The food is great! Really enjoyed our dinner out here.
At first we were brought to sit in the front which was nice but immediately the smell of smoke consumed us before we could even sit down. We asked to move to the back, dock side view, and we were much happier. There's no smoking inside but there's separate door access near the bar where people can smoke in an enclosed area outside and that's why we smelled it.
Still my favorite place to dine as long as we stay away from that side.
Absolutely fabulous the service the meal the manger and the owner came by to make sure our meal was perfect . Will go back very soon. Love it .
Loved this hidden gem in the heart of Patchogue!
The restaurant was loud. Although the food was very tasty, it could have been served much hotter. The dinner portions were on the smaller side. The bread pudding was served with a half scoop of ice cream which really seemed like nothing.
The food was pretty good, I think that the portion was rather small but I guess that’s what I should have expected for a prix fix menu. I felt bad for our waitress, she was dealing with an entire room of tables by herself, I guess they didn’t plan on it being so busy for restaurant week. The New England Clam Chowder was excellent, though I thought my jumbo shrimp were anything but jumbo. The chocolate chip bread pudding was amazing and was loaded with chocolate chips.
Everything was wonderful. The service was great and the food was excellent.
The service from Kim was phenomenal! She was attentive, energetic, knowledgeable and overall the best service we have had on Long Island.
Food was great, however noise level was very loud. Noise coming from a large table who were very loud.
One of our favorites. Great food!
If you enjoy seafood, please consider this restaurant. Super fresh selections and a wonderful and attentive staff. The restaurant has a great nautical flair. Thank you to their chefs and waitstaff for a flavorful and delicious meal. They were also sensitive to guests with allergies and cooked to order for us :)
Again the food was good. Watching the boat parade and having dinner is a great experience.
The food was great and we love the place, service was fine. If I had a complaint it would be that it took a while after we were sat to take drink order and while I was eating still they tried to take my plate. I had to explain I was still eating. But I still would recommend and we will be back.
Food was ok. Appetizers were good the lobster Won Tons were doughy sauces were average . seafood chowder was good . my husband got the French onion tasted like Manhattan clam chowder to him and he is a cook ..made up for that withbgis entree bountiful on the diavolo... I got the special surf n turf... Was alright steak wasn't done the way in had asked .. Was noisey as we were sat next to the bar .. Our server Sam was wonderful very attentive...
Outstanding food and service
Awesome food and place! Can't wait to go back!
Food and service were good. Will go back but not on a Friday night. Noise was way too loud.
Popular restaurant and I found out why! The food and service were excellent. From drinks, through appetizers, dinner and dessert, our entire party was impressed. Can't wait to return...
I suggest making a reservation because the 1st time I went it was closed for a party. The second time I went there was a wait. Finally the 3rd time I went I made a reset and was seated right away. The food was great. When it came time for the bill the waitress told me I had $40.00 left to spend on my Groupon. When I added up the bill on my own I was only $4.00 off. I feel I was mislead on how much I spent so I would spend more money. I highly suggest adding up your bill on your own.
I had the roast duck. It was two legs w/ thighs but no breast. You had no choice on how you wanted it cook. It came only one way which was slightly over cooked and dry. My wife had the scallops which were very good. We started with the tuna tartar and PEI mussels. Both were very nice. It was "steak night" Thursday and so very crowded and the service was a little slow. We arrived close to 7pm, had appetizers and entree only and didn't leave until 9:30. All in all it was a good experience.
We arrived before our time and were seated very quickly. Our table was inside looking out at the water. The noise level was very loud and it was difficult to have a conversation. We shared the baked clams appetizer. It was very bland except for an intense oregano flavor. The pork entree was just okay. The filet Mignon was cooked perfectly, but our baked potatoes were undercooked as well as the green beans in the vegetable medley. We were very disappointed. We have been to many a Happy Hour there, but would not go back for dinner.
It is a bit of a drive for us but we always enjoy our dining experience at the Oar
The food is good.but the prices have gotten out of control...
The meal was 99% superb, though the popovers served with the salad were tasteless. Odd, considering how good everything else was. I would reconsider those. Otherwise, don't change a thing.!
The location is a tad hard to find, thankful for the GPS. The food is really good and the service was good. The waitress forgot something we ordered and it never came. The cost is really expensive, we had 2 drinks, 2 soups and 3 appetizers and it was around $100. Definitely somewhere for a special occasion but not a general night out.
Service was extremely slow and server was disorganized. Had to order drinks several times. Server brought out food to another table with our food (but not all of the food for either table). Salmon was terribly undercooked, sent back and still raw in the middle. My friend ate only one bite and was ill an hour later. Just a terrible experience.
Many many other patrons there, so we probably just got a bad night.
We were celebrating our 27th wedding anniversary and asked for a romantic table. They honored our request. We were greeted with a anniversary wish. When we were seated they brought us a glass of champagne to start our celebration( on them). The food and service was great. Will definitely go back again. It was a wonderful evening.
Made reservation and it was closed! How can you take a reservation and not be open, very frustrating
Our first time there. We had made pre-theatre reservations for 7 people at 6:00pm. Our table was ready when we arrived and our waitress made sure we were served in time for us to make our 8:00 show time. Food was good and will certainly visit again.
Friendly staff, waitress went out of her way to serve us. Food was delicious and drinks were fun and creative, enjoyed the Long Island Mule. I had the chicken pot pie - very comforting and delicious. Husband had the strip steak - said it was wonderful - finished the full meal.
Great service and the food was very good.
Nice place, right on the water. Probably great for outdoor happy hour. Food was not as good as hoped. Bland, basic, disappointed.
Great atmosphere, great view, great food & of course a really great staff. Even if you have never been there before the staff & customers are so friendly you will feel like you've always gone there!
Good fast service. Tasty food and reasonably priced.
I made my reservation for Monday March 6 and received a confirmation. Friends had recommended the restaurant. I'm not from the area and I was looking forward to dinner there. Much to my surprise the restaurant was closed. It was a totally wasted trip and I was left without a place to eat. I was extremely disappointed. How can you accept reservations and send a confirmation for a restaurant closed on Mondays???
Was there on a busy Saturday evening recently and the service and food were excellent. One of my favorite places to eat on the island. Very happy with the gluten free options. The food is always presented beautifully and I love the special drink options. Love the music too!! Great place for a get together or first date.
Wow, never had this happen before...waitress returned to our table after we paid the bill and left her a 20% tip on the full amount (we had a groupon discount), to tell us we did not tip her enough! OMG! We were really shocked, flabbergasted actually. Food quality was only mediocre, prices were very high, everything alacarte. Not worth the experience. One of my friends ordered vodka on the rocks. When the bill came, after the waitress came to discuss the tip, we saw that the drink price was nine dollars with a three dollar surcharge. The surcharge was because it was vodka straight up and no juice added. In our experience, that was ridiculous! If anything, they should just charge $12 for the drink. Overall the restaurant left a bad taste in our mouth,no pun intended, and we probably will not return for a very long time...if ever.
All great but they let the table next to us drink straight vodka shots and if course one if the 10 fools emptied his stomach AT THE TABLE AND THEN JUST WALKED OUT A BACK DOOR. Staff needs to learn to shut people off, its a restaurant not a night club. Ruined my dinner.
Nice easy going place. Food tasty and many different offerings.
Attended a fund raiser on 2/19 an figured we would try it for dinner.
Enjoyed our evening and look forward to returning in summer....maybe by boat!