Was a go to restaurant but menu and overall quality of food seems to be coming down. Pepsi products are also terrible.
We eat at Stone Creek once or twice every week and have consistently good food and service. I’d highly recommend it.
I made reservations here for a early lunch on Fathers Day for my family, as my teenagers had to work. Was pretty disappointed when we arrived at 11:15am and had to order off the dinner menu. Sorry. but wasn’t interested in a mediocre at best filet for brunch/lunch hour. There were a couple sandwiches/salads on the menu, no specials for the holiday though. I keep wanting to love this restaurant and always leave thinking I’ve overpaid for just ok food.
This location wouldn’t honor my open table points card. My 10$ card was wasted .
Great food! Filet mignon cooked to perfection. And amazing service from Nicole - as always. We go here for every special occasion and just those random date nights. He loves their gluten free options. I love their steaks and salmon.
We never have had either a bad meal or bad service at Stone Creek at HTC. The food is always quite good, from the bread and oil to dessert. Our only issue is that it sometimes tends to be loud in the dining room. We would also like to see a more extensive martini menu as Stone Creek's martini's are what first brought us to the restaurant. We will be back . . . . . .
Wait staff seemed stressed and apologized a number of times. Fish was excellent and we enjoyed our meal.
I stated on the reservation that it was a birthday and the server had not been informed. Server was very nice but very “green”. Eg asked for food order from the males at the table first. I had a salad which was not fresh at all and the chicken on the salad was very dried out.
Amazing dinner. Waiter was awesome and very informative of the specials and the suggestions he gave for appetizer and also dessert was perfect. Will be going back very soon.
Super good as usual. Wonderful specials very glad you
Have a fish selection to offer.
Very nice restaurant. Above scale and good for our business discussion. Our lunch meals were excellent. Spicy calamari maybe a little to spicy, but everyone liked their food.
Part of a group and would definitively go back again when in the area, or, to their other restaurants.
Just a nice restaurant with a nice menu. We are appreciative of Cunningham restaurants.
We enjoyed an Anniversary dinner with excellent food, service, and atmosphere.
We were seated upstairs so it felt like we were isolated. We were the only people upstairs and plenty of seats were available downstairs. The portion sizes were very small, asparagus and potato wedges were undercooked, and the water was warm. We decided to visit for our 22nd anniversary, but we will not be returning.
Inexperienced waitress that seems to be put out too soon. Incorrect drink delivered, incorrectly cooked steak delivered and incorrectly billed drink. Also, asked if a one off change could be made, she checked on it and she said it wasn't a problem. Came back 10 minutes later to say there would be a small up charge which seemed reasonable but when the food came the change wasn't made. Fairly disappointing experience which is surprising as previous experiences have been fine. Likely just a training issue as she seemed to be trying.
My family was celebrating my wife’s birthday. Great food always.
Excellent meal. The food was perfectly prepared. I will fault the staff for not reading the requests when I made the reservation using your website. Neither the hostess nor waitstaff knew where we wanted to sit nor why we were there. The questions indicated they had not looked. A very good experience.
Nice atmosphere and diverse food choices.
The staff and the owner were very accommodating to our party and the food was excellent! Me and my wife will be back! Great job Stone Creek!
Attentive, very good service from our waitress. Enjoyed a quiet dinner during the "Early Bird Special" time .
The customer service was excellent. The food was fresh and delicious. The atmosphere was a bit noisy, but not overwhelming.
Our dinner was very good. The portions were large enough that I took some home. The atmosphere was relaxing. An overall good experience.
Awesome! Great food and service!
Food was excellent and so were the cocktails. Our server, Will was very attentive and courteous.
Regular guests @ Stonecreek. Never disappointed. The service is outstanding and the food is always great.
Went for Mother’s Day. I ordered a filet mignon and it was cooked and seasoned to perfection. One of the meals at our table came out cold and had to be sent back but the manager rectified the issue promptly. Dessert was excellent! Overall the location, ambiance and food was good I’d return.
My cousin is disabled. The hostess went above and beyond to make sure we had a table with room to park her scooter. The manager corrected a mistake with a side dish immediately.
The food was so good!
Great dining experience!! Our server was fantastic!
Enjoyed Mother's Day celebration here. Everyone enjoyed their meals. We've dined here previously and plan to return again. Part of CRG for dining rewards (spend $1,000 to get $100).
we were very disappointed with the Bloody Mary's. Was not asked if we wanted it spicy or not, nothing in it, not even 1 olive. Totally not worth the price. Never again for drinks, food was fine. But to go for overall meal and drinks, not.
Very nice for our 4th Mother's Day at the restaurant. Wonderful steak/benedict. The kids bacon was too fatty and not edible, so watch that next time. Great server - Allie
Meal and service were excellent. Will definitely return.
We were celebrating my boyfriend's birthday. We've been to this restaurant multiple times and LOVED everything we got every time. This time was a bit different, unfortunately. Nothing was "bad" but most all of it was pretty bland and my boyfriend's filet was very, very tough. He almost couldn't cut it with his steak knife (or mine). We were disappointed, but we will be back again, because every other time has been very tasty.
We have always, always enjoyed dining at Stone Creek Noblesville but this time, not so much. Our cocktails were very slow to arrive coming after we got our appetizer. When I got mine, I'm not sure what it was but not the Dewar's and soda I ordered. When we were asked if we wanted to order appetizers we said yes, but when the waiter got my wife's order he was prepared to walk off not even looking at me to see if I wanted to order something, which I did. When my wife's filet medallions arrived, instead of being medium they looked like they had barely passed through the kitchen. They were extremely rare. They were sent back. When they were returned, yes, they were now medium but it looked like the whole plate had been put under the boiler including tomatoes and side dishes. We still like Stone Creek but think they have some work to do to reestablish the quality service and food they have built a reputation providing.
You'll like this one! Service, from being seated, through paying the bill, was exceptional. Creative menu, and very tasty. Not too expensive either. Nice place for any occasion, I will return again.
They always have a great steak. All the food is excellent. I love their house salad and the bread is to die for!
When we came in they asked if our visit was for a special occasion and we told them Anniversary and they were very nice. When presented with the menus I asked if we could see the early bird menu and then all of a sudden the mood changed. My wife (who has waited tables in the past actually mentioned it to me). We even felt like we were rushed a bit like they needed the table. Heck I was still eating my salad with fork in hand when the waitress asked if she could take my salad plate. It was still OK but I could tell the waitress lost some of her interest in us like we were going to stiff her on the tip. The food was great, and portions were good. As a parent of 4 young ones the early bird menu was what allowed my wife and I to go out to a nice dinner on our special day.
Sorry if I got the wrong impression.
Never had a bad meal at Stone Creek. Food was prepared perfectly and served piping hot. Can't complain about that.
service was slow and hardly anyone in the restaurant
Service was slow and waitresses were not attentive. There were two people in our party who ordered drinks that were not brought out until our lunch was served.
Nice waitresses, one was new. Food was great. Restaurant was nice and pleasant.