St. Elmo Steak House
Indy's best steakhouse!
Book your next event with us
I have been a repeat customer for many years. This is the first time I found our waiter to be overly aggressive and somewhat unwelcoming. Because I brought friends in from out of town this was a bit of a disapointment
Great food, great waiter.
Awesome! Doesn't matter what cut of steak you get, it is always perfect.
St. Elmo’s has ruined Steak for me. (I don’t want any other steak) and Jeff has ruined Custmer Service as well. You owe it to yourself to find out what I mean.
consistent quality steaks / good wine selections / great dessert (bread pudding.........)
St Elmo’s always delivers. Excellent food with high quality service. If you live in Indy or visiting...St Elmo’s will deliver a great dining experience
Only two suggestions. I overheard the people at the table behind me talking about being offered a tour of the facility. I would have enjoyed this tremendously. It would also be nice for those of us who don't love horseradish to have that option for the shrimp cocktail.
Drink was spot on! Food was spot on! Service was spot on!
Worlds best resteraunt. I have been at least 12 times and I have never had a complaint about one thing.
St Elmo’s does not disappoint. Great meal. Great service. A must when in Indianapolis. My daughter and I had a great meal. The lobster bisque was wonderful!
This was our first visit and we loved the whole experience with the restaurant itself. We, however were less that pleased with the valet parking. We visit several restaurants downtown, always valet, and have never had the experience with valet that we had Saturday. It was very cold outside when we left the restaurant, there were several people waiting outside and we soon found out they were all waiting for their vehicles. We ended up waiting outside in the cold for 1 1/2 hours. The guy in charge was very short, unapologetic,and basically acted like we should expect this when we come downtown. I'm sure he was overwhelmed, but this is not the way to attract people downtown. It wasn't just us, he was this way to everyone. I know that he was directing things for both St Elmo's and Harry & Izzy's. I hope this problem gets resolved because we do enjoy coming downtown, but this was ridiculous!
St Elmo is a great old fashion steak house. We had a reservation for 8 at 7:30 on a Sat night. We got right in on time. Service was great. Had a couple orders of shrimp cocktails which were fantastic. Everyone thought their food was great. Had a fish order and the rest were steaks all cooked perfect. My third time there and would definitely would go back.
It's a beautiful restaurant and the service was AMAZING. Andy is one of the two or three best waiters I've ever had. The shrimp cocktail is fantastic. The green beans and the steak were very good, though my expectations may have been too high. I was looking forward to a bit better for the price. Still, it was a 4.5-star dinner and a memorable experience.
Fantastic food - the shrimp cocktail doesn't disappoint!
Great atmosphere Jordan was very good waiter. Gave us all info we needed.
Outstanding service, as usual. SE will always be our go-to for family birthday occasions - even though we all drive in from 2 and 3 hours away to celebrate! We wouldn't miss the SE experience! Drinks, Dinner and Desserts - each, over-the-top amazing!
Delicious and great atmosphere! Amazing food and staff was spectacular and knowledgeable.
One of the best dinning experiences i have ever had. Highly recommend it!
Food was excellent. Service was a bit slow, but very good.
Great experience and reservations were right on time. Food was amazing with the cocktail sauce being out of this world. Something my family and I will remember and do again soon.
Fantastic place to eat. The service is great. It is a little pricey but a wonderful place to dine.
As always, perfect service and amazing food! Never disappointing!
Our party had everything from aged NY Strip to Surf and Turf and it was all perfectly cooked and delicious! This was our fourth annual visit and the Shrimp Cocktail never gets cooler. Service was as always first rate.
St. Elmo’s is a SPECIAL place, therefore it should be treated as such. Don’t wear jeans & t-shirt, take off your hat inside & don’t yell and swear, there’s no need for that.
The food is EPIC!! The best steak I’ve ever had & the shrimp cocktail kicked my butt! The service was fantastic, quick and accurate. The ambiance was warm & rustic with historic pictures of Indianapolis all around.
It’s a special place and if you go there once a week, then you’ll take the significance out of a grand meal. Keep it special, keep it rare & let the magic of St Elmo’s take it from there.....
Our server was as amazing! Food, just as good!!! Extremely worth it!!!
Great steak! My son tried the cocktail sauce for the first time and it was a little strong for him, funny because he used alot, he laughed afterwards though! Very nice staff!
Awesome meal. Server was very polite and offered suggestions. Shrimp cocktail was great
Beyond the Shrimp cocktail sauce, everything else was average. There are plenty of great restaurants in Indy offering better food for less cost.
Phillip is the best waiter I have ever had anywhere
I don’t go to Indy without stopping at st Elmo’s. I never order the same thing and it’s always amazing
Always juicy and grilled the way we like them. The service is always cordial and amazing as well. St Elmo's never disappoints. YUMMMMM!!!
The service was slow, luke warm food, and 1 over cooked steak
Amazing place with great food. Always worth a visit twice a year for us and worth the money for sure!
Steaks tend to be undercooked
My husband and I were traveling through Indianapolis and wanted to have dinner at St. Elmo’s. We have dined there 5 or 6 times before and have always enjoyed it. What a disappointment! The table we were seated at was a 2 top, up against a wall and was leaning so badly to one side my husband rolled up his napkin and tried to level it. The restaurant was so loud that we couldn’t hear each other. Our waiter never introduced himself and asked if we knew what we wanted to drink and what appetizers we would like as i was still taking my coat off. He was definitely trying to rush us through. St. Elmo’s has turned into a tourist attraction and is definitely not fine dining except for the price! we have sadly marked St. Elmo’s off our list if go to places.
Excellent service. 5 star restaurant. Food was incredible, but a bit overwhelming with the portion sizes. Shrimp cocktail is AMAZING! Lobster Bisque was phenomenal. Very expensive, but worth the money to try here. Great place!
Wonderful food and service. Only negative was the noise level. It was difficult to have a conversation. But, we were expecting that.
The 8pz filet was Delicious but the shrimp cocktail, which they are known for, was average at best. The shrimp were of poor quality.
I was very disappointed in the shrimp cocktail
Morgan Freeman was the best waiter and the food was amazing!!
Library section louder than other parts of St Elmo's.
Fantastic decor and history. Service is impeccable along with the food.