It was a very uneven experience. Restaurant looks great, server was adequate but the steaks were over cooked, fruit flies by the bar and there was even food on the menus. Horrible experience that a free desert can’t fix.
We visit twice a year. Unfortunately they seemed off this time. The dipping oil for the bread was all herbs and no oil. The garlic mashed potatoes were flavorless and a big sticky lump. The steak was lacking flavor as well. Quite disappointed. It’s usually spot on. We had made reservations with another restaurant and decided to cancel because we knew we liked Stone Creek so we should just go there. Sad that it wasn’t as tasty as usual. It was our belated valentine’s dinner and I had looked forward to it for two weeks. I had even thrown my back out the day before and made myself power through the pain to still go. Really disappointed.
Outstanding experience! I've brought my daughter here two years in a row for Daddy/Daughter dance and their food is amazing and atmosphere is perfect! I've also brought my wife here, which she loved as well. Keep up the great work Stone Creek!! We'll definitely be back!
As usual the food at Stone Creek was delicious. I REALLY did not want to pay as much as I did for the scallops, but they ended up being delightful. I did not like the tomato stuff on top- very sweet.
My husband got a burger and their house fries. Neither of us liked that either. The only thing I didn't like was that the server did not ask us why my husband didn't eat his fries. She just took it away without question. (He didn't mind because he just didn't like them- but to me, they should at least ask.) Other than this, our experience was overall good.
valentine’s with friends
I think we would have enjoyed our first-ever visit to Stone Creek (Plainfield, IN) more if we had not been seated directly across from the server station. It was brightly lit with servers going in an out all the time which was quite distracting to our conversation. The food we ordered was good. However, the service left a lot to be desired. Our server was very inattentive and rarely checked on us to see if we needed more drinks and bread. Overall, I was disappointed in our visit. I was really hoping for a more enjoyable experience since we were having a last dinner with friends before their move to Texas.
Stone Creek is quickly becoming one of our favorite restaurants. Food is always excellent, especially for the price and the service has been good every time we go in there. The bread is outstanding!
We enjoyed a good Valentines dinner. After a aloof greeting and delay, the manager comped appetizer (very good calamari) and a dessert. Impressed by his awareness of what happened. Food was very good and service was great. We will be back and recommend highly.
Service was great. Good wait staff. Food was nothing special and was not served hot. Nice ambiance. Would try it again, maybe just a bad day for the kitchen.
Always good food and service. The bread and dipping oil is the best! Reasonably priced for date night meal.
I have always liked the restaurant. I had the smothered chicken tonight. The chicken was overcooked on the edges and difficult to cut with a fork. It was a disappointing experience this time.
While the food and wait staff are constantly above expectation, getting seated is not. We make reservations every visit and every visit we wait at least an additional 30 minutes. We are taking our business to Carbonos. Same food and service but their hostess seems to know how to get us seated at reserved time.
We were seated 30 minutes after the reservation. Our table was by a coat rack and the emergency exit. Service was ok, the service was uneven. Great when the server remembered us. Not great when he didn’t.
The food, however was outstanding.
Good as always
Service and meal were exceptional. Very good atmosphere.
Great birthday celebration meal. Table was ready, server was attentive and food was excellent.
Something has changed or the time of day but I was not impressed as I have been in the past. Everything was just good, not bad nor excellent.
The early bird was not tasty and not worth the price
The salmon was covered in citrus vinegarette and did not taste fresh. The waiter did not explain the preparation and the salad dressing w as like ketchup
Very nice atmosphere. Decent food and service.
Couldn’t have had a better experience — food, staff, especially Server (Brandon) were great. Manager stopped by table to check in—a lovely Sunday lunch.
Didn't know they were participating in Devour Indy at this location. Since they were, 3 of 4 meals were from that menu. Brought out of town guests after raving abt Stone Creek and Stone Creek didn't let me down. Great food, great service.
Love lunch at Stone Creek...pick two soup and half sandwich is perfect. French onion soup delicious. BLTA is delicious and clearly freshly made...not bacon cooked the day before. Outstanding attentive service.
I haven't met a Cunningham restaurant I didn't love, and Stone Creek is very near my home, so I go there often. Usually we sit in the bar, where there are large, cozy booths in addition to the bar, itself. This was a family celebration, however, and I had made a reservation for 6 in the dining room. I was surprised by an extra person at the last minute on a busy Saturday night; but a quick phone call, and the manager assured me they would make room for us upstairs.
Very good wine was suggested by our server, and while some did the Devour Indy menu, I opted for the ahi tuna appetizer and the beet/feta/spring greens salad. Both were wonderful, and all the other family members loved their food, as well. You can't go wrong with any of the Cunningham restaurants: Stone Creek, Boulder Creek, Charbono's, VIDA (fab!), Bru Burger, Mesh and a couple that I have yet to try (heard that the Livery was very good, too.)
Love this local restaurant when visiting the Indy/Plainfield area on business. Always can get a table. Good food, nice atmosphere and excellent service. We'll be back....
We got seated in what appeared to be the bar area at a table. The noise coming from the kitchen area was very distracting. Glasses clanging together and lots of dish noise. Then they set up for a party of 6 with a handicap person right next to us and while they were being seated, the other guest bumped into my date 2 times. They did apologize. They tables were set way too close for an event like that. We were only there to use up a gift card we got. Not sure we will go back. Might ask for a booth next time.
Our food at Stone Creek was excellent. We love the “pick 2” part of the menu and appreciate that it can be shared.
Lovely atmosphere great staff and amazing food! Can't wait to go back!!!
It seemed like the time it took for our food to come out was a bit long considering it was a lunch meal. Glad we weren’t in a hurry to get back to work.
Frequent diners at this establishment, it offers solid food choices. Service was good, as was the atmosphere. Good soups on a cold Indiana day, and bread with oil always hits the spot.