We usually go on Friday, but decided to go Thursday this week. We had the escargot, as always, and it was so delicious. We love the bread. We got there for happy hour and house wine, chardonnay, is $3.50, an delicious. We had the chicken Sergio. It was amazing. For dessert I had a bananas foster martini. It was all so delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant. It has amazing delicious food, elegant ambiance and the whole staff is nice, and wonderful. An very helpful.
We always have the escargot. Its amazing. So us the hoyse Chardonnay. The service is always wonderful. Christi the bartender is fabulous.
This restaurant is amazing. The service and food was outstanding. And the blackberry cobbler is best I have ever had!
The lamb was phenomenal. The filet mignon was a little dry.
Escargot was amazing. Christi bartender was awesome an one of the owners, Chad. They are all nice an awesome. Soo is the fpod an drinks. They have a great happy hour too.
Place was quaint. Didn't have many customers for a Friday night. Food was just average and was only warm when brought to our table. For the price $135, I expected better service and better food. I've had better steaks at the chain restaurants. It was my 1st visit and my last.
Always a great dinner and experience. My go to local date place.
We had the escargot as usual. It is so delicious. The best escargot I've ever had. We got there in time for happy hour, the $3 house chardonnay. Is delicious. Christy the bartender is always awesome..
Weve been several times an always have the escargot, which is the best I've ever had. An we had the salmon with mashed.sweet potatoes. Which were amazing. Happy hour prices are awesome. An.so is the house chardonnay. This place is awesome. I highly recommend it.
We had escargot, which I always get here, and I love it. Theres is the best. We made it in time for happy hour, which we had the house chardonnay, which was $3.50 a glass. We also had a salad and chicken, picatta , I think. It was alll so delicious....... for dessert key lime pie. Was all so amazingly delicious. The owners were there, they are so nice an welcoming. The ambiance is perfect. I love this restaurant an highly recommend it.
The service was medium - not exceptional as we sat with empty wine glasses for quite a while before being asked if we wanted another. The food was good, but again not exceptional. We consider ourselves "foodies" always looking for great places to meet our friends at and we were checking this place out as an option for our next group get-together. We will not, however, suggest this to our group. Considering the price, I don't feel that the service and food lived up to it.
Food was excellent, service was excellent however a large party convened & it got loud... fortunately
we were almost thru with dinner, so we got out just in time....
Excellent service and one of the best rack of lamb I've ever had.
Overall a great evening. Service with Angelo was great. Prime rib great also. The seafood New Orleans was a little disappointing. The scallops were tough and shrimp so-so. Next time I will do prime rib. Prices are a bargain for all you get!!
Service was not good. Only one waiter who seemed more interested in speaking to the people at the bar than waiting on the tables. There were only 4 tables with patrons. We had to finally ask the girl bussing the tables to let the waiter know we were ready to order. Took forever for him to come back to refill drinks, etc. my daughter asked for more rolls and we never got them
We love going to the Hilltop. It is a place where we love to bring friends and family. You can actually have a conversation around dinner and hear one another. The atmosphere, service and food and always wonderful!
It was a wonderful experience . Staff was super friendly and the food was awesome and the atmosphere is beautiful I highly recommend this place. It is a beautiful old looking home with a bar area, And beautiful area for outside wedding ceremony overlooking a Koi pond, a glass sun room dining area also over looking the pond . There are many other large rooms to host a party, wedding reception or a large gathering. This was a gem hiding in Orange Park. They say has been here 30 years. And who knew there was a hill in Jacksonville. LOL
We had not been to the Hilltop in a while. We were very pleased with everything from drinks to dessert. The quality of the food was great. We were treated like family, thank you Angelo, and will return soon.
Thank you so much for the 5 Star Review and all your wonderful words. We greatly appreciate this and we are so happy you enjoyed yourself. We look forward to your next visit! Sincerely, Stacey Martorano Manager/Event Coordinator 904-272-5959
We enjoyed our meal very much. It had been a couple of years since we had been and it was great to see nothing has changed. The food and the service was great!
