Good food and good service. We enjoyed the ribeye steak. This is a nice alternative to the other venues on our small town.
Great friendly service and solid American food. Nice booths and plenty of space.
Sutter's Mill is an "old school" steakhouse. The food is really good and our server (Anna?) was outstanding. If you're looking for a nice meal in Simi Valley I would recommend Sutter's Mill.
Always consistently good. Excellent prime rib.
Always a great meal at Sutter's Mill. Service is also always the best!
My husband and I love this place! We wish there were more places like Sutter’s Mill! They are hard to come by these days!
We brought our own wine and I liked they don't have a corking fee. I normally try the house dressing but it was blue cheese which I don't care for. I had a fillet and it was good but not great. However, it was cooked perfectly which makes me think it was the quality of the ingredients. I had a potato with my meal and it as properly cooked. Lastly I had their peach cobbler and it was not memorable.
We had great service and the customers around our table were friendly but the ambiance is fairly dated and not very private. It reminded me of a nice country café.
For me, the bill seemed higher than the quality or quantity of food - I would have expected more of either for the cost of the meal.
Birthday celebration for Mike. Always a great value.
If you go to a more expensive restaurant you expect good service and you get that here. Clearly, the owner is concerned with providing a great experience rather than chain restaurants that only want to minimize labor costs.
This restaurant for me reminded me of the restaurants of the 70’s and early 80’s. Lots of leather booths not too dark without the cigarette smoke hazeThe food was excellent. The portion not too small or large and the wait staff attentive. Our server offered to split the check. We had a good and left trying to figure out when we could go back. I recommend the Prime Rib
Food and service was awesome as usual! Thank you for being open Christmas Eve so we could have an amazing meal.
Always a great steak. Try the peppercorn sauce. Food is always above everything
Always good dining. A subdued atmosphere conducive to table conversation and enjoyment of cuisine. We've become regulars.
Sutter’s Mill has always been a local gem in Simi Valley. Easy parking and easy to get a reservation. Our last visit was just so so. Our server was wonderful. My Prime Rib was a bit dry and a little tough. The other folks at the table who also ordered prime rib, had the same issue.
I wonder if it’s the same owner or perhaps it was just a bad cut of meat.
Either way, we’ll be back because it’s a great local eatery.
We arrived on time at 11:45. The restaurant was closed . I received an e-mail a few minutes later telling me they would not be open until 4 or 4:30. We were from out of town and had to go searching for another place to have lunch, a big disappointment! I gave a low rating in everything because Opentable would not allow me to post this review without a rating but we were not able to experience the place, it was closed. Opentable should not have confirmed my reservation.
Exceptionally good service and delicious food. The prime rib was superb. Get there early as the prime rib runs out later in the evening. A big plus is their "No corkage fee" policy! Decor is comfortable, old world style like steak houses used to be. We loved the intimate setting. You would never guess that you were in a strip mall once inside. Nice bar area too.
Old school steak house with delicious food, great drinks, and warm/friendly servers.
My son and I had a very nice dinner. I had a filet and my son had steak and shrimp, all nicely prepared. We also had cocktails which were well made. The server was friendly and professional. We'll be back!
Incredible Food (Maine Lobster, Stuffed Baked Potato, Garlic Toast and House Salad Dressing!)
Incredible Service (ALL the Girls and Josh!!)
Incredible Value (15% off and No Corkage!)
Granada Hills is in the House!!
Russ & Nancy Davis
The food is amazing and the service was fantastic!
Great steak. Try the peppercorn sauce. Best service as always.
Sutter's Mill is consistently one of the best restaurant values in Southern California! The service, food, 15% discount, no corkage fee, garlic bread and stuffed baked potato ROCK THE PARTY!!
great little restaurant here in Simi to have nice lunch or dinner or just cocktails. Bar with Tv and large area for large parties. Service is always nice and freindly and food good. Been going to Sutters for years, better than driving to Thousand Oaks or Pasadena
Excellent service and our meal was cooked to perfection. Best wedge salad I've ever had. Can't wait to go back. A little pricey but worth it for a nice meal on special occasions.
fabulous, delicious prime rib, also peach cobbler was fantastic.
Nobody does Maine Lobster better than Sutter's Mill locally!! When you combine that with solid Salad w/house dressing (leaning towards blue cheese strength!), garlic toast and stuffed twice baked potato. You have a meal fit for a King! PLUS...
...my wife and I enjoyed a good bottle of wine WITHOUT CORKAGE FEE!
Bottom line- she had Ground beef, salad, potato. I had lobster, salad, potato and we split garlic toast...$55!!!! We came before 5:30pm and got 15% discount!! $55!!!
Service was very good. Food mediocre and expensive.
Best Moscow Mule in town! Always above excellent service! Awesome prime rib, and best sides are the stuffed baked potato and fresh dinner salad. For dessert you must have the fried cheesecake. Beyond delicious!
Sutter's Mill always very good and consistent. Service this time was outstanding. Appreciate the somewhat enclosed atmosphere which provides relatively quiet and relaxed dinning.
Always a great steak
Sutter's Mill is great- food is always good, pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff. What's not to like?
We had 3 different cuts of beef and all were amazing. Server was professional and friendly. Fully recommend.
Excellent food and service! We will go there again!
Have always enjoyed the subdued atmosphere. The drinks and steaks are usually very good. This time the "Special Steak"had a lot of gristle. which made it less enjoyable.
One of our old favorites. We come here for the great food, good ambiance and good experience overall.
As usual, Sutter's Mill did not disappoint. We went with something different than our usual steak, scallops, lobster tail, soups and salads.
Started with the shrimp cocktail = Stellar!
Split the Halibut with some crab legs on the side...it was so delicious and plentiful. Even though I always split with my wife, we can never finish our meals due to the healthy sized portions here!
Best part, we are always greeted with open arms and a smile as soon as we ate foot through the door. The fantastic service, positive atmosphere and warm ambiance keeps us coming back...and oh yes, the food is ALWAYS to die for.
Thanks for being you Sutters!!
Sutter's Mill is dependable for a good meal in a pleasant atmosphere. Service is always timely and friendly.
Hands down best steak in town. Always have great service. Dessert was awesome also.