The Pewter Mug
No not really. We had Prime rib and a baked potato and it was excellent. However the salad bar was a big disappointment. Wilted lettuce, cheap toppings and a very limited choice of salad dressings. The bread station also was a disappointment, a choice of 2 types of sliced dried out bread. The good news is the service was very good, not rushed but just the right tempo. Overall I'd give it a fair rating but I would not recommend it.
Amazing salad bar and really good food. Will definitely go back!
Anniversary dinner for out of town guest.
We had great meals and we were essentially pleased to see the salad bar in its glory. My only complaint is that they need a dehumidifier to get rid of musty smell.
Prime rib was great
salad bar and food is second to none for the value and the quality
Good food, excellent service, great salad bar, a little noisy but not bad. Staff is great.
While expecting more ambiance based on website the food and service made us forget the ambiance. Prime rib was large and delicious and server Colleen was outstanding. Her personality, timing, wine presentation etc. were "fine dining" level. My wife has over 40 yrs experience in restaurant business including fine dining and for Colleen to get five stars from her is rare praise.
Great food great price!!!
They have ok early bird (4-6pm) specials where you save about 3-5$. But they have been consistently good for the many times we have gone there. It's hard to not fill up on their soup and salad bar, before the entrees come out. They never rush the entrees. I can't stand feeling rushed so I appreciate this, especially.
The ambiance lost a lot of its original charm and the main dining room can feel a little sterile but they have a side dining room dedicated to the old location that we haven't tried sitting in that could make a big difference. Their prime rib is why we go but their other items are very good and they almost always have some kind of off menu special.
Great atmosphere-Excellent food
Great food. The best prime rib anywhere.
Our experience was great, the food, waitress and our first time to the new location was not a disappointment.
Prime rib was fatty
The food value was exceptional. Really enjoyed salad bar, entrees and 3.50 wine. Waiter was great. We will definitely return.
Good food and service> we will return in the future.
Very impressed with the New location and changes made to Pewter Mug. Been a long time customer back to 1991. Always good but now it is even better. Our ribeye steaks were absolutely perfect.
Our birthday celebration was very nice. The food here is outstanding. Prime Rib as always was a hit as well as one person at our party had a hamburger which was excellent. One person got the steak sandwich with aux jus. We thought it was strange that it was different and better than what came with the prime rib. Service could have been a bit more attentive for a birthday celebration that I made sure to tell the hostess as well as Open table that I made the reservation through. The salad bar is outstanding. I've always said it is the best salad bar around. Overall it was a very nice birthday.
We love The Pewter Mug. Great bar and the food is consistently good. If you are looking for not to fancy, but great prime rib and great salad bar, this is the place. My favorite dinner is the chopped steak, sauteed spinach and a baked potato!
Decor could be better. Ribeye was good.
Dinner was wonderful. Had drinks at the bar first, bartender was awesome! Proceeded at the exact time of our reservation. Our server, Sammy, was very friendly very knowledgeable and awesome! My husband was dying for your prime rib. It did not disappoint. I ordered the scallops and they were perfect, as always.
Food was excellent! The noise level was a little high! Servers were friendly and warm! All and all a good experience!
Food is excellent and they are very flexible on substitutions. Very experienced, friendly wait staff.
We ate with friends on July 31 and our experience was exceptional. We were promptly seated at a great booth. Glinda was our servicer and she was wonderful! Informed us of happy hour drinks and other specials. We all were return customers so our selections were based on past orders. It was recommended that perhaps a blacken prime rib should be ordered a bit rarer...spot on. Another great night night at the Pewter Mug!
We loved the food, and Jeremy, our waiter, was excellent! Thanks for a lovely evening!!
Great service and food
OMG! I can't believe I fell into this dump. They took the old dump and moved it to a new building. Old nasty scuffed tables, old drab paintings, NO ambiance whatsoever. And the junk stacked off to the side of the hostess station was a nice touch...No, on to the food. My husband is a sucker for salad bars, so I obliged.....Set in the middle of a dining area is a long, institutional refrigerated salad bar, items different on each side, tomatoes chopped so large they were inedible, high cost items hidden on the ends when your plate would be full, an off to the side soup station , bread and cheese display. BORING, OLD concept that actually was better at the old site. Baked sweet potato overcooked, steak soso. $24 early bird dining, salad bar was 13.99 alone. Sweet Tomatoes chain does a better salad bar. Worst part for me, people lined up to get in...does no one appreciate good food anymore. I do and will not return to this dump that turned a beautiful venue into a swamp
Our waitress Cindy was wonderful and we like the new place better then the old location. Prime Rib, Rib Eye and Filets were all outstanding.
Best in town .........................................................
Went for the prime rib and was not disappointed.I would recommend this place to a friend and will be going back .
We have been customer for years. Their new location is far superior. Additionally, the new updates to cold plate cooler and new placement of soup area is a nice improvement.
Sissy, our server was excellent. She seemed to be there at just the correct times.
The food is always great.
Great food, awesome prime rib! Pleasant servers....superb salad bar. Would recommend and would come back!
Great food at a great price. The early bird menu is a real bargain, as are drinks at the bar during Happy Hour.
Awesome salad bar and delicious meal. I had the Tipsy Sslmon. It was perfect. My husband had the prime rib and it was done just right. Highly recommend.
Really great salad bar! Crab stuffed salmon was fabulous. Great happy hour drink prices.
This was very poor quality of food no matter what the price. We watched a waitress empty the bottles in the clean up area by drinking them!! It was not clean and there was a comment that they had run out of prime rib for our cuts of meat were not prime rib!!!
Food was very good. Decoration cheap and not so nice.
Steaks and Prime Rib was prepared as requested. Tender and tasty. Fabulous salad bar. Great staff. Thanks.
Prime rib was great as always
We really enjoy having Cindy as our server. She's the best!