My girlfriend and I went there for our two year anniversary and we had a great experience! Kevin was our waiter and did phenomenal. We never felt neglected or overwhelmed with attention, there was the perfect balance of help and letting us enjoy the night alone. The food was great and the GM came out to offer us a free desert to help celebrate our anniversary! This place is incredible, when you get there ask for Kevin, he did a stellar job and the GM was very professional! Very impressive to see management walking around and mingling with guests and staff instead of sitting in the back!
Very relaxed and elegant atmosphere. I would definitely recommend this for a more special occasion kind of place. Enjoyed the extensive wine list, the specials as well as the menu in general. Our food was delicious and the portions were just right. There was live music on a Saturday night which added to the whole experience.
Not a fan of making a reservation and then having to wait 15min for our table. Table service and food were great! Will definitely go back when in FoCo.
Excellent food and good service with an old time steakhouse environment. The prices are quite high and only one side dish is included with dinner. For a $40 steak, I think a salad should be included.
We had a great night celebrating our anniversary. The service was great and the food was exceptional.
Fantastic dinner and excellent service! A wonderful way to celebrate our Anniversary! Would absolutely recommend Sonny Lubick’s Steakhouse, from our appetizers to our dessert everything was delicious!
My wife and i were celebrating our 5 year anniversary . We enjoyed the calamari for an appetizer and we both had lobster tail and a steak
Always impressed by the food and the staff! Everything was made just as we'd hoped from the fantastic cocktails to the prime rib, the filet, and the creme brulee. Thank you!
My fiancé & I absolutely enjoyed our food! He ordered the surf & turf & I got the lobster ravioli & it was delicious! We will definitely be coming back.
Food was delicious. Went for the oysters. Service was great.
Food is always consistent. Worst service experienced in 8 years! Server was more interested in chatting about kids to other guests than attending to groups in serving area. Manager had to take dessert order - poor showing buy server, good pick up by manager at the time.
Went to Sonny Lubick for an early Valentine's Day dinner, service and atmosphere were excellent. My wife and I both ordered the filet, it was just a bit dry and slightly overcooked, but nothing to complain about, excellent flavor and the wine selections were fantastic. Would recommend going here for the outstanding service, quiet atmosphere, and great wine.
Our dinner was around valentine's Day, so the special on the menu we chose was Chateaubriand which was for two. We also chose the table-side salad which was prepared at the table, adding ingredients of your choice. The meat was excellent, tender, and tasty, and was accompanied by roasted vegetables. We like it served with Bernaise sauce that we found out later was an additional charge. The service was not up to Nico's standards (previous owner) but was very good. We plan on making this our special occasion restaurant.
Service was great. Had the bison steak and was very flavorful although I’ve had more tender bison before. Oysters on the half shell were outstanding. Great service. Friendly staff that checked on us often enough to be helpful without being overbearing. Desert was a little underwhelming compared to the rest of the dinning experience.
Excellent food and great wait staff. Fantastic wine list.
Sonny's is a favorite. Food is always fantastic! Will be back again for sure...
Best Steakhouse in NoCo!
We arrived at the time of our reservation, only to be told that we could not be seated as they did not have a server. We were shuffled to the bar, however, we were never waited on in the bar. The bartender did not come to our table to inquire about drinks. Next we were off to the dining room, evidently, the server had arrived.
The meal was good. The service was good. The beginning to the evening did not really set a positive start to the evening.
Excellent food quality and superb service. We enjoy dinner and wine was an good pair with the meat - thanks
We were very impressed. The staff was very friendly and walked us thru the menu. They had some kind of problem getting our food out to us as quickly as they wanted to so they didn't charge us for the wine. They were very apologetic and comforting. We are hoping to return again very soon. Thank you for making our 39th wedding anniversary special.
Steak was not hot and not medium well as we ordered it. Was our anniversary and told them that when we made reservation but our waiter didn’t even know. Nothing special about the evening. Did get a free desert once we told them it was our anniversary, but thought it would be a little more special occasion than it was.
Food was.good and service was good as well. Will go back for sure.
Great food, service was delightful and love the atmosphere.
The staff was very gracious and accommodating. They compensated us for a little longer wait time and made sure we were taken care of despite some confusion about our dietary needs. We will definitely make Sonny Lubick’s a dining favorite spot!
I took my daughter to Sonny Lubicks for her 18th birthday. Your staff made this an easy and enjoyable occasion. Thanks to Justin and Stosh (sounds like a premier cigar :). We we be back with the family for graduation.
We eat at Sonny Lubick‘s about once a month, either in the dining room or in the bar. We love the atmosphere, the service and the food. Three of us ate here on Friday night in the dining room. We all ordered something different – fillet, ribeye, and spareribs. Everyone’s meal was cooked perfectly. The service by Greg was excellent. We shared the flourless chocolate cake for dessert, which is always excellent. Highly recommend.
Great food and wine selection
Great chance that we’ll be back!
Steaks were better than the prime rib, which the waiter correctly identified in advance of our order. Food overall was fine, but below the quality of similarly priced restaurants in Washington, DC, where we were visiting from. Bourbon selection very modest for a steak house. Atmosphere/decor below average. Other meals in Ft. Collins were more inspiring.
I loved the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room in a friends home. I definitely would return to try more dishes. The entree's were fantastic, the staff was wonderful, and the wine selection was amazing.