The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn
Our famed Sunday Brunch has been the proud recipient of the Asbury Park Press, Readers’ Choice Award for Best Brunch since 1996. The Brunch is available Sundays from October through mid-June. On Easter, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Thanksgiving, and Christmas we offer a seasonal and more extensive Brunch for our guests to celebrate their special holidays; reservations are required.
Wonderful food and service
best place for a long lunch No rush. Waitresses are great
Wonderful dining room on the river..a definite must!
Always reliable with outstanding food and service in a beautiful setting.
Outstanding service, food, and view! The place to eat when family is in town.
The dining room is always a safe bet for an elegant environment and good food. The views of the river are fantastic.
Always good here, decent food and excellent service.
I had hoped for better food... it was to average for the money. Service was good but only 3 tables were filled...
Why ask if it’s an occasion on the open table form???
It was an Anniversary... so???
Happy Hour at the bar is a better deal
Excellent food and exceptional service.
Quiet especially considering there were lots of bridal showers going on.
It is our favorite go to restaurant
Nikki was terrific- great evening- thanks for bubbly- nice touch!
Our Server Nicole was excellent as usual. The air conditioner was too low when we arrived, a little chilly. We mentioned it to Nicole and the maintenance man came and turned it down. Thank you Nicole!!
Service was terrific. Only flaw was in the reservation I asked to not be seated at the window and the hostess took us to a window table. When I asked to move she was very accommodating.
Food, ambience and especially service was great! We were not rushed giving us ample time to enjoy our food and guests. Thanks!
Dinner menu too limited although what we had to order was great
Nelson is a good waiter. The food was very tasty. Portion was a little small. Wine was over priced.
I met here for a business meeting. The service was exactly what I would have hoped for. Attentive but not at all intrusive. The Braised short ribs were truly amazing. Not even the butter knife was needed. Thank you!
The food was terrible and the waiters were confused and brought us the wrong drink, wrong order, and seemed unorganized. The best item I had with my dinner was my cappuccino. Although the view of the water is beautiful, the befuddled service and lack luster food were not worth the price.
Great service and food as always
We wanted a quiet place for a dinner meeting. It was beautiful, the food was very good and the dining room was very quiet which is exactly what we were looking for. It was perfect dinner. Thank you.
Excellent meal. Very relaxing. The food and service was outstanding. Beautiful view. Highly recommended for a relaxing, excellent meal.
The lighting in the dining area needs to be dimmed. The recessed high hats especially. It’s a beautiful space lit like a hospital room.
Love the location and the ambiance of the room. Appreciate the old school feel. Piano player was outstanding!
Food was well prepared but the soup and entree' should have been served hot (temperature wasn't hot enough).
Food is terrific and the service is great. Nothing like sitting and looking out on the water. We truly enjoy our lunches there.
The hostest was able to get us in even though our appointment is at 1:30pm. She accommodate us. That's excellent Customer Service
The Molly Pitcher is always a wonderful dinner experience.
It was a beautiful evening. At first we thought menu to be pricey but the quality of food was worth it.
This was the Valentines prix fix menu. The meal was good, but not great. The dessert however was very disappointing. Vaguely cute for Valentines Day, but much less than the quality of an average bakery at best. For the occasion and the meal the dessert left you feeling let down.
Great food and ambiance; will definitely go back.
Wonderful service and beautiful view of the river.
Can't say enough about this place. Had the Cobb Salad, and French Onion Soup, food was excellent as always. Service was great
Very disappointed in quality of meal. My beet salad had no flavor at all, not any sweetness. The Lobster cocktail was average very small pieces. Five in our party ordered the filet mignon, the most expensive dish on the menu, I might add. It tasted very bland not at all up to a meat lovers expectations. My husband mentioned was that really filet?? The soggy mushrooms and strange risotto accompaniments were disappointing. If the chef noticed, 4 of the steak dishes were 1/2 eaten. My husbands partner ordered the Lobster pot pie which had no lobster in it. The chef added some after the fact!
It was a retirement dinner for my husbands office manager. I did not complain at the time, but I am calling the hotel manager tomorrow. I have eaten many times in the dining room especially for “special occasions”. This was certainly not what I expected.
Service was good. Food was Excellent. Beautiful place. A little pricey, but worth it. Highly recommended
We have dined here any number of times. The food is always tasty and perfectly prepared. The service is impeccable. The dining room has a splendid view of the marina and the Navesink River. This establishment offers a most pleasant dining experience.
Apparently you need reservations for the lounge too. The bar area manager rudely ushered us away from a table in the cocktail lounge when we arrived early for a pre-dinner cocktail. When this behavior was brought to the staff’s attention we were told that a manager would stop by our table to discuss. No manager found the time to discuss.
Dinner: The limited menu was even more limited when two of our party ordered the lamb shank we were later told there was only one left.
Susan, our waitress in the dining room, was very pleasant and provided excellent service.
Continue the great food and service, love the Molly and all it’s class. My wife and I will soon return.
Thank You, Mr. and Mrs. Braccia
A wonderful way to celebrate dinner with friends. Waiter (Jorge) was exceptional. Would absolutely dine here again. A great place to celebrate birthdays and anniversaries.
We were celebrating my sisters birthday and it was just wonderful
We went to the Molly Pitcher to celebrate my wife's birthday. The ambiance is magnificent as is the view of the Navesink River. The dining room is beautiful and the food is without equal. The chef made our occasion especially memorable. All in all a remarkable time.