Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
Perfect evening for our 25th anniversary! Colleen took care of us and did an excellent job. The cowboy steak was cooked perfectly, and my wife's 2 lb. lobster was quite succulent. We will be back!
My favorite restaurant
S & C never disappoints us! The cuisine is always delicious and the service is superb. I attribute the success and delight of customers to the hands on oversight of Cookie who is the consummate restauranteur!
Thank you for another delightful evening.
Bev and Harry
Steve & Cookies never fails to deliver a special dining experience
Great food, and great wine at a reasonable price per glass, perfect night.
So good! I had a salad and the Seafood Pan Roast, my husband had the Sunday Pasta with Pork Chop Gravy. They do everything right with an innovative menu and the freshest ingredients-loved it!
Have heard about Steve and Cookies for years!
So happy to finally go and experience... was perfect
Our dinner was excellent as always ! The service was great !!
Valentine’s Day weekend 2019!
Amazing staff and amazing food! Fried lobster with crab imperial stuffing... amazing! Wine list was great!
Always great never any problems
Excellent excellent excellent only words to describe Steve and Cookies!
Our meal and service was the best we’ve ever had! George was extremely knowledgeable about his wine, funny, and all around amazing!! We can’t wait to go back!
Joanne, our server, was the best!
Good overall experience . If you live within 10-15 minutes of the location it’s worth it. If you are coming from further such as Cape May County you can get the same experience across the board in your backyard. I was slightly disappointed with the service to be honest. The dessert was amazing. The oysters were superb. The entrees were good overall. The filet is outstanding.
Excellent food and experience. Highly recommend. Don’t miss out !!!
My girlfriend and I had a great experience as usual at this restaurant. Everyone including the hostess, the busboys, the servers, the bartenders, and the chefs did an incredible job! Also got a chance to meet and speak with Cookie which was nice.
It was wonderful as usual. It’s always a delicious meal with great service!
The only issue I have is with trying to modify the reservations with Open table I usually have to call the restaurant directly if the time needs changing or the number of guests needs changing.
Great meal! Can’t wait to go back!
The food was great and matched by the great service; however, the lighting was so poor that I COULDN'T READ THE WINE LIST AND NEEDED HELP FROM THE SERVER'S SMART PHONE LIGHT.
Delicious! Great choices for vegetarians!
Excellent food and great service. Can’t wait to go back !
Valentine’s Day dinner with my wife. Steve and Cookies is my wife’s favorite restaurant and for great reason. The food, service, ambiance and overall experience is outstanding. Can’t wait to go back!
Love this place. Consistent in a good way. The problem is I always order the same thing! Our favorite place. We also like that Cookie gives so much back to the community.
Absolutely amazing! Never a bad meal, never a bad experience, never a bad time at all. Not even mediocre. Truly ALWAYS always great. Best lobster tail in my history of existence ❤️
For a special dinner, you can hardly beat Steve & Cookie’s! It’s chefs are consistently excellent, often creatively offering new twists on dishes we love. And the wait staff is efficient and very helpful.
I can’t wait to go back!
Excellent food and service. The only criticism is if you have 5:00 reservations you cannot stay in Restaurant before 5. Even though they have a full bar, you cannot have a before dinner drink or have a comfortable seat. We had to wait in our car. They should consider opening the bar at 4:30, especially on holidays. It did put a little damper on an otherwise amazing meal.
Very expensive, $110 bill with no booze or desert. Service is done by kids, that gather and gossip by the bar. Expected more professionalism for the price.
This restaurant always seems to get top reviews but our experience included oysters that were too large, mediocre food, and slow service.
Excellent food as always. Our server Hector was very friendly & attentive as well as our food runner.
We ordered the suplini, burrata, bouillabaisse, cowboy steak & jumbo lump crab over pasta. Everything was delicious. We didn’t even have room for dessert. My favorite restaurant still!
Always LOVE Steve & Cookies. Fresh succulent oysters, Great steaks and chops, veggies that are well prepared and exciting. Great meal, romantic setting.
We had such an amazing night , the food is always delicious and consistent from the bread to the dessert
Our waitress Kay was great! The food was delicious! Everything we ordered was beautifully presented. The negative...we could not hear each other speak at all, I know you could do nothing about this but the table of 5 young women, right behind us were so loud and boisterous... as if they were hanging at a bar, so loud that many other patrons on the other side of the room were turning around. When we were first shown our table I wanted to be seated at another immediately but didn't since you were already so crowded I assumed this was the only table. The draft from the door was very uncomfortable so much so I had to wrap my coat around my legs. The lentil soup my husband ordered was lukewarm. We had to wait very long for our meal...45 minutes maybe more after the first course. The waitress came by 3 times and apologized. We don't like to complain, but since you asked I felt compelled to let you know...I do want to commend you on an amazing menu and delicious innovative meals you serve. Also, the young men pouring water etc. were all very, very pleasant and right on top of everything! Thank you for a delicious meal. Adonna Calabrese
We had a great time and the food was wonderful. Our waiter was aces! However, the restaurant did not credit my open table points.
Excellent as ALWAYS!! We love the atmosphere and the food is exceptional!!
The hostess accommodated our late appointment and we were immediately seated and served. Very cozy restaurant, super romantic and exceptional food. Celebrating an anniversary or any special occasion here is a must if you are close to Margate Bay.
First visit to Steve & Cookie’s & it won’t be my last!
Food & service outstanding, my wife had the Lump Crab
& Pasta and said it the best she ever had! My very tender
Veal Chop was delicious as were all of the entree’s,appetizers and cocktails. The wine list was fantastic and offered everything you could look for.
Our favorite Restaurant in South Jersey!!
Always the best!
The food here is always great. We had a two pound lobster perfectly steamed and tender, fried shrimp, pork chop and everything was delicious. A little noisy but service impeccable and all in all a memorable dinner!