Great food & great service
Sara Wessel: exemplary service!!!
The service and the food was wonderful, as always. George took great care of us.
Outstanding food and service. Always meets my expectations.
Undeniably the best mashed potatoes I’ve ever eaten. Absolutely awesome shrimp cocktail.
Incredible food and service. Our server Jordan was friendly and knowledgeable about menu items and make excellent recommendations for the whole table.
As always, the food and service at St. Elmos was fantastic. Our waiter, Evan, was extremely knowledgeable and offered great advice on our wine and food selection. Thank you for a wonderful evening!
I was excited to take my daughter and her friend to St. Elmo's before deploying overseas, but was put in the basement under the air vent . The steak was overcooked (ordered medium) and was cold (it had to have sat for a good 15-20 min). I have typically had a positive experience at St. Elmo's, but unfortunately this will go down as one that wasn't positive.
Days later I’m still in awe. A fantastic experience for my wife’s and I anniversary!!
Took friends for their first time. Excellent service as always. Memorable experience.
Great atmosphere and incredible food . I would highly recommend.
Best steak dinner ever, paired with the best service ever!!
We had great steaks and wine.Our waitress helped us select a wine we really liked and the steaks were great as one would expect. The shrimp cocktail blew our sinuses out. We also had baked potatoes and lobster bisque. All was very good. My only complaint was that the lobster bisque was an additional $8.00 and the "loaded" for the baked potato was $5.00. Everything was overpriced, I suppose that is why we go once every 10 years.
Anytime I'm within a hundred miles of Indy ( I live in Cleveland) I'm eating at Elmos. Period. With a daughter at Purdue I get there on occasion. Our last meal was exactly like all the times I have eaten there- great food, good ambiance, and excellent service- this time it was Jason White and he is a wonderful server. Everything was spot on including his pace of the meal and his sense of humor. They can keep all the cookie cutter "Name brand" steakhouses in Indy and elsewhere just give me a shrimp cocktail, some bean soup, a filet and a nice cab at Elmos and I'm good every time. My first time there was 1983 and I'm never leaving. Love this place.
Steak was very good but the tables are very close together. Not only is there a lack of privacy but there wasn't enough room to take off our coats comfortably. Our server was hospitable but the famous shrimp cocktail is very spicy and overpriced for a few shrimp.