We loved our waiter.

Service was outstanding. I thought food was ok for the premium price. Steaks were very good. Side dishes not that great esp. cream spinach which was cool and too much cheese on top. Onion rolls good, sourdough not so much. Chicken quite yummy. Roasted asparagus great. Mashed potatoes meh
Not quite as good as in the past

Food was nothing special.
I think it's more of something to do just to say you did it but wouldnt plan a special occasion there.
Honestly alot better places to spend $250

Great servicing staff members. Very polite and family friendly.

I took my hubby for Father's Day and what an experience! Great food! Great service!

Truly enjoyed our meal and our service was great

Our 40th wedding anniversary. Very enjoyable. We were given a complimentary dessert for the occasion.

The food was incredible as always. Our waiter, Phillip, was very knowledgeable and extremely personable! The steaks were cooked exactly how we like them

The only thing I would change is the one dining room with no windows is very dark and dated. It could use some modernizing to lighten it up a bit. But I would not let that stop me from going. This is a fantastic restaurant!

Had a great eveneing. Phillip our waiter was excellent.

Server advised us that the steaks were cooked rarer than traditional. So we ordered a little more well done then we would normally, it was not the case. Steaks came out as I would have expected, not as we were advised.

Order it normally.

Great food, waitress awesome

St Elmo’s NEVER disappoints! The food is amazing and the service is like none other in the city.

Wonderful meal (tho a little pricey) and as always, wonderful service from Andy. Will be back again.

Overall it was a great experience, with great food and service. It was a little pricey, but the taste made it much more worth it.

The dining room needs a face lift.

Best in Indy. Never disappoints. Always recommend to anyone who is looking for a great song experience.

Excellent steak house. The atmosphere was terrific . Have eaten in many upscale places around the Cincinnati area and other areas around the country. This was definitely one of the tops as far as quality goes.

Great service, great food and the ambiance was awesome. Took my wife and son her for our 26th, Fathers Day and an outstanding day on the pitching mound. Great way to celebrate.

Great food and service!! Even the the guy bussing our table was pleasant, and efficient. The food was terrific and our waiter was really great!

Elmo's, as always, was great. My only concern was the proliferation of balding, wanna-"ballers" wearing blue tooth headsets at dinner, along with the patented jeans with sport coat and tee shirt combo. I even heard one say "I want you to make my martini strong." to his waiter.

A martini is a glorified glass of vodka. There is no such thing as a strong or weak martini...go buy some propecia before you return to your gated community of townhomes.

My wife & I loved our meal, and our waiter was fantastic. I expect nothing less from St. Elmo's. There's a reason it's an institution in town.

We love it! We come here every time we're in town. Jeffrey is the best!

Outstanding dinner, service,ambiance. Not a tourist restaurant- it’s reputation is well deserved.

Great first visit for our guest!

Overall, our experience was excellent. Plan to dine at St Elmo's again when we are back in Indy.

This was a retirement dinner. Our server Philip was personable, attentive and lively!

The best steaks in town. And the service is always good

Wonderful server!! Although one steak was overcooked, the other two were perfect. The one piece of Blueberry Bread Pudding for 3 to share was huge and melted in our mouths. Great place for a memorable meal.

Philip was our server and was fantastic! Food was very good

This restaurant is highly overrted. The aged steak just was not worth the price.

St. Elmo's is a wonderful experience. The staff is fabulous

Great place to bring a clients with its legacy recipes and a historic roots. It's not the restaurant's fault, but the very interactive panhandlers hanging around the front door are discouraging.

Steaks cooked to perfection. Sides had great flavor. Server was extremely knowledgeable and attentive. Shrimp cocktail was great!

Best steakhouse in Indianapolis! Great ambiance and food!

Shrimp was fantastic steak was adequate

Our waiter was friendly and helpful!! We enjoyed having him as our waiter. The food was amazing!

The whole experience is a treat and should be experienced by everyone.

Went for our anniversary and they made us feel very special during our dinner. Food was simply delicious. The shrimp cocktail did not disappoint!!

Birthday dinner in the Husse room and it was amazing. Excellent service and the food was amazing.

Great food and service. We will be back.

Only the third time I’ve had the pleasure to eat here and it’s just as good as always. Grounds of delight with each bite from our table.