Tuesday-Saturday Dinner: 5pm-10:45pm
Sunday Lunch: 11:30am-3pm
Sunday Dinner: 4-9:45pm
Park Street - MBTA Red/Green Line
I reserved a table for 7 with all the women in my family , including my 11 year old cousin, as we go to see the nutcracker every year and the location was close to the theater and the reviews looked okay. We were lead past several open tables and sat at two wobbly tables pushed together at the bar. Several groups of people were standing around us, drinks in hand, and it was very hard to hear or see. (My 11 year old cousin making comments about why she was allowed to be in a bar and upset at the noise level) When we asked to be moved to somewhere else we were told no, they were fully booked, tough luck. We made due at the bar and upon leaving counted at least 3 locations that had remained empty throughout the course of our stay that we could have been moved to. The food was good but the blatant refusal to accommodate us while we stared at other empty tables all night was insulting. If you’re here for drinks and food and a casual night and don’t mind being treated badly by management, this is your spot.
Restaurant obviously knows they can get away with poor service because of where they are located.
Great experience all around. Had the scallops which were cooked perfectly. Bartenders have outstanding skills. All the staff are very friendly.
Fun place with lots of authentic historic structural elements. Huge bar with wide array of draft selections. Food is solid pub fare - don't miss the fried artichokes! Order taking was prompt, but better timing is needed with the kitchen. Main courses were delivered before we finished the appetizers - and the table was too small to accommodate all the plates. Seating is a bit close, but no worse than many Boston restaurants. Easy walking distance to Boston Common and Macy's shopping/pedestrian area. Would certainly return.
Friendly, welcoming place that blends old Boston with the new.
Great place before a show or a game at the Garden. Nice beer list. Had the ribeye and my wife had a burger. Scotch egg app. Everything was really good. They also take reservations.
Inattentive waiter, ruined the vibe. Never refilled drinks, never asked if we needed anything. Food was excellent.
Very good New England Chowder and burgers, excellent beer selection and great hand crafted cocktails. We were going to a 7:30 show and made a very early (3:45) reservation to allow time for a walk around the common for Christmas light viewing after lunch/dinner. The timing was just about perfect except that we had to rush to put our order in because the kitchen closes from 4-5 to set up for dinner, but nobody told me that even when I called to ask about accessibility for a member of our group, and it is not stated in the website. People who came in ten minutes after us were refused food service. However, they were gracious about allowing us to linger at our table after our dinner, finishing drinks. An interesting place with lots of character, nice servers and they do good work. I recommend reading about the history of the place one their website before, during or after your visit.
We has the clam chowder which was a good size and tasty. Also got the fondue which was a big portion, comes with 3 large pretzels.
The restaurant had a nice selection of food and appetizers. It was a bit loud at times but that's to be expected at a bar/restaurant. The food is a bit overpriced for the quality, even though it was good. The pretzel was pretty dry and not all that great. The clam chowder, however, was pretty good. The duck and risotto were cooked well but kind of bland. The fisherman platter was large and the seafood was well seasoned.
The food portions were large, reasonably priced, but just mediocrely. Convenient location. May be better for lunch than dinner.
It's clear that they work hard. The manager was running around like crazy. The menu is creative, unexpectedly so. We enjoyed our meals.
Food was good, it took at least 15 minutes for anyone to ask for our drink order, and another 10-15 for it to be brought to us after seeing it sit on the counter for awhile. I think they were between shifts with servers so I'm sure some things got lost, but the couple next to us was completely served and finished before us, but we were sat at least 15min before they were sat. Food was brought much more quickly and the fried artichokes were amazing.
A little bit loud for a date but overall a nice experience.
Dinner before seeing Hamilton. The service was so attentive. I was impressed.
The restaurant was just around the corner from our hotel. We made a reservation the same day and had no problem getting in. We had a small table right next to the bar. It’s not a large place so the noise level has very high. It has great Boston history. It was several businesses before it became a bar and restaurant. The service was slow and a little frustrating. I’m vegan so I ordered a salad and two wonderful side vegetables. My husband ordered the Shepherds Pie and loved it. The frustrating thing was that the two men who were sat 20 minutes after us to our right got their food 10 minutes before us! What? If you like a noisy pub atmosphere, want to grab some good hot Irish food and want to see a original Boston landmark, this is the place for you.
