We would definitely give this restaurant a second chance, even though our first experience was not great (the salmon gave my wife an upset stomach and my hamburger was just too drenched in mayo). But there are other menu items that look good and the place is fun and lively, with an attractive decor and good service. Ask for a quiet corner if a vibrant bar scene is not your thing.
We celebrated a birthday & the staff was fabulous! Service was superb; friendly & attentive. The food was excellent with the defect ambiance of Saratoga.
Could not have asked for a better night out. The food and staff were amazing, absolute professionals who didn’t miss a beat. We will definitely be returning for more fine dining!
This has become our new "go to" restaurant!!! We love everything about it ; from being seated by a very friendly hostess, to always attentive servers, to great food and beverages and the ambiance. Wish I had discovered this sooner :)
Always great food and great service. We come here quite often and never had a bad experience
Love this place. Top notch food and it’s our go to place. They always have a booth for frequenting locals.
Local GEM. Always delicious! Carol Ann and Lawrence make us feel at home.
Love! Service with a smile! Cozy! Yummy! Great local spot..... so lucky to have a place like this so close to home!
Have been there twice so far and each time the food is outstanding! Service was great since we kept adding on to our party and our waitress couldn't have been more accommodating. Would definitely recommend eating here!
Excellent service and food was great
This was not the first time we ate at the Brook Tavern. Had an early dinner 5:30p.m. on a Saturday night during January. Hostess was very friendly. We sat in a booth which was cozy. Waitress was courteous and competent, was not pushy. Food was very good and ample portions. House wine seemed adequate. Chose not to have dessert but the coffee was fine.
Pretty good value overall. Solid restaurant would recommend!!!
The Brook Tavern is our go to restaurant. The food, service and atmosphere are superb. Weekday specials can't be beat. My Marine son ordered the full rack spare rib dinner (he eats a lot), he had a hard time finishing the whole rack. My wife ordered the hamburger, medium rare, cooked perfectly and she looooved it. I had the fish & chips, I took most of it home since it was sooooo large and I had the French onion soup, delicious. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu. Compliments to the chef.
food good good value only I was disappointed in they're famous crab cake compared to past in it was a little light on the crab meat heavy on the bread
Food is always very good and they always have interesting specials. Love this place!
As usual the tavern service was great. The french onion soup we both had was very good as was the bread. My wife is a filet person the the tenderloin medallions were cooked perfect and tasted great. There were 2 challenges however. The crispy 1/2 chicken was way undercooked. The appearance was a pale white. The dark meat was nearly raw but the breast was cooked. So the filet was a 5 and the chicken a 2. I debated sending it back but I didn’t want her and I to dine seperate. Also the mashed were done all prior to service as they were dark , very pasty and about 100 degrees. We had a reservation for 8:30 so it was late. None of this will turn us off from going back as it is usually much better.
We always have a fantastic meal at Brook Tavern. It is such a lovely, cozy, warm neighborhood place with high quality, creative food.
The atmosphere, the food and the staff were all amazing! Everything we ordered was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!
Great ambience, great service and delicious food. Highly recommend
Great service. Food was a disappointment.
We had a great night with the warm and welcoming staff.
Great service and staff very friendly and inviting....however our steak & burger were very salty ...though won't stop us from going back and trying something else.
All great! Everyone enjoyed their meals, the wine, the atmosphere,...
Awesome food and staff. Great atmosphere. We’ve always had great service and food here.
What a great restaurant. Great food and great service.
Great evening my with great service. All the staff were helpful and friendly.
Has a real tavern feel. Food is excellent for what it is. Not a choice for fine dining, but if you are looking for good food in a casual, fun atmosphere the Brook Tavern is a great choice.
Good food and good service, never been unsatisfied
Ok from the moment you enter, everyone is so warm and friendly. Live music playing in the bar was amazing. Agatha was so so sweet and chatted with us several times to make sure we were happy. Food was amazing!!! We will be back.
Love Wishing Well and Brook Tavern! The food is great at both restaurants.
We find Brook Tavern to be friendly, fun, and the food is delicious. Two of us had the salmon which was excellent, one had the chicken which also was good but slightly over cooked in parts and one person had the burger which was “just right”. The service was very good. Almost too attentive for four people who are trying to catch up but that is not a big complaint. Just maybe one or two too many interruptions into an enthusiastic conversation.
We love this restaurant. We moved here 3 months ago and it has evolved to be our favorite. I wish your bar area was larger. I guess that is my only real complaint. Love the music on Monday night.