We went for Mother's Day brunch, overall was plenty of food and good layout. Only minor complaints, the desserts weren't labeled so it was difficult to determine what each one was; also, prime rib ran out shortly before the last seating, and there was a 20 minute wait before more was available. Better planning would have made for a more enjoyable experience, but its definitely something we'll try again in the future.
After 30 plus years of enjoying the Hilltop, it remains a jewel in the crown of Orange Park.
Food was fantasic and plentiful. The grounds are gorgeous. Angelo, our server, was amazing!!
Parking was terrible. Your website did not say it was a buffet. Felt the buffet lacked
uniqueness for the cost. Some in our party thought it all excellent.
Wonderful experience. The food and service were great. Love this place.
Sorry, just not a fan. Shrimp was terrible, hard. The omelet station was the b st but that’s a lot of money for an omelet. Need some people checking for refills on dishes.
The building was probably nice in its day but it is run down and not well kept. The food was marginal at best with a semi'tough NY strip. The service was terrible. The food was brought out and set on a stand feet away while we looked at it waiting for our server to serve it to us. My wife had to take my glass and find a waiter to ask for a refill.
The reviews on Yelp gave this place 4.3 out of 5. We just didn’t see why? My wife ordered Filet Oscar style and the crab meat was burnt and nasty, and the bernaise sauce was like custard. My steak was excellent, but I got collard greens as a side and it looked like canned spinach. This place is absolutely beautiful, but we wouldn’t go back.
Great Food, Great Service, Great Scenery!! Hubby and I will be back!
Came to celebrate my birthday with family and friends, first time there and was impressed. Loved the building, grounds, atmosphere, food and our server, Angelo, was excellent. He gave us history, descriptions of food and was generally informative, polite and not intrusive. Also appreciated the piece of cake he gave me to bring home. We will definitely be back!
Very slow service....
Food was great ... have been before and service was better
There were 2couples eating 4 different meals. Each one of us loved the food. The atmosphere was wonderful. We have found our new favorite restaurant.
Hello DavidH, Thank you so much for the 5 Star Review and very kind words. We are so happy you found your new favorite restaurant! We look forward to your next visit and getting to know you better! Sincerely, Stacey Martorano Manager/Event Coordinator 904-272-5959
This was our fourth visit. All were 5 star. The servings are large and presented nicely. The servers are polite and attentive. It is nice to go to a restaurant where you can carry on a quiet conversation.
Hi TomM, Thank you so much for your visits here as well as the 5 Star Review. We appreciate your kind feedback and look forward to seeing you again! Sincerely, Stacey Martorano Manager/Event Coordinator 904-272-5959
As always the food and service was great. The price and value are totally matched
Hi ara1234, We are so happy you enjoy each visit with us. Thank you so much for your very kind words and 5 Star Review. We look forward to seeing you again soon. Sincerely, Stacey Martorano Manager/Event Coordinator 904-272-5959
Great food and atmosphere, and they make a good martini, my favorite restaurant in Orange Park for an upscale but casual meal
Good afternoon MichaelS, Thank you so much for the 5 Star Rating! We sincerely appreciate your feedback! So glad you are happy with your Martini...Kristi is an amazing bartender! We look forward to your next visit! Sincerely, Stacey Martorano Manager/Event Coordinator 904-272-5959
This is the second time I have dined at your establishment and I totally Love it!!!
The service and food were great. The menu had good options and there were a lot of great specials to choose from.
Quaint old place. Good comfort food. Staff very friendly but rushed and lacked training. Good value for the money
Address is incorrect on Open Table. Nice atmosphere overall. Live piano was cool. Crab dip was delicious. Combo seafood was good. Pork chop was dry. Caesar salad had bitter yellow greens. According to the waitress, it's always that way. Recommended changing that. A little too pricey for the quality.
Dined there for Valentine's Day. Pleasant ambiance. Excellent meals and good service. Very enjoyable evening.
Went for Valentine’s Day where there was a special menu. Appetizers were amazing with the pork ossa bucco and coconut shrimp. The she-crab soup was delicious and I wish I could have bought a gallon of it. Main entree was crab stuffed Chilean sea bass and then there was a dessert sampler. It was a perfect valentines dinner date with great food, great service and great ambiance .