Drink service was extremely slow. We didn’t get drinks until 25 minutes after we arrived at the restaurant. They had one waiter for a ton of tables and he just couldn’t keep up - not his fault, just low staffed. Atmosphere was cool.
Good spot for a pre Opera House show. Food was fine, not great, but also not bad. Chicken was a bit dry, as were the fries. Salad was very good. Menu is somewhat limited, but they are a scratch kitchen, and will accommodate. Dining tables were VERY close to one another. Definitely a better bar stop than a meal stop. Paid a bit more than I think it was worth. The staff was friendly.
Delicious meal!! Awesome ambience. Went before a show. Great location!
No one in our party was satisfied with the food. The two seafood dishes did not taste like they contained the freshest fish or shrimp. The fries were blah, the fried chicken sandwich nothing special, the serving of slaw paltry.
we ate here before a show after our reservation elsewhere was cancelled....we were lucky to find a place that could serve us quickly so we could get to the show on time. We were seated and served in less than an hour! Handled my husband's food allergies well. Everyone liked what they had (shepherds pie, chicken legs, scallops and sandwich. Kudos to them for not serving bread. None of us need bread before dinner.
Sat at a high top table in the bar area so bartender and waiter was one and the same which made it easy. Asked for martini recommendation and after a few words the bartender said “let me make you something”. He came back with a mixed cocktail in a Masson jar which was tasteless. I then said I would just prefer a cosmo. He cane back with a horrible version of a cosmo that tasted like it was vodka, sour mix and a splash of something red. Very disappointing. My husband and I ordered the fondue with pretzels as an appetizer. It was delicious. Warm baked pretzels with a nice melted cheese for dipping. For meals, I ordered the scallops. The first thing I noticed was that they smelled, which usually means they are not fresh. They were also very salty- too salty to enjoy so I ate half of my husbands meat. My husband ordered the beef which was delicious. My last drink was a gin and tonic which was good.
Atmosphere is terrific. Very old Boston, which I liked. Excellent location to the Opera House which we were going to.
I’d recommend you go but stick to beer ( which they have a ton of choices for on tap) and beef / burger.
Made a 6:15 reservation before seeing Hamilton. The location is very convenient to the theater district, and good service allowed us to relax and make it to the show in plenty of time. Our only complaint on this unseasonably warm November evening (70 degrees!) was how hot we were in the restaurant. But the pretzel fondue and lobster grilled cheese were both delicious choices!
To be honest, I had high hopes for Stoddard's after reading some of the Yelp reviews. Unfortunately my experience didn't live up to those of others.
I'll sum it up:
Asked for no croutons on a Caesar salad (person who ordered is gluten free), out came the salad with a large flat crouton over the top. The other Caesar didn't have it.
One check for refills as soon as the salads came out, nothing from the waitress until the meal was over.
"Beef Cheeks" menu item was majority fat. I understand the cut of meat, but half of the meat should not be fat.
A member of my party ordered the scallops and found them way too salty. Again, no waitress to check in, so we finished the meal. When told about the salty scallops when it came time for the check, the waitress went over and had an animated discussion with another member of the wait staff while constantly looking over at my table. No check in from the manager, nothing. Only a $5 off discount on the bill.
It's not about the money, it's about the service. I won't be going back to Stoddard's anytime soon.
We needed a place to eat before a show and Stoddard's was nearby. It turned out to be an excellent choice. We did wish the noise level were a little lower; some absorbent material probably would help. Both the food and service were excellent. We did not have any alcoholic beverages on this visit, maybe next tim
Delicious Dinner before Concert:
We booked a table for a dinner prior to a concert at the Orpheum. The menu sounded diverse and I was sure we could both find options we liked. My husband had the Mussels and I had Haddock and Cole slaw.
