St. Elmo Steak House
Indy's best steakhouse!
Book your next event with us
Try the dry aged filet. Worth the extra $. Unbelievable flavor
As advertised great steak...awesome service. Ill be back for sure.
Went for anniversary dinner and had a great time. First time experience and was worth the money
Have ate there several times. This was the worst food ever had there Cost way to much for bad food
Very meh. My steak was over cooked, another in group was WAY undercooked. Very mediocre for the money.
I wanted to treat my son for his 13th Birthday and it was just that! The staff were amazing and wished him happy birthday as soon as we walked in, they all signed a card for him and our waiter even treated him to a creme brulee bday treat. Their food is amazing and their service is over the top. My son wants to make this a bday tradition every year now! St.Elmo's cant be beat!
I would even recommend St. Elmo Steak House to someone that was not a friend. It's just that good.
Great service! We were initially sat in a very busy, bright, and crowded area of the restaurant which really would have taken away from our nice dinner. When my partner talked to the hostess and asked if it would be possible to be sat somewhere a little bit less crowded and bright she moved us to a wonderfully intimate room which was much less noisy and bright. We couldn't have been more thrilled about this, as it was such a special evening for us.
Did the Sunday special and it was nice. Felt a bit rushed by servers, could just be me though.
Wonderful experience. Sarah was on top of her game and made sure everything came out how we wanted. Thanks for doing such a great job!
What more is there to say? Delicious food, excellent service, relaxed atmosphere. Perfect!
Had not been there for awhile. Everything was as I remembered. Food and service was exceptional. Definitely one of best in Indianapolis. Looking forward to returning.
The food and service were over the top. The taste of everything was excellent. The Elmo Colas were like no other drink. Roxanne's service was prompt and delightful. She was able to answer all of our questions and she was a delight. Super experience.
Took my wife to St. Elmo's for our 38th anniversary. Had the 3 course Sunday special. The blue cheese dressing made the salad outstanding. The main course of filet mignon, smashed potatoes, and crisp green beans was just right for our appetite, barley had room for raspberry topped cheesecake.
Can't wait to go back again.
This was my first time here and it did not disappoint . Lobster bisque was good. I had the ribeye and it was excellent . Will be back!
The food and service was excellent. We were seated in a brightly lit basement by the bathroom. Dismal ambience.
Birthday! Everything was fantastic
Known for their steak and shrimp. I looked up “best steakhouse in Indianapolis” and liked what I saw at St Elmo. Little did I know just how good their Shrimp was! $40 Sunday feature—absolutely incredible steak and shrimp. Impeccable service. Better than expected and expected to be great.
Absolutely delicious steaks, sides, desserts, and drinks.
Impeccable service, outstanding food! Worth the 2 hour drive. Fantastic restaurant!
The best night out we’ve ever had!! Andy was FANTASTIC and our meal was AMAZING!! Perfect first visit. Can’t wait to return!
The food was phenomenal!! Best meal I’ve ever had! Truly! Can’t wait to come back!
We hadn't been here in a long time as we now live in Ohio. But the addition of the 1933 lounge is wonderful for before or after dinner. We found the food to be as we remembered. Most of all we were extremely impressed with the service we received from Kate.
Great atmosphere, food and service! I would highly recommend St. Elmo's. The steak was one of the best and loved the crab mac and the brussel sprouts.
This was me and my wife first time. It was an amazing experience the food was amazing and the service was excellent. I definitely recommend for anyone that hasn't been to definitely go.
One of the best meals and experiences in a restaurant I have had in my entire life. Seriously.
The best steak and pork chops we've ever had, not too mention the baked potato was amazing. Be sure to save room for dessert.
Best steak we have ever had. The service was FANTASTIC!
Ordered the tomahawk ribeye, most expensive steak on the menu, medium rare. Waiter said “cool red center”, steak was refrigerator cold, raw, and completely under seasoned, as in non existent. It was amazingly the most expensive steak I’ve ever had, and the worst steak at the same time. I typically order steaks rare so when I say “raw” I am not exaggerating.
Outstanding food and wait staff, certainly a cut above the rest. Was a little pricey but once in a while treat makes it worth it.
The food is always unsurpassed and the atmosphere is warm, private, quiet enough and brings me peace.
This is the first time I have to walk away from a reservation, they sent me on to the bar and they gave my table away. Also they were extremely rude.
I will not be coming back,
Everything was Excellent
The steaks were cooked perfectly! More importantly everyone wishes us a happy anniversary (they definitely read their notes) and the server gave us our time to drink and eat, did not rush us at all. Also made gluten free (celiac) very easy to accommodate. Thank you for the beautiful signed anniversary card too! So thoughtful !
Best steak in Indianapolis. Navy bean soup as an appetizer is outstanding. Of course...shrimp cocktail!
Overall the night was great. There was an issue with our steaks not being good properly but our waiter resolved the issue quickly. There was also kids in the restaurant which took away from an adult night out but didn't ruin the evening.
Tables crammed together. Noisy. Steak was mediocre at best and definitely not worth the price. Server was great. Would recommend other places well above this.
Great place, great food, and great service