Shockingly bad and shockingly overpriced. Embarrassed for them.

If you’re looking for excellent steakhouse food - this place doesn’t disappoint. It is quieter than the usual suspects on the steakhouse circuit, so if you want to have a working lunch or dinner where you can actually hear yourself. If you want to have phenomenal food without yelling to be heard, this is the place. It’s a quiet gem, and I recommend it to everyone. The staff is excellent, and there’s never a no for whatever request you make. Great wine selection as well.

The service, food and overall experience was awesome! Would recommend for both business and pleasure dining!

Nice looking place but lousy ambiance.

Great Steak cooked to perfection. Quite enough to have a business discussion.

I've enjoyed The Staghorn Steakhouse numerous times over the years. Great place for a business lunch as the noise level is very low. Service is impeccable and very professional. The food is exceptional. List of "bar food - appetizers" are plentiful. The Steak on Toast is terrific as an appetizer and don't miss the onion rings! Steaks are perfectly grilled and served the way you ordered. I've stopped in for a Happy Hour drink and the place is hopping. I've been to other "big name, big box, open since 1895" type steakhouses, but the cuisine, atmosphere/ambiance is totally different.. The Staghorn has more a private club feel. I've noticed that Management and servers greet many guests by name, definitely a good sign. Very friendly place. I have never been disappointed, be it for a business lunch, quick drink or dinner. BTW... I have never been rushed at The Staghorn...even when a business lunch lasted almost 3 hours or just lingering over the last glass of wine! Try that in other steak houses.

It was a great meal, great food and great drinks. Not very crowded so very attentitive.

Good food. Efficient knowledgeable staff. Lack luster decor and atmosphere.

I’m sad to say the food was a major disappointment. The filet was chewy and so was the sea bass. It was terrible. There were only 3 other people there and now I know why. The waiter couldn’t have been nicer but that’s likely because they are desperate for customers.

Excelente Servicio .. La Comida era aceptable , pero no acorde la relacion precio - calidad.
No lo volveria a visitar

One of my favorite steak houses in NY

The food and ambiance were fantastic. We will definately be back!

Great food, great staff. Would definitely go back and recommend to a friend!

Great food and a hidden gem.

Nice little gem in NY. Excellent steak!

I love this place. The owner plays an active role in assuring that everyone of his patrons are being taken care of and are happy with everything. My GF wanted steak and I searched for a steak house around Penn Station and that is how I found Staghorn. I will definitely be back and will be telling everyone how great this place is.

Over cooked the steak, but the service was great.

Service was spot on! They were very attentive & made us feel like they truly cared about our experience. Steaks were great & the dessert, tiramisu was amazing!

Another fantastic meal at Staghorn. I went there with my brother on Friday night, as we like to do every couple of months. Had the porterhouse for 2, which was cooked to medium-rare perfection and could have easily fed 4. For sides, the creamed spinach was excellent and the crispy hash browns are a must. Add a martini and a glass of cabernet and the dinner is a 10 every time. Highly recommend.

Great appetizers and steaks. Very attentive service, quality big screen projector for the game.

Walked in.. no ambiance. Nice wine list but really only one available? Five of us had dinner.. we did order a seafood tower so that was pricey. I had only a lobster bisque for dinner and my husband only had a mozzarella appetizer for dinner. We had filled up on appetizers.. bill was almost 700... not worth it. We dine in steak house often. Very disappointed.

Great place

Enjoyed lunch at Staghorn. Nice ambiance. Quiet place, great for conversation.

Food was good, prices high.

I couldn't have had a better time or a better meal. The steak was perfection.
I hadn't seen my cousin in 3 yrs. We finally were in NY at the same time. The waiter was patient and very friendly. I'm afraid we sat and talked for over 2 hours, but happy that we were not rushed out. No one came with the check until I asked for it. I want to thank Staghorn's for offering such a lovely approach to its diners.

Always a great meal. Their steaks are the best! Decided to have Salmon on this trip and it was very good. Many visits to Staghorn and never a disappointment.

I recently visited Staghorn Steakhouse on a business trip with a colleague. The wine, food and service was outstanding. I had the Lobster Bisque and Strip Steak. The bisque was delicious. The steak was perfectly prepared, very flavorful with a very generous proportion (I left some which never happens). It came with spinach sautéed with garlic and potatoes which were also fabulous. My colleague is a vegetarian so he had a salad with Tuna (medium rare) which he very much enjoyed. The tuna was fresh and cooked to perfection.

I almost forgot the wine! Great selection, reasonable prices and a very knowledgable wine stuart to help you out.

Overall, our experience was excellent and I will definitely include Staghorn on my list of restaurants next time I'm in NYC.

It's not the first time that I have been to Staghorn and this place never fails the food was exceptional service very attentive just excellent

Only two other customers in the restaurant but food didn't seem to receive the care it could have received from a quiet kitchen. Filet was huge, perhaps too big if that's possible. I ordered in medium but it was pretty close to rare as I worked my way toward the middle. I know baked potatoes have to be made ahead of time but mine was certainly nothing special and lukewarm at best.
I'll try the place again but make sure I go when it's a bit busier.

Beautiful quite romantic ambiance. Absolutely delicious food from the bread and butter to the juicy lamb chops!

We had tickets for Billy Joel and came to the Staghorn for dinner. Wine list was extensive for its bottles, so-so for wine by the glass.

My wife had the crab cakes and lobster bisque. The crab cakes were a good size (2 served for dinner) and she said the were delicious, She really liked the lobster bisque as her appetizer

I had the grilled octopus as my appetizer. Absolutely delicious and a generous portion for the price and especially it being a NY restaurant!

And, yes as a steak house, I had the salmon and sautéed spinach and garlic. Outstanding!

Excellent steaks. A little pricey, but the best filet mignon I've ever had (16 oz). Was quiet as the rain kept a lot of diners away. Everyone in our party of six were satisfied

The Mgmt and Staff are very welcoming. Food great and the restaurant feels like a private club.

It was empty for a Saturday night - we though we stepped into the Twilight zone we were the only ones in the restaurant it was so weird.

Food and service were impeccable, but why oh why is there a television playing the Mets home opener in the bar? It just spoils the ambiance completely. When I'm dining at a restaurant that purports to be a high-end steakhouse, it's pretty disappointing when, despite the delicious food and charming service, you feel as if you've been transported to a Knights of Columbus rec room.

We got there for lunch at 11:30am. The kitchen doesn't open until noon, but the owner allowed us to be seated and talk while we waited. He was very cordial and made us feel right at home.

The service was excellent. Had soup and a salad. The lobster bisque was great.

I'd definitely make it back here soon.

This is a great restaurant with a great selection of steaks, seafood, and deserts. They have great selection of wines, and deserts as well. I have been frequenting this restaurant since they opened, and consider myself to loyal customer. The owner "Chirro" is a fantastic host!

Great job Staghorn Steakhouse, and thank you Chirro!

Bill M.

My clients and I always enjoy our lunches. Great, food, service and handsome place

Staghorn Steakhouse is a hidden Gem. I tend to like places that are a little elegant, but not too stuffy and a place one can easily hold a conversation while having a meal, Staghorn satisfies both criteria. Most important is the suburb quality of the food. My fillet mignon was done to a trun and a very generous portion.

The service was attentive, they make an excelent Martini, and gave me good advice when it came time to order wine.

Keep in mind that you'll be paying steakhouse prices for your meal. It IS a steakhouse after all. ;) But the food and the atmosphere make it a great value.

Sadly, we were the only diners at 730 on a weekday evening---so this might be a good place for steak when you don't want to be seen!!