We split battered Onion rings. Everything was delicious and could not have been better. I would definitely recommend for the food. The ambiance was OK, but would have been better with out the flickering T.V's with sports channels on along with the rather loud music in the dining area. It was difficult to talk or hear over it.
Good food and atmosphere. Asked the server for a gin cocktail recommendation, he didn’t seem to be sure and just picked one off of the menu when he looked at it. Other than that great spot!
This pub/restaurant was a mismatch for us. We were looking for a more upscale pre-theatre dining experience. This is a pub with a good selection of beers and sandwiches. They do serve fancier entrees (which when previewing the menu led us to believe that we'd be happy with this choice), but this is really a fish and chips and burger place. We sat downstairs and it was dark, noisy and bar-like. If we'd come to watch a game, we would have written a stronger review. i think the description of the restaurant on Open Table could be revised to be more accurate.
This pub has all of the attributes that people either love - or hate - about pubs. It is arguably 'authentic' in that it is cluttered, idiosyncratic, noisy and completely unique (although it isn't as old as it looks - the bar was rescued from an English pub and the site was a retail cutlery store until comparatively recently). There are cask ales and interesting beers on tap and a menu that is part pub - shepherd's pie, ie - and part nod to contemporary tastes - a nice plate of seared scallops and a good to very good duck breast. The location - around the corner from Boston's theatres, adds a star to the rating, since finding a reliable bite and a drink at 6 pm for a 730 curtain can be iffy. We were a party of four and we had a delightful time and a good meal. I would return.
Great, casual dining with a nice variety of food choices. We’ve been there several times and have always had a great dining experience.
Amazing in every aspect! Had the best time, we had to go back the next night. Food was so fresh, cocktails were carefully created.
Stoddards is a great place for a pre-show meal -- food is delicious, service is friendly, and the beer selection is fantastic! Will definitely go back next time I'm in the area for theater or a concert.
Stoddard's is accustomed to pre-theater diners, and we were in and out quickly. Part of the experience is the building, one of the oldest in the vicinity, having survived a fire 150 yrs ago. The food is good pub food. We particularly enjoyed the burger and the bratwurst. Messy, but tasty. They have an interesting cocktail list, as well as a variety of beers. Sadly, they do not offer desserts.
I was disappointed with my fish and chips. the fish had little flavor, the sauce was terrible, ( tarter) the cole slaw had no flavor, bland, pretty bad. The best part was the fries. the pretzel / cheese dip was much better than the meal. I would not go back. the ambiance was too loud, table sticky, and wobbly, could even read the menu as it was so dark. the waitress was very, very nice. and my cocktail was good.
The hostess came over after 90 minutes and told us there was another reservation for the table and we needed to leave. The server had just told us we could hang so we’d ordered more drinks. Server A+. Hostess F.
We were about 20 minutes late for our reservation due to traffic but it was no problem at all. They seated us immediately. Service was quick, which was appreciated as we were very hungry! We enjoyed our meal, but the noise level was so high that it was nearly impossible to have a conversation. Great option for pre or post theater eats.
Made a reservation here to have a meal before going to a concert nearby. Was attracted by the draft list and the menu, and Stoddard's didn't disappoint. The draft list was wide-ranging, I we were happy to try beers we don't normally see. My husband's jasmine rice bowl was better than my gnocchi, but overall the food was tasty. It was busy, but it wasn't super loud. And the service was great - everyone was friendly and attentive. We would go back to Stoddard's again if we find ourselves in the area!
We had a scotch egg - very tasty - The poutine was yummy - instead of drizzling the cheese, it was a fried wedge on top of the fries and gravy - golden goodness! We both had burgers with large Onion rings, that came hot and juicy, and 2 drinks off the menu that sounded interesting to try, but we'd get others on the menu next time.
Server was attentive but didn't hover over us, which was great. Ambiance was cool downstairs. Wood beam ceilings and brick basement. A+ Dining experience.
Our food was cold and tasteless. Our service was just okay. Cocktails were nothing to brag about.
Food was really great