Broiled Whole Bronzini (Mediterranean Fish)
Pasta & Fagioli
These are wonderful people it’s like going to family
This is definitely my new favorite restaurant. The owner is very caring and hands on. The chef is incredible.
A great find! We stopped on a whim and so happy to have found a new favorite place to dine!
Service is so friendly, informative and inviting. Cocktails and food were delicious and generously sized. Staff recommendations were spot on.
All staff were inviting and accommodating, anything anticipated was attended to.
Happy to have found a new favorite restaurant!
Always a great meal and service.
Attentive service coupled with a large and varied menu. A great choice for elegant Italian dining.
Linguine with shrimp and clams, stuffed artichokes, calamari, beet salad all very good.
Tesoro is a terrific restaurant. We ordered a variety of appetizers, all were delicious. Same for the entrees. Our waiter, Joe was great, very honest & friendly. Deserts were also good. We look forward to a return visit. 5 Stars !!
It was my wife’s birthday and a wonderful restaurant to celebrate the owners make you feel as though you are family
Our party of 6 was so happy to choose Tesoro as our first restaurant, post pandemic regulations.
How can you not love a place where the owner and his wife greet you like family.
The loyal wait-staff are great at presenting the specials and always accommodating if there are special requests.
The food is always spot on delicious.
The ambiance is always uplifting and fun.
Thank you Tony and staff.
Food was delicious and abundant
Waitstaff was courteous and attentive
Bar tender doesn’t know what tequila they have. Was also provided a check, handed them my credit card to then get my card back (after being ran) with a different check and no apology or explanation. I thought maybe they were comping us a drink for their incompetence behind the bar. Unreal. Probably won’t go back now.
Would visit again. Just wish the specials were written down. To many to follow.
The food was delicious and lots of chief specials which our server recited with easy
Way overbooked the evening we dined, food waits were forever, over an hour for meal to arrive, appetizer was cold and unappetizing, not even edible.
Regulars get lots of attention, everyone else treated as forgotten cast offs.
Entree was good but never again on a Saturday.
Had a 7:15 res. Waited 15 minutes to get parked sent wife in to check place was packed wasn’t going to get a table till 8:30 apparently open table res meant nothing!
Got a last minute reservation which we were pleasantly surprised the Saturday before Mother’s Day. Once we walked in to this packed restaurant we thought there was no way there were going to be able to seat us. They were extremely apologetic and explained they had a communion party wrapping up. The party seemed to stay a little over and kept walking down the wall without masks. We had our two young boys. So we were a little uncomfortable, however the staff was working hard to get the room turned over.
Our waitress was excellent. Very friendly along with the rest of the staff and management checking in. Potions were big, many options on the menu as well as specials. Kids enjoyed their meal. Had an old school Italian vibe. We would return.
Great meal great service they make you feel at home
The artichoke was like a soup instead of a stuffed artichoke. Impossible to eat. So much liquid that really could not eat the artichoke. Perhaps it was sitting there? Substitute chef? The penne with Bologna’s sauce again was massive. But so much sauce that it was overdone. I would return, but I think they suffered from too few dinners. Good service. Lively ambience
The food was outstanding!! The restaurant was extremely busy but is was a Saturday night and to be expected. They do not rush you out! Definitely recommend!
As always a great meal it’s like family at Tesoro’s
Great food as always, great service, terrific restaurant,
The outside of this restaurant is deceiving. At first it appeared to be shut down because there was garbage strewn all over the outside.
However the food is really delicious.
The waiter was great when he was around.
Anniversary we had cocktails, appetizers, veal sorrentino special and linguine with Clam sauce. The service was wonderful and they took 20% off with anniversary coupon.
Service and food were excellent as usual!! We always come to this restaurant when we visit our daughter who attend a nearby university!
Great food and Service. We will definitely be back again.!
If you want to be treated like family, or like a regular even if it's your first time, this is the place for you. These people know hospitality. From the moment we walked in to when we walked out, we were attended to like if we've been going there ever week for 30 years. It's quite refreshing and the reason I'll chose to return to a restaurant over and over again.
The prices are high, but the quality, portions and service are worth it. The hot and cold seafood apps area must. The lamb chops were very good and the rigatoni vodka was perfect. The ricotta cheesecake was meh, but I'll still order it again because I just love ricotta cheesecake, even ok ones.
I highly recommend for a large family meal.
Perfect every time. Love the clams! Friendly homey, always welcome. Excellent prices.
I went there during covid and the restaurant was completely packed . There is no social distancing , the bar area was full, there was no partition separating any tables . If you looking for restaurant that abides to the covid rules . This is NOT the place the go.
Valentine’s Day dinner
We went to Tesoro for Valentine's dinner on Saturday night. The food was very good. My husband and I both had fish and it was excellent. We had a cold antipasto salad as an appetizer and it was delicious. The waiter was great, and the staff are very friendly. We have eaten here many times over the years and the food does not disappoint. We had the chocolate cake for dessert and it was amazing. Their prices are moderate. We wold definitely eat here again.
Our waiter Joseph was a gem! Personal pan pizzas are delicious. This is a great restaurant.
This is one of our favorite restaurants we go there at least once a month
Absolutely unacceptable! I had 9.30pm reservation, we arrived at the restaurant at 9.25, lights were out and all the doors were closed, nobody answered the phone either. They actually called during the day to confirm my 9.30 appointment, so they definitely knew we were coming. People just left without even calling me or canceling it on Open table app. How disappointing :(((.
My halibut was very good..needed more oreganata sauce on it though..my husband's veal parm.was lil tough,pasta good... ambulance great....as were the baked clams and drinks...we live supporting local restaurants and will continue to do so......
We have gone to Tesoro's several times since the indoor dining restrictions were lifted. As always, the food & service are excellent. Tables are situated so that more than the required distance between them is maintained. All servers/employees are masked at all times.
Service was great. Food was delish. We really enjoyed it.
My friend was happy with their meal personally overcharged for pesto with gnocchi it just felt very lack luster and the ingredients didn’t seem as fresh as they could be. Personally that’s a dish I’d avoid because they really can’t balance it right. Cheese & pesto don’t mix well for some odd reason because a numb lmk ear of places get it right but this place doesn’t
The best! Tony and his staff are exceptional in every way ..... we always feel welcome, food is delicious WE LOVE TESORO
This is the Italian restaurant me and my wife have been looking for! My wife is Italian and I had not been able to find the place that combined great food, amazing service, an "old school" atmosphere with lots of friendly, talkative people. Me and my wife were close to the youngest patrons there, and we are in our mid-40's...but it didn't matter. We had a great dinner and not too expensive!
Always visited by gracious owner and wife. excellent food as always!
Tesoro Ristorante offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 334-0022.
Tesoro Ristorante is rated 4.8 stars by 588 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.