St. Elmo Steak House
Indy's best steakhouse!
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
"World Famous" St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail
Say a prayer to the "Patron Saint of Clear Sinuses."
St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail®
4 jumbo shrimp served with our spicy, signature cocktail sauce
Sliced Grilled NY Strip Steak
Easy to eat amazing steak for twoyou're welcome.
Rare night out for my wife. St. Elmo’s was awesome!
When ever I leave California going to the Midwest I route my flights thru Indianapolis
to eat at St Elmo , always well worth the detour!
Great Experience.... Highly Recommend... Atmosphere is amazing
Our room was a bit noisy with others nearby. Just think it is an old building without sound reduction help in place.
This was the best steak I've ever had. The service was amazing. This place is a must for anyone that comes to Indianapolis.
Food was not the greatest. I ordered the new York stip. No flavor and not cooked to my liking. Sides were bland. I didn't even enjoy the water. There was no ice in the water. Only good thing I had was the bourbon butter cake. Don't waste your money.
My family was in town for an event and we always try to diner at a nice steakhouse during our stay. This restaurant didn’t disappoint. Very good. We enjoyed the Filet Mignon, Sirloin, and Ribeye. The shrimp cocktail was good and spicy. The lobster bisque was delicious. Unfortunately, we didn’t have room for dessert. The service was terrific. Our waiter was Jeff S. Very nice, attentive, and made wonderful suggestions of what to try. We will be back if we visit Indianapolis again.
Highly recommend! Steak and Lobster tail were amazing. Shrimp Cocktail was perfect!
Amazing!!!! Everything was great!!
We've been waiting for almost two years to drive from Columbus Oh to Indianapolis for St Elmo's. The cocktail is great from the store, but it's amazing to have there. So much hotter and so good. We can't wait to come back.
The food was absolutely incredible and the service was as well! Everything was so amazing that we decided to go twice during the week we were in INDY.
Fantastic time with awesome food & service!
Visited while on business a couple years ago. Wanted to visit with the wife while on personal trip to Indy. Great experience, good food. A classic restaurant.
Food was just average at best
Shrimp Cocktail sauce was excellent
Bread pudding for dessert- it was poor
My wife and I celebrated our 31st anniversary and enjoyed our evening at St Elmo’s. Our waiter Jake did a very good job with service and the food was delicious. We were in the bottom part of the restaurant and there were several large parties around us so it got very loud in the room. Despite that, we had a nice evening.
Took my boyfriend there for his birthday. It was a very nice evening.
Always dine at St. Elmo’s when passing through the area. One of two favorite steakhouses in the US. Don’t even need to see a menu: shrimp cocktail, wedge salad, 8 oz filet with baked potato. Glass of Cabernet Sauvignon or a bottle if husband will share. Can’t wait to return when traveling again.
We had an amazing meal and our waiter was fantastic.
Such an amazing place to spend an anniversary!
Service from the moment we walked in was impeccable. I ordered the prime rib... which was 38oz of sheer perfection!
We will be back hopefully for many more years to come.
Wonderful food and service. All items served were properly prepared and delicious. I would highly recommend the Lobster bisque. Service was attentive and recommendations were very good.
2 of us were in town for my birthday, and St Elmo came highly recommended. It absolutely lived up to our hopes. The reserve wine list is extensive and reasonably priced. Service was prompt and very friendly. David was superb, including taking us on a tour of the wine cellar and explaining some of the history of the restaurant. Just an excellent overall experience, and I’ll be back for certain.
I went with my boyfriend for his birthday and we had an awesome nigy
Our waiter was Phillip and he was outstanding. We had great service and great food and he took great care of us while being very funny and sassy. We brought people who had never been there before and they can’t wait to go back. We were celebrating two birthdays and they received complimentary desserts.
Didn’t cook my steak to my preference so I was disappointed I had to send it back!
It was our 27th anniversary and it was a beautiful evening in our waiter Steve was phenomenal thank you for a beautiful and warm experience.
Food and service was good. Would return. Shrimp cocktail is a must
Amazing service, atmosphere, and food. We had a party of 14 and all went smoothly from reservation through arrival and dinner.
This was an awesome experiance from the beginning, valet parking, was given an anniversary card when we checked in and a dessert as well. Jodi did an excellant job in taking care of us and the chefs prepared our food to absolute perfection! We will definatly be back soon!
We are frequent fliers at St Elmo and this was probably the worst experience we’ve had. The air conditioner was blasting over top of us, the server brought me the wrong steak, and when informed I ordered something else she was apologized and put in a “rush” order. I ate my potatoes and was fine with this but it came out in 10 minutes and was pretty well under cooked when I originally asked for medium. Still had to pay full price. She wasn’t overly friendly or fun as other servers we have had in the past. Not to mention all that is going on with COVID there, you would think all servers would be over the top accommodating and friendly. Don’t need to go back for awhile.
We had a beautiful anniversary and birthday celebration at St. Elmo!
Phenomenal as always. First time back since pandemic and, with the exception of fewer tables and everyone reading masks, it felt the same. Same great good and service.
appalled waiter approached table with hands full of dirty glasses
Food was amazing! Services by Jeff was really good. Thanks for the wonderful experience.
One of my favorite restaurants. Classic. Highly recommended.
Great food, reasonable prices given reputation and portion sizes. Food actually came out too quick as we didn’t finish soup when meals came. Seated right away with reservations on a Friday night. Waiter Philip was top class.
Brought my wife here for our celebration. It was awesome as usual
Excellent steps to make you feel safe and comfortable in light of Covid. Avoid the bone-in filet...too dry.
Passing thru Indianapolis and was recommended to us by friends. So glad we stopped in for dinner. Steak was excellent, service was first class.
Awesome as always. Clearly Saint Elmo is not a cheap place to eat. If you want cheap, go to steak and shake! My wife and I moved here in 2013 and have enjoyed our anniversary dinner and typically one other visit every year since then. The establishment has never let us down. I also enjoy taking visitors there as well. Some of my favorites are the brussels sprouts, of course the shrimp cocktail, the ribeye, and lobster.
Food was wonderful. One of the best steaks Ive had. Ambience was classicsl and well done. The white chocolate blueberry bread pudding was amazing as well. I’ll definitely return!
St. Elmo Steak House is rated 4.8 stars by 17679 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.