St. Elmo Steak House
Indy's best steakhouse!
Book your next event with us
Phenomenal as always!
I was not near as impressed with the quality of food this time around. I love the atmosphere and will return, hoping this was a one off time thing.
Thank you for sharing your feedback Troy. We would like to extend our apologies for your disappointing experience. Please check your inbox as I have sent you a private message to discuss in detail the issue noted above. Thank you.
Excellent place for dinner, totally lived up to the hype.
At least 30 visits in the last 15yrs. WORST ANNIVERSARY DINNER EVER. I am disappointed beyond belief on the service on this trip. ZERO response from Management or Huse.
Thank you for reaching out Richard. We would like to extend our apologies for your disappointing experience. Please check your inbox as I have sent you a private message to discuss in detail the issue noted above. Thank you.
Our table was where the servers were putting clean wine glasses and we could not fully enjoy our meal because it was always interrupted. They were constantly putting the glasses away right by our table. My boyfriend even had to move his chair so they could reach the shelf
Excellent food and top notch customer service. You always feel important when dining at St. Elmo's.
Overall amazing , would have rather to be seating in the dining room than in the cellar .
First time but highly recommended. Made reservation through Open Table, had to wait less than 5 minutes on a super busy night to get seated. Our server was very knowledgeable about the entire menu. The food was fantastic, the shrimp cocktail is a MUST! Love, Love!
Best steak and shrimp cocktail anywhere. Excellent service
We had a party of 7, so they gave us a private room upstairs. It was wonderful! It made the night comfortable and special.
Great! Liked our experienced waiter. The only neg was they were out of prime rib.
Wonderful experience as always. Great service, great food, lively environment.
Doug was my server and he met high expectations. The service was amazing all together.
Ordered the porter house, great steak, can't go wrong with shrimp cocktail.
Not the best steak. Had the dry aged filet and it was hard to cut and chew. Not what filet should be. The shrimp cocktail was excellent
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback Janice. We would like to extend our apologies for your disappointing experience. Please check your inbox as I have sent you a private message to discuss in detail the issue noted above. Thank you.
Our waiter, Phillip, made for an outstanding dining experience!
Excellent food. Top notch quality. Would totally go back. One
Great experience. 1933 lounge upstairs is an awesome start and the service food and experience was great
Lovely way to celebrate a birthday. Nice touch with the birthday card! Meal was delicious!
Always top drawer. Service attentive not obtrusive, steaks wonderful, and wine list extensive.
Superior in every way.
Always stop here on my way through Indy. Love the food and service.
Everything, from the staff down to the attention to detail was outstanding. The only reason I gave it 4 out of 5 stars for value is because my husband's bone-in (prime) filet was unexpectedly fatty. The server said this was a rare occurrence, which we believe as we've been there before, and wouldn't take "no" to a free dessert. Truly a great place and experience overall!
And BTW the best Bourdon Cake desert ever!!!
We’ve been in Indianapolis for the WWETT show for just under a week. We researched places to eat and St. Elmo was high on the list. We were able to work the schedule to get reservations on our last night here. Walking into the entrance set the stage as a cool, good old boys, kinda vibe. Darker wood, darker carpet, red lamps. Just felt homey and comfortable. Our waiter, George, was awesome! So much fun and informative. The cocktails were delicious and large. Great pours here, but still a smooth drink you can enjoy. The food, O.M.G. Amazing. My filet was just like butter, cooked perfectly. The mashed potatoes tasted like a fully loaded baked potato, amazing and smooth. We asked for a recommendation for a bottle of wine and gave our price range. George came up with 3 different choices and we picked one based on the name. Excellent bottle that paired perfectly with our meal. It was a 2012 that had a bit of sediment. George poured it perfectly into the decanter to greatly minimize the sediment which meant we could easily drink the wine, and we enjoyed it greatly!! Kinda sad this is our last night as we would have eaten here nightly if we could! Can’t wait until we’re back again next year!
Great as always but was loud enough we couldn't all hear the server when he was trying to explain the specials and asking us for drinks and dinner. Otherwise, outstanding as always.
The food and service was amazing. Our server, Rico Alvarez has worked there for 31 years! He was wonderful. A must go place to eat!
I’m sure it’s not always as loud as it is when our group of contractors come to town! Any way you look at it, still by far the best steak house in town!!! Gotta get the shrimp!
The food was superb, the ambience excellent and the staff attentive. Billy, our server, was well informed about all aspects of the menu and wine list. We had a great time and thoroughly enjoyable meal.
Food is always great. The service is unmatched, anywhere. Thanks to Jeff our server ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Good service but poor quality bottom end food.......
Great place, enjoyed our evening. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone
Excellent as always. Loud, but that’s typical for our convention crowd in town. Wouldn’t want to go to any other steak house!
If you’re looking for the best steak and service in downtown Indianapolis. This is the place!! Amazing food and service every time.
Food was delicious and everything was enjoyable. Pricey but very tasty.
First time there. Great service, great food. Will definitely go again
1st visit. Lovely, relaxing environment! Our waiter was very knowledgeable with an outstanding personality. The food and drinks were delectable. Perfect steak!
I ordered the aged ribeye thinking it would be the best taste........my buddy ordered the porterhouse and it was a lot better tasting steak. Plus my ribeye was burnt on one end
Waiter was not attentive and didn’t bring our drink after it was ordered nor our soup. He didn’t come back to check on us