A comforting meal and a bang for your buck!
Our family was looking forward to the prime rib, and we were not disappointed. The prime minister cut was enough for most, but our teenage boy put away a Big Daddy.
As usual the dining experience was superb. The food was excellent, and the waitress was very attentive and amiable. The signature prime rib was as good as you find in Naples and the soup and salad bar is the best in Naples. My friends were very impressed. We will definitely be back as we frequent Pewter Mug at least twice a month.
Our reservation was late 8:00 Felt like they were ready to get out of there
After reading reviews I was hesitant but it was better than the last time
The service was very good. The soups were thin and salty. The steak was med rare but dry. I would not recommend this restaurant.
Delicious, as always!! Prime rib, medium-well, grilled - amazing!!!
Great food and a pleasant surprise in an area that doesn’t offer lots of options that aren’t really expensive
Casual and comfortable
Great soup & salad bar! Would definitely return here.
All prime rib lovers really need to come here for the beef!! You can pick your size and pick your style (traditional, blackened or grilled). We’ve had the traditional and blackened, both are excellent. The salad / soup bar is also very good. The only caveat is the outdated seventies decor but true beef lovers should not let that stand in the way of succulent prime rib...
Everything was great, we enjoyed the evening. Well will return.
Delicious food and plenty of it!!! Go there hungry!!! The roast beef is so delicious!!! Our server was on the spot! We will definitely go there again!
Good spot we enjoyed with friends
Excellent Prime Rib...nice salad bar...good deserts...everything you need for a full value meal.
The Pewter Mug is a must whenever we are in Naples!! Prime Rib is fantastic!! Old school salad bar is just what you need before diving into the delicious Prime Rib!! The service is always superb!!
I made reservation same day using OpenTable at 5:00PM and arrived a few minutes early. The bar opens at 4:30 but you can’t be seated at a table until the restaurant opens at 5:00 - we were promptly seated in order of arrival/check-in.
The soup and salad bars were outstanding. Prime rib was excellent. Service was perfect.
Food was excellent. Would return for prime rib
Always pleasant servers-good food....only point is that when you enter it smells musty...
We enjoyed our dinner. It was delicious.
We were a group of four and three of us had the Prime Minister which we all loved. Our service might have been a little slow but we didn't mind because we had good conversation going. In fact it seemed like we just about closed up the restaurant. We had desserts which we enjoyed. And always love the salad bar. My wife and I come here maybe four times a season. That might not seem often, but we go out to dinner very seldom...usually when we bring friends or relatives . We had Thanksgiving here last Nov. and that is always yummy. Also have brought our son and his family to the Pewter Mug and they always demand a dinner there when they are here. It is great for kids with the salad bar. It continues to be one of our favorite restaurants.
Our family is eating here number of times and it’s always fantastic
We enjoyed the Prime Rib prepared medium-rare to perfection. Salad Bar has always been to our liking.
We used to come here years ago with our parents. Went on March 16 2018 and when I called to confirm our reservation we made in open table they said they never got it. The honored the 6:45 PM reservation but after arriving 5 minutes early, we were not seated until 7:15.The staff who were seating us seemed very stressed and things seemed chaotic. Our waitress that night was excellent and the soup was good but everything else was subpar. There was no lettuce at the salad bar both times I tried to go up. I had the duck and I didn't finish as it was terribly dry. We were crammed in so tight that the wait staff had to turn sideways to get by our table. The meals offered on the menu were way overpriced for the quality of the food and the atmosphere.
There are too many nice places in that area to compete for my entertainment dollar for me to ever go back sorry
the food is really good service is good but don't come here if you want ambiance. lol
place hasn't changed in for ever
Very crowded and very noisy ! Roast beef not like it used to be ! Now a bit tasteless.
Don't know Dijon Mustard in this day and age ? WOW !!
A good meal at a reasonable price.