35 Day, Dry-aged, Prime Porterhouse
Our House Specialty
Excellent service, great food, and wonderful surroundings- expensive but worth the price for special occasions.
Not worth it. Service was awful. Food is overpriced and very basic.
Carlo and his staff always outperform and make you feel like you are at home. Best quality you can ask for.
We like this restaurant, we went with another couple to celebrate our 49th wedding anmiversary, but, on this visit the service, spotty.
There were only a few patrons. We had just sat down, when the waiter rushed to ask for kind of water and drinks. We asked him for a few minutes so we could settled down. He disappeared, after a while, we had to ask other waiters to get him.
We put the drink, appy and dinner order. When dinner came, we were missing one order. The waiter claimed that our friend didn't order dinner, really? We all heard her order dinner.
She did get her order but had to be sent back because the steak was too rare. We ordered dessert, again a problem, hot fudge sundae came with some cold chocolate syrup, not hot fudge, when we questioned the waiter, he was adamant, so we sent it back. No apologies from the staff.
The Service is impeccable and the food is delicious. Would recommend this restaurant to friends and family.
As always a perfect steak and service.
We always have an awesome meal when we go to Sparkill. The service is fantastic. The food is delicious. And I had a drink St. Germaine martini. So refreshing and great!!! We love going to Sparkill. We never have a bad meal.
Food is outstanding, very friendly staff! Highly recommend ! Very cautious with covid restrictions.
Always consistently great food and excellent service!
The porter house for 2 was exceptional. Flavorful & not chewy like some steaks when ordered “more rare then medium” = My favorite . Oysters were mouth watering excellent & cold as they should be served. Not so thrilled with sides of mushroom caps lacked seasoning. Cottage fries turned out to be potato chips. Ugh My bad probably didn’t read full menu description. Desert came with candle & staff sang Happy Birthday. 🙂 Cheesecake was yum. 2 alcohol drinks each. Bill was over $300 with tip. Bit pricey. Would definitely go back for the steak & oysters. Drink before I get there 😜
The food and service were amazing and I would recommend Sparkhill Steakhouse in a second BUT the tables are eay TOOOOOO close and it doesn't seem as though they cut back on the tables in the dining room. I didn't feel safe at all.
I try different steaks every time I go. Tried the T-Bone this time. Excellent, but still trying to figure out which steak is my favorite. The food is amazing and the staff is outstanding.
Truly amazing experience. Everyone was super attentive to our needs. They made me abs my son’s Valentine’s Day date one to remember!
This place is terrible. $311 for 2 people on a fixed menu. The steak was ok, the crab cakes app came with literally 1 cake. They asked us if we wanted dessert and coffee, we waited 35 minutes for the coffee that never came. The service was not good and it would take a lot to ever try this place again
As I’ve written before, my go to restaurant in Rockland/Bergen. Best value in area. NYC quality steakhouse right in our own backyard minus NYC prices. Best value in the area.
Food was terrific, albeit due to Valentine's Day, the menu was ore fixed, would’ve been nice if you were able to have a choice. Some restaurants during other events like Restaurant Week offer the regular menu or the menu for said event. Overall great experience, although if you order the porterhouse for two depending on your preference when they say medium, try to go for medium-well, since the cut can be pretty thick and a medium may on occasion be a med rare.
The ownership and staff at the Sparkill steakhouse have turned this quiet location into a dining destination. The service is excellent. The choices on the menu will please everyone at the table. The quality of the food is consistently good. Most importantly, as a steakhouse it lives up to its name and presentation and in taste. If you are worried about being too close to people, upstairs is a place with high ceilings and excellent ventilation. Tables are far apart. The serving sizes are good. The bartender has a great feel for original drinks and the wine list is superb. The only reason I don’t go every week is because I like it to seem special when I go back the next time! You can feel confident taking friends or family here for a special night together.
We had such a wonderful time! Celebrated Valentine’s Day a bit early. With our daughter. Service was outstanding. Wine suggestion was great. A bottle of Stags Leap. Appetizers were delicious. Tomatoes prosciutto Burratta was great! But the thick cut bacon was AMAZING!
I had the sirloin. Was undercooked but they took care of that. It was great second time. My husband and daughter shared a porter house for 2. It was awesome they said. Sides (fried and sautéed asparagus) and dessert also so good. We will be back. Was our first trip. Loved it!!
Very friendly and attentive service, food was exceptional and perfectly cooked.
One of my favorite places. The waiters are all great, the food is amazing. My husband and I love this restaurant. Food is consistently good.
We had an enjoyment evening. The porterhouse was done perfectly. Our salads were great. The wine list is extensive.
Ordered the porterhouse for 4. It was cooked to perfection. Service was impeccable and complimentary bubbly at the end added to the special night. Looking forward to going back!
We waited for more than an hour for our food, until we called them no one even noticed. When the food finally came it was clear they forgot us and made it quickly so it wasn't even very good. No one came to apologize and we paid full price. Didn't wait for birthday desert and left most of the food untouched.
Food was excellent. A great location for that special occasion. Drinks menu very overpriced but food was worth the price paid. Service was great and checked in often at the table.
Actually my birthday dinner but we come here frequently. NYC quality steakhouse at suburban prices. Friendly attentive staff My favorite restaurant in the NY Metro area period all things considered (quality, value etc)
Wow. Simply, wow.
Experience a premium steakhouse without traveling to NYC. The food was fantastic and the service was even better.
This is our new Go to special occasion! Food was perfect! No other words needed
Outstanding food and service!! A must dine experience!
The Best around! Food and service is outstanding!!!
Best steak and service in a very long time. Highly recommended!!
First time dining at Sparkill Steakhouse. Had the Bacon Slab, Cottage Fries and Onion Rings, Steak for 2 And it was perfect.
Can’t wait to go back again. The place was very nice , the staff were awesome and the food was as good as it gets.
The food and the service was good. We advised them in advance we were celebrating a birthday. They didn’t do anything special for that but did for another table. However overall it was a good experience and we will return.
Maybe because it is a "steakhouse", I'd stay away from the salmon. It is dry, overcooked. (second time ordering it). Everything is a la carte, so if you like vegetables, the tab rises very quickly from an already overpriced entree.
Beautiful restaurant, Service was mediocre, food was ok, not what I expected for a steak house. Main dish was priced well, but the sides were “family “ style and extremely small for what we paid. The steak was just plopped on a plate, like I just took it off the bbq..... no garnish. Poor presentation.
Would I return? Probably not. Sorry😢
Food is always consistently delicious. Best steak around and attentive service.
Excellent food and service!!!
Food and service was excellent
We had a very nice time at this restaurant. The service was first rate and the food was very good. We had the porterhouse for two which was cooked to perfection.
As always, excellent food with superb service!!! Owners are welcoming and friendly. Would highly recommend!
My husband and I ate at Sparkill’s for our anniversary. The food and service was outstanding! We will be back!
Sparkill Steakhouse is rated 4.7 stars by 679 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.