We had a very good dinner. On Sundays they have oysters for $1 each. I then had the prix fixe dinner. I chose the Caesar salad and the moules frites. Both were delicious.
Delicious food and great service I would highly recommend this restaurant
Amazing sservice, Max is the best! The food is also outstanding!
Wait staff can use some training, but overall a great night out.
Great birthday dinner. The Wednesday night lobster specials can't be beat. So fortunate the birthday fell on Wednesday.☺️🎉 My whole steamed lobster was not as tender as on previous occasions but still tasty and the sides (fingerling potatoes and haricots very) were delicious! Husband had the cod which he loved. Friend had lobster garganelli. She was impressed that it was not glue-y which often happens with creamy pasta sauces. It was her first time at the restaurant and she is looking forward to going back. We all had a different desserts and they were all good. The management was nice enough to comp a dessert for the birthday boy. All in all, a terrific meal. It was relatively quiet which we much enjoyed.
great tasting food and very friendly and professional staff. Kid friendly as well!!!
One of the best restaurants in Sag Harbor.
Never a disappointment. Quality food, service and staff.
Usually very good but on this night Service was slow, waited 45 minutes between courses ....
Filet was over cooked and very dry
Great food and price fixed menu
Great new year eve dinner. Food and service excellent as always!
We be of the top restaurant s in the Hamptons
My favorite restaurant in Sag Harbor for sure and one of the best in the Hamptons. Excellent delicious food, always great ingredients, generous portions, wonderful attentive service. I'm always pleased by the overall experience. Since I'm rather particular and often disappointed by restaurants - my review makes Bell & Anchor stands out even more.
We absolutely love The Bell & Anchor. We dine here any time we are in town and are never disappointed. The food is consistently delicious and the wait staff is always on point and pleasant.
Love this place, oysters perfect, food incredible. Great creativity and awesome wine list to boot.
Great food, wait staff, atmosphere, and management!!
Table location could have been better but every thing else was very good.
Wonderful food, impeccable service and just an overall fabulous experience. Highly recommend!
This was recommended to me by a merchant in Southampton Village. I have tried most of the better restaurants in the Southampton, Bridge, Sag Harbor area and was really impressed with Bell & Anchor. Everyone's food was excellent and the service was also very good.
Great meal. Beautiful space with solid service.
Great food and the host Max is very friendly and helpful.
Consistently good! Go here often and always look forward to it.
Love it here - food and service are always good and chef accommodates everyone's food issues seamlessly. It's great for a casual dinner with friends or family. Specials can be a bit pricey though, so be sure to ask before ordering.
Nice, friendly atmosphere and excellent oysters and creative farro risotto. The wine selection was also excellent. Will definitely be back!!!
Bell & Anchor is a very special place. From the front of the house to the service and excellent food!!!!
It is very wonderful and of course we will be back many times.
This restaurant never disappoints me!! Always great.
This is one of our neighborhood go to restaurants.....reliable for anything from fresh seafood to a burger. It is consistently reliable though not very exciting. The menu varies very little with the seasons or year to year. The people couldn't be nicer or more helpful. The tables are comfortable...noise level can get loud as this popular restaurant fills up.
Absolutely fabulous! Best meal & service in the Hamptons!
Waitress did not tell us about the specials. Shrimp cocktail was on the online menu, but we were told that shrimp was no longer available.
We ordered two lobster dishes, lobster Cobb salad and a pasta with lobster. Each had about 3 little pieces of the top of the claw.
Also, the bread was stale.
My party of four was warmly welcomed and shown to a table by the window. We all had a different seafood dish and all were excellent. Service was impeccable and the ambience was friendly and smartly casual.
We have been there many times and each time our experience has been excellent.
Exceptional food & service.......one of our party was invalid in wheelchair and the staff were just beyond thoughtful and accommodating.
Always excellent. Great service, great food. Will be back later
I can't recall when I could label every dish 5 stars. 3 of us ordered a dozen each Montauk Pearl oysters ($1 each!!!). The “Old School” Lobster garganelli w/ Corn, Basil & Saffron Cream was wonderful. (I had similar, smaller, much less satisfying dish at Almonds the previous week). I ordered it on the Prix Fixe ($37), while my wife ordered the smaller portion ($20) and they happily split my delicious arugula salad. I tasted my friend's pork chop and I will probably order it next time. His wife assured us the salmon was excellent. The four of us shared 2 desserts, both first rate. Wine and beer around and I had a generous Irish Coffee. At $130 a couple including tip ... excellent price to value in the Hamptons. The noise level hinders conversation. Service was good, but somewhat harried.
Good food, fresh ingredients, good wait staff, lively atmosphere, kid friendly, varied cocktails and wine list, $50 + pp
Spectacular view. Good good.
Wonderful restaurant and beautiful view of the harbor and boats. The BEST dining experience I have had in the Hamptons in years.
Bell and Anchor is one of our steadfast go to restaurants.....The menu does not change much; the food is consistently good as is the service. We enjoyed burgers.....love the jicima slaw and burgers cooked perfectly every time.
We love and have know David, the owner for many years. This is a homerun!
The food was outstanding here!! And our waitress was attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Very nice meal!! Would definitely go back!! Also enjoyed not battling downtown traffic on a Saturday night!