The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Molly Pitcher Chicken Pot Pie
Our Take on the Classic
radish, celery, red onion, citrus vinaigrette, micro greens
Molly Pitcher Burger
House Blend Burger, Cheddar, Blue or Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, French Fries
Great ambiance, wonderful delicious food and the service was excellent! Absolutely enjoyed a wonderful family dinner! Highly recommend!
Husbands 75th Birthday
Always enjoy having a meal at Molly Pitcher. Can always could on good food and serve along with a great view.
Wonderful experience at MP for a birthday dinner. The service was great, the food was delicious and we can't wait to go back!
Fabulous menu and wonderful service at the Molly Pitcher! The restaurant ran like clockwork to make our New Year’s Eve dinner spectacular!
The menu always contains new items as well as old favorites. Preparation is superb. Service is always competent and considerate if not always prompt. The view of the Navesink is great. Spacing of tables is such to make for comfortable dining. The experience is well worth the price.
Beautiful good food good service. Clean everyone wearing masks
Despite the fact that I live around the area and have driven pass Molly Pitcher a zillion times, this was my first patronage to this historic Inn. We went for lunch on this past Christmas Eve, (actually it's better to avoid the dinner crowd and the service tardiness) there is nothing negative to say about this place. The view from the dinning room towards Navesink River is second to none, even though dinning out on the deck is prohibitively cold and the landscape lacks the greenery of other seasons. The food is sumptuous and adequate; I ordered the American Chowder and Lobster Roll and between the two, I guess I was served the equivalent of two lobster meat. My sister order the Skirt Steak and it was tasty and cooked just right. After the meal we walked around a bit to take in the ambience of this old English style Inn. I do recommend this place and is worth a visit.
The evening meal and service was amazing
Came to Molly Pitcher Inn at suggestion of cousins who live in Red Bank - and they joined us for brunch on Sunday. We all enjoyed our food - especially the sausages.
Coffee was very good although the milk pitcher dribbled -we all had difficulty pouring milk into our coffee cleanly.
I had a couple of other quibbles: 1) the toast was not warm enough to melt butter when it reached us; 2) the hash browns amount seemed skimpy. The table service was friendly and helpful….and the view was lovely.
Lovely holiday lunch. Ambiance and food delightful. Service erratic. Overall positive experience
The hostess could not have been more accommodating when I requested a corner table to assist a hearing impaired guest at our table. She was wonderful and started the evening by making us feel taken care of.
Virginia our server was excellent! Very professional and accommodating to our order requests. Beautiful view even after sunset. Special dining experience
Great ambience and menu selection. Service terrific.
Had a lovely business holiday lunch here. We were seated right at the window with great views, had wonderful French onion soup, salads, entrees and desserts. Service was great. Highly recommend.
Ultimately the seafood risotto saved the experience. Very loud space, service not so great but not sure if that was due to backup in the kitchen? Entrees took an hour to come out after salads, but one entree was so spot on it saved the day. The chicken was supposed to be stuffed with spinach and cheese but seemed to be stuffed with…stuffing? Table of two and bizarrely our bread basket was comprised of a single roll. Even when we asked for more bread; another single roll would be furnished.
We had a wonderful time at the Molly Pitcher Inn last night after a showing of the Nutcracker- it was a perfect way to end the night. The food was delicious and our waitress, Virginia, was incredible- she was attentive, kind, and answered all of our questions. We love the Molly Pitcher Inn now.
Lovely ambiance of the holidays, great service and food. Enjoyable experience.
George provided beyond perfect service. Cheese plate was a great appetizer. Salmon with creamed leeks and lentils and roasted chicken were all cooked perfect. Red wine Risotto with the chicken was just ok.
A wonderful holiday dinner date with my husband. Everything was great!
Service great food was nothing special view there is awesome we were 1 of 3 tables out of many but they had us at a table with an obstructed view- so was super disappointed
Beautiful view and decor. Perfect place for holiday brunch!
The Molly Pitcher Inn, being a land mark, follows the tradition of the season. Brightly decorated and river views is one of the reasons all tables were occupied by happy faces at lunch time. Food and service were, as usual, very good. Can't go wrong if seeking a dining experience with special touches.
Beautiful dining room overlooking the river. Food was delicious and served hot and fresh. Always enjoy the elegant atmosphere of this grand hotel.
Good service, ambience, and food great!
Service great. Food sub par. Shrimp was great, but sausage stuffing was 95% bread with one Nickle sized piece of sausage - which was tasteless. Carrots dry. Disappointed. The pie for dessert? Couldn’t cut crust. Hard and dry. With tip paid $180 for 2 person meal. This was Thanksgiving dinner. Of course location was great. Rest rooms clean and well appointed. Parking adequate.
We had a wonderful dinner with my newly engaged daughter and her fiance. Everyone enjoyed their meal from the cheese board starter, the pasta carbonara to the perfect ending of creme brulee! The service was very good and we will be sure to return.
seated next to a large birthday party with children. got a little noisy.
What a beautiful morning to spend at the Molly Pitcher . The dining room was lovely , peaceful and inviting . Excellent coffee !!!! Waffles and French toast excellent !!! Service excellent ! Thank you we will be back
The ambiance was nice and the staff was friendly but the food was horrible.
We had a great time. The food was excellent and we felt very comfortable there. Great service and great ambiance
Run to Molly Pitcher for dinner, got married there and go every chance possible for dinner and celebrations. Best place! My happy place.
The view of the Naversink was beautiful. Waiter was very attentive. He let us order a drink and settle in before we order the food. Food was delicious and the portions were a good amount. Dining room was elegant. Will be going back
Wonderful service, atmosphere and food.
Historic Hotel in Red Bank NJ with a beautiful water view, Great restaurant with
both Food and Service. Fantastic outdoor seating during the summer months.Great location also for weddings.
Had a table with a beautiful view of the Navesink River. We were thrilled to have a bald eagle fly over to entertain us! Everyone's meal was outstanding, especially the signature chicken pot pie. A delightful experience at an elegant, upscale restaurant.
Waitress was very friendly
n helpful along with bar
Very nice. Good service good food
Food was good not great - fire alarm goes off in middle of dinner all had to leave dinning room. Let back in but never told what happened. No one covered food or offered to heat it. Waiter was slow I asked what was the problem and his answer was we don't want to rush you. I said thanks but it's been a long time and we would like our food. We observed he seemed to be the only waiter for over 10 tables.
The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (732) 747-2500 ext. 520.
The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn is rated 4.7 stars by 757 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.