St Mary's Seafood & More
This was a birthday celebration. There were 5 of us (all adults). I hadn't been here in a couple years. Meals were delicious & server was attentive.
All of need carry-out boxes. We couldn't finish our meals. Portions were plentiful.
Cole Slaw was not very flavorful.
Based upon other reviews, I went to this restaurant while working in the Jacksonville area thinking that it would be much better than it was. The service was friendly. The food was marginal though. The fish tasted fresh. Presentation was sloppy. The green beans I ordered as a side were WAY over cooked to where they were soft, mushy and totally unappetizing. I couldn't eat them.
They have perfected fried shrimp at St. Mary's! The slaw, the onion rings....it's all really really good. Our server, Damien, was also excellent. He was very knowledgeable and attentive. We will be back!!
Comfortable restaurant with good food and good service. Had become a family favorite of our for fresh seafood.
Great food and service!! Our waitress Cindy was great!!
it was our first time there, and we will definitely be back. The service was great our waitress was very attentive. The food was delicious! And great portions. Will go back again.
As always, the team at St. Mary’s delivers hot, fresh tasty food in an enjoyable atmosphere! We enjoyed our visit and the food! Definitely recommend this restaurant!
quickly seated. Excellent service. Excellent food.
Always have a great meal here! Food is fresh and served hot. Service was very good!
Very disappointing meal - a lot of our meal seemed to have sat in the kitchen for hours. Chewy calamari, canned flat beans, and while I liked the hush puppies-it’s because they tasted like donuts and they confirmed they make them with sugar- weird. The special tonight was over cooked fish. If you go - upgrade to the fresh sautéed green beans - the highlight of the menu as it’s FRESH.
St. Mary's Seafood has the laid back feel of a diner, delicious seafood and reasonable prices. I recommend it highly. It's great to be able to order quality seafood without paying a fortune.
it was actually a little too noisy, but the food was good and the service was great.
Food and service was excellent as always. Great casual dining with options for everyone.
St Marys Seafood is still a good destination for affordable meals.
We have noticed the food quality isn’t quite where it was.
My slaw was good, but the bowl was half full. My grits were chunky, which happens after grits have been sitting.
My shrimp and scallops were on the dark side, especially the scallops, instead of golden.
The hush puppies were excellent! Our server was better than excellent!! I’d give her 6 stars.
The food was pretty good, and better than some other places I’ve eaten seafood.
My Moscato was well priced, but a scant half glass.
Will I go back?
Yes, because even though the prices have risen, it’s still a reasonably priced restaurant with reasonably good food.
Been there before but this visit was not as good - service was very slow and food cold. I think waiter forgot to get food and it sat for some time
It was our first time there but we really enjoyed it. The food was great and so was the service. For the price the food was very reasonable.
This was our second time here. We enjoyed it so much the first time that we came back. They made a mistake on my dish but was resolved very quickly with management coming out to apologise. Good was great and definitely will be coming back.
Food is consistently good and at a fair price. Service is friendly and efficient.
Avoid the long wait lines and make a reservation via Open Table!
Wait staff was friendly and prompt and the food was very good
Server was fantastic!!!! Food awesome!
The food was AWFUL, the service awful. This was the Old St Augustine Rd location. I have eaten at the World Golf Village location and it was good.
Our waitress was very nice; however, it took quite a while (approx 45 minutes) to get our food. The amount for the price was pretty skimpy. In addition, the booth seats desperately need to be replaced. When you sit down, you sink into them so much that you have to lean up to reach the table! I also noticed that all of the overhead vents were filthy. Kinda makes me wonder how clean the kitchen area is. I used to enjoy this restaurant . . not so much anymore.
We have eaten at St. Mary’s quite a few times and the food and service are wonderful. We enjoyed our dinner.
Fried Baca and the fried Shrimp. Wine Wednesday 🥰🥰
Service was great and the food was awesome. I used opentable for my reservation for our group, and was happy with that as well.
Nice evening out!
Enjoyed my evening . Food was great. Wait was short. Drinks were good. Only negative was I did not get all my food that I ordered. Had to ask twice about. When I did get it , I had already finished my meal and it was cold. Waiter need to address needs of customer with out pointing blame on kitchen staff. Its is the waiters job to make sure my experience is the best it can be.
Delicious! Service was excellent and we enjoyed everything.
I always enjoy eating atSt. Mary's Seafood. I never realized you could make a reservation which was very helpful
Food and service was good for the price
Our server "Carrie" was awesome she was attentive and knowledgeable the food was good but I won't say great as I've had better at this location. The clam chowder was a bit undercooked with the potatoes still with a bit of a crunch and the clams still too chewy for my taste. The shrimp and scallops that I had were pretty tasty though so that was a plus as were the fries. The others in my party didn't have any complaints that I heard so overall it was a good experience and by using the OpenTable reservation were we seated right away after we arrived.
We Always enjoy our meal at St. Mary’s. Everyone is so friendly and so willing to help. The food is excellent.
Always delicious! This is our go to place when we want fresh seafood that is consistently good, served fast, in a comfortable relaxed atmosphere. The service is friendly and attentive...they never disappoint!
Excellent server,great food. Our first visit was a grand experience . We were greeted with a smile by the owners. Our server was knowledgable and very helpful. Look forward to returning on our next visit.
The second time was great. The wife and I, enjoyed it a lot.
Good food good service zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Great Fried Shrimp. Casual place, no need to dress up.
poor quality offoid and on top ofthst, significantly overpriced. It was mych better when it firsted opened. The owner isnice, but she must be blind or just not care. She is there all the time, but she never asked about thefood or sevice. Will drive to Cedarriver instead.