The Pewter Mug
Jordan made our evening. She was very personable. Prices were a little high but food good. No complaints
All ok except for some reason our original server Seth was removed and replaced by Tammy. She had too many tables and was very difficult to find all evening. Very frustrating.
Great as always.
Has the ownership changed? I'm surprised the prime rib I ordered even came out of your kitchen. I've never had such a fatty steak from your restaurant before and I've been there several times. The service was fine. The salad bar and soup were fine. Unfortunately, I come there for the prime rib and it was not up to your or my standards.
Wonderful experience. Food was delicious. Fantastic salad and soup bar.
Our first time at the new location of The Pewter Mug. The food was good, though not great. However, our experience was a positive one because our waitress Cindy was both attentive, efficient and nice. She made the meal a very pleasant evening. We will go back because of her.
Nice service, great salad bar and tasty food.
Outstanding service and great food. The salad bar is a meal in itself. Wonderful dining for a reasonable price.
The food was excellent!!! The best Prime Rib ever!!!! Awesomely fresh salad bar !! Mike was wonderful. We went twice in one week and will be back again soon!!!
Pewter Mug has been a steady, reliable restaurant for years. This time it was a disappointment. The restaurant was out of lettuce for the salad bar during dinner. How did that happen?
The young waitress was nice but not skilled in opening a wine bottle, serving wine or responding to concerns. The food was not up to the usual quality.
great prime rib just as advertised!! very nice salad bar!! great value!
Sad to say, was not “as remembered”. Restaurant in SWFL that doesn’t source Gulf Shrimp and doesn’t use butter or offer butter to customers (only margarine) doesn’t get another visit.
I have been going here for quite awhile and always had a wonderful meal, this time we sent back our prime rib ( too tough) was rushed by our waiter, and just had a horrible experience! Very disappointed
We enjoyed their Prime Rib & Lobster Tail. Very good salad bar & soups. Reasonable wine list. Excellent service from Cindy. This restaurant is moving soon to their new location.
We are two couples who go to Pewter Mug every Birthday and Anniversary for many years.
We have never had a bad meal and love the salad bar and the servers.
Very good salad bowl and soup offering. Chump sirloin with 8 steak fries = $23 !!! My wife's salmon was excellent but very lonely on plate by itself.....
Our server mike was great. Our whole family got the prime rib and we’re all very happy, it was delish.
Food was outstanding once again but the service was very slow. I would still return.
Old fashioned steak and salad bar, reminiscent of Steak and Ale. Very casual atmosphere. Salad Bar is excellent and freshness appreciated. Something for everyone!
Highly rated on paper, actually awful! The salad bar that comes with all dinners was low on everything- never replenished. The waiter must have had a bad day and was just short and angry. The prime rib and baked potato were good, but certainly not a top ten steakhouse like other reviews gave it.
Salad bar was best part of the meal. Ribs had good flavor. Beef stroganoff was bland. Prime rib was good, but again, like the stroganoff, lacked flavor.
They were out of a lot of food
Went for the prime rib . ( I guess they are famous for it) unfortunately they were all out when we got there at 7:15 pm.
If you are in to local old world favorites, I am sure you will enjoy this place.
• you like salad bars ? It was maintained and nice
• service adequate, waiter was tired of his job.
• apitzers were ok
• ordered rib eye steaks and fillets and they were cooked to perfection and OK!
• place needs a good remodel!
• Manager/owner was very nice
Lots of fabulous restaurants in Naples in the same price category. No wow factor whatsoever,
First time there. Food was very good service at the bar ad at the table was very good. Will go back again.n
This is the best steakhouse around. Enjoy the salad bar and the custom cut steaks. One of my favorites in SWFL.
Great restaurant for everyday dining - good food, good menu, friendly staff with moderate pricing.
Had a perfectly wonderful experience for my birthday! Everything was absolutely outstanding in Cuisine and freshness!
Consistently excellent prime rib with an always fresh salad bar and delicious soups. This is our favorite place for prime rib for my husband and salad bar for me. You will not be disappointed!
As always everything was wonderful. This is one of my favorite restaurants in Naples We have taken many of our friends there and are never disappointed. I always want to try something new, but land up with the prime rib. Hope the new place is as good as the old.
Good service, food was excellent and will definitely be back.
Our strip steaks and prime ribs were excellent. We all enjoyed the salad bar. Our waiter was wonderful. He was very attentive. If you are looking for a place with greats steaks and wonderful wait staff, pay a visit to the Pewter Mug.
Excellent value for money. Great soup/salad bar that is included with your entree.
Busy even off-season... make a reservation!
As usual, an excellent dining experience. When you have something good, you don’t change it and that’s the case here.
Hope your new location is as lovely as this one. We hope to be notified of a special happy hour before you close since I understand all the liquor has to go before the move...………….
Pleasant, good eats and great salad bar. Prices and service great. Relaxed atnosphere.
Prime Rib was excellent as always. Wonderful soup and salad bar. Looking forward to their new location this summer.
Parking was an issue, but we had reservations and even though it was packed, we were seated within 15 minutes. The food was excellent and the service was good. I love the salad bar. For the price, this is the best deal in town. Portions were huge and it was all so delicious. Best deal in town for fine dining in my opinion!! Had not been in 26 years and it's still amazing. Will definitely not wait so long to go back!!
Mix up with reservation. They said we book 4 seats at the bar. Certainly not with minors! While they did accommodate us, gentleman at the desk was less than pleasant.
Our prime rib was fatty .. It was Father's Day .. And prime rib is his fave.. Not so much this time