The steak was probably the worst I have ever had at a restaurant. It was cooked the right temperature, but the meat was awful. The best part of this restaurant was the corn chowder and the fact there was a bar located right next door.
We gave this restaurant 3 stars just because we have found the food in Jackson to be average at most restaurants. It was pretty empty the night we were there but the food was good. We had the corn chowder but it was more of a creamy potato soup. The shrimp appetizer was delicious. The panzanella salad would have been better if they used fresh croutons. They seemed to be from a bag.
Excellent variety of delicious entrees on their dinner menu. Attentive wait-staff. An enjoyable meal was had by all-- 3 of us had the steelhead trout (SUPER YUMMY), one had the walleye (very tasty) and one had the ribeye steak which was cooked to perfection. You can't go wrong in eating here.
Very fun, Wild West style restaurant. Food was good too
The service was a bit slow. Dinner which was one appetizer and 6 entrees took around 2 hours. Yes, I enjoy a slow paced meal, but this just seemed very slow. I also didn’t like that the salad came with the meal, it only comes before if you ask, and our waitress did not tell us. We ordered the Bison Tenderloin and the ribeye. The Bison Tenderloin was good, probably should have ordered rare instead of medium rare, it was a bit dry. The ribeye was not good, didn’t have any flavor. The spicy shrimp appetizer was amazing, especially the sauce. We would probably go back, but if we had limited time, we would choose somewhere else.
We were very excited to eat at the Silver Dollar for Christmas dinner. The prime rib was tough and cold when served, and I returned my risotto with root vegetables- I added chicken to it. When it was delivered to the table the smell was not appetizing, but I still gave it a good three bites before I sent it back.
On the upside, a lot of history there, and the flourless chocolate torte was fantastic!
Overall, overpriced and we had several better meals in Jackson.
Always good food and good times, great service, great staff
We ate in the bar because the dining room was full, food was amazing, great atmosphere and wonderful service! We will go back!
The salad was crisp and fresh. The burgers tasty and thick. The elk chili tasty with large tender chunks of meat. The spare ribs appetizer over corn was spot on. We tried a local beer that had a light refreshing taste. We were throughly satisfied with each of our choices. Our server was very knowledgeable and personable.
Anniversary dinner. After we were seated, the waiter made initial contact, then disappeared for 20-25 minutes. I’ll note here that we were the only customers in the room at that time. When he returned, I ordered a dinner salad and a 10 oz ribeye, medium well. No parmesean cheese was requested on the salad; however, when the salad arrived, it was covered in parmesean cheese. He took it back and returned with the correct order. Then the steak arrived; it was dropped off and he disappeared. I cut into the steak and was bleeding, it was medium rare, if that. At this point, I had enough and ate what I could. My wife flagged him down, told him it was raw and needed to go back on the grill. I told him never mind. The manager (Kate) stopped by to ask how our dinner was so I gave her the details above. She apologized and said this was not the standard the restaurant operates to. She took care of our bill, even though I told her we would pay it. Not sure I will go back again