St. Elmo Steak House

Wonderful all around. Food staff everything shrimp cocktail a must

Since 1982 anytime business brings me to Indianapolis the only place I go to dinner is Saint Elmo’s. The quality of food, not just the steaks but the best shrimp cocktail (sauce is perfect), the service and the ambience are always five stars.
I have recommended Saint Elmo’s to anyone that goes to Indianapolis over the years and after this visit I will continue to do so!!!

Always enjoy St Elmo's, never sad to have gone. The shrimp cocktail is the best and the filet sliders are fantastic!!

One of the best places in Indy for steak. Great place to have private dining for work events.

We love St. Elmo’s and am always very happy with the service and the food. St. Elmo’s is one of the top restaurants in Indiana for sure!

Great experience and friendly staff and great food

Great service, lots of character, and best Gin Martini Up in Indiana.

Very special

As always, just wonderful! We were traveling through Indianapolis, a place we have been often for work. And, as we have done many times before, made a point of stopping and sharing a meal here. St. Elmo’s never disappoints. Thank you!

Excelent service. Best porterhouse, ribeye, and lobster soup. Amazing food and environment

The service was slow on refills, the navy bean soup was luke warm and the description of the mild shrimp cocktail sauce was way off! It was almost as painful as the hot sauce. I probably will choose another restaurant before we try St. Elmos again.

First impression. Water was tepid, no ice. Bread wasn’t warm enough to melt the hard butter. The steaks were both undercooked, and mixed when brought to the table. No one waited to be sure that they were right. Later, our server came by and tried to make it right.

We took my mom and her husband there to celebrate their 1st anniversary. You guys knocked it out of the park! An anniversary card, champagne, and dessert on the house! You guys do it the right way! Thanks for creating a memorable night out!

It was a great experience. Our first time there but so many friends have told us how amazing St. Elmos was and I agree!

We had a great meal. One of the best, if not the best steak I’ve ever had.

Love St. Elmo's! Brought our kids and had a wonderful dinner. Great food and service! Shrimp cocktail is everything I wanted and more.

Outstanding meal and experience...do the Shrimp cocktail absolutely

LOVE THIS PLACE, FOOD, HISTORY. ALWAYS THE BEST FOOD

Doug was an amazing waiter. Much appreciated.

I have been to the restaurant a few times and always had amazing service and food. This time, my steak was overcooked (no pink and ordered medium rare). They did bring me another but my husband and friends had finished before I was served, so I ended up leaving most of it. No discount on our bill (we didn't ask for it but would have been a nice offer). Several times, we had to remind the waiter to being things too. I'm sure it was a fluke in the normally high quality of service we expect but disappointed it happened when we brought our friends for the first time.

The rib eye was bland, no flavor at all. Very disappointing

Everything was fantastic

As always, St. Elmo’s was a perfect location for a family holiday dinner! Food was delicious, we never felt rushed, and our server Glenn was outstanding! We have been coming to St. Elmo’s for years and look forward to continuing the tradition for many more!
Thank you!

We always love coming to St. Elmos. Glenn Ware is our favorite waiter he just makes our experience even better.

Our waiter, David B., had been with the restaurant almost 30 years and was outstanding. Food and drink amazing every time. We don’t live as close as we used to, but had the chance to make reservations to stop for our anniversary on a drive through Indy heading home after the holiday.

From the beginning of my family’s reservation until we walked out, everything was absolutely fabulous!!! Dave, our server was awesome!!!

The food was excellent but was a little disappointed in the service.

It was my birthday and we requested George for our waiter. He is excellent, well organized and very attentive to all his parties. Bartender Mike G makes the best drinks.

Love this place. We were your regular old Ron Swanson’s. What up meat sweats!!!!!!

Ordered the filet, best steak I have ever had. Cooked to perfection. Highly recommend. Excellent service as well.

Couldn’t have asked for a better experience!! Highly recommend

Daughter and son in law were in town for the holiday. We decided to eat at St. Elmo’s before the Pacers game and tree lighting. We really enjoyed the food and service received. It was a great beginning to wonderful night.

I love eating here as it just gets better each time I’m able to come in. My brother and sister n law comes in from TN every year, Tommys Birthday is the 26th so it’s always birthday dinner on the 27th.
I made reservations online this year instead of calling so in the special request box I put it was my brothers birthday in hopes you would put a Happy Birthday Tommy placard or card as in the past but there wasn’t anything, maybe you all don’t do that any long so maybe I just need to do it over the phone.
Bill done an amazing job and we were very appreciative of him and of St Elmos.

I was disappointed in my bone in filet. I probably got 5 or 6 bites and was left with 75% bone fat and tendons. Not a lot of flavor or crab in the king crab Mac. However our server was very attentive and accommodating. They made sure the steaks were cooked well and told us ahead of time how they prepare them. The shrimp as always was the best part!

The food was good. The ambience was not what I expected from a steakhouse. Lights were very bright and it was noisy. The server we had was a total dud. Our waters were always filled, food was served quickly and on time. The server refused to recommend things. I asked about a few bottles of wine and he admitted knowing nothing. Then when I asked about desserts he recommended he told me it was a “trick” and refused to answer. Overall I wouldn’t go back to this restaurant.

Excellent food and service! Great facility. Will definitely come back next time I am in Indianapolis.

We took our newly wed brother, new wife, & son for their first visit. They were very impressed.
Great special treat meal.

Our server Michael was outstanding, food and service as always were top notch.

Ordered two steak dinners. Both dinners were prepared and tasted great. Drinks were superb. Service was excellent. First time going here, and will return in a heartbeat. Highly recommend it!!

Great food, service and we,ll be back daughter wife and sc on lovefbit.