We work with you to customize the menu for your celebration and budget.
Great experience. We drove 45 minutes to get there from Mechanicsburg because we had an overnight guest from the Uk and wanted to take her somewhere that we knew she would appreciate. As it turned out she had very complex dietary restrictions and the chef bent over backwards to accommodate. Couldn't ask for better service and the food was delicious!
Restaurant Sidney never disappoints. We've patronized it since it's inception and are treated with kindness and respect.
We had a simply outstanding experience at Sidney. The Halibut and Pork Loin entrees each had very interesting, complex flavors happening, which made them a dining experience. We can't wait to go back!
The wait staff was outstanding and the food superb. It was a special occasion and my parents were treated like royalty. We were the only ones in the dining room which made it easy for my father to hear and participate in our conversations which was an Extra special accommodation.
Very good meal
Great good, great people, great time.
I have never been disappointed in the food or service at Sidney. It's a bit of a mix between a neighborhood gem and fine dining, simultaneously creating the ambiance of a special night with warmth and familiarity. All of our meals were very well prepared and properly served. The wines list offered an interesting and affordable selection. Always recommend!
I love this restaurant. Every time I go I am never disappointed. The cocktail were superb, first course was a blast of flavor as was the main course. The dessert was beyond good. I love eating out, and travel all over. I am always suprised as this little place in the middle of nowhere is one of the best. I compare the food to Emerils Delmonicos in the big easy.
Sidney once more lives up to its sterling reputation! Our spicy shrimp appetizers - superb. My wife's monkfish tail was well prepared, but a bit underseasoned. My halibut was a generous portion and extremely delicious. The finale, a creme brulee, was the perfect finish.
It was extraordinarily hot in the restaurant. You literally were sweating sitting still at your table. It was unclear if the air conditioning wasn’t working, or was non-existant. It was truly 10 degrees hotter inside than outside. There was a table of eight that was extremely loud, as well. While that was not the fault of the restaurant, combined with the heat, it made a miserable dining experience. You could not talk with the person next to you. Ery disappointing. You could not be heard. The food was good, but not extraordinary like it often is. Service was fine, but it would have been nice to have been moved to another table in a different room. I’ve been to Sidney Tavern many times, and of course will return. It was just an off night. The loud rude people in the dining room were a good reminder of what is, and what is not proper dining etiquette.
Sidney is one of our favorite restaurants. We have eaten there at least 20 times. The food is always delicious; serving sizes are just right for us. Prices are appropriate for the quality. There is a quiet side room to accommodate small parties in a more intimate and quiet setting -- that's our favorite way to experience Sidney. For couples or smaller groups, you can choose to sit in the main restaurant, which is small and still feels intimate, or to sit in the "bar" area, which is also very nice. Service is attentive but not overbearing.
It’s been awhile since we dined at Sydney. Had a great cheeseburger. Delicious. Amy was our server & she made it fun. A keeper.
Sidney's was great. I was disappointed that, when I made my reservation, I was asked if the event was a special occasion. It was, but the staff didn't seem to know that. I think that if the question is asked and answered through Open table, then that information should be passed along to the staff. We were celebrating 2 graduations so it would have been nice if a note was made on the reservation and the host acknowledged it. In general, the staff at Sidney don't exactly have warm personalities. One or two of the servers are friendly but those are the exception rather than the rule.
If you get seated in the pub, hope for a sober and courteous bar patron . Loud mouth giggles and voice were very annoying and made our conversation very difficult. So on your way in take note
My guest enjoyed the burger (ordered med rare & came as ordered), mushroom soup, and farm specialty drink. My burger was well done and I ordered a med rare burger, mushroom soup was warm at best. Service, by Nick, was EXCELLENT.
I absolutely love Sydney Tavern. We always have wonderful, creative, amazing food and great service. I love the old building and the atmosphere of going somewhere special. Will definitely go back and would definitely recommend to everyone.
Sidney is consistent in it's preparation of interesting menu, but for regular diners, menu may need to be changed up more often.
Great venue for Easter dinner with family. Although the menu was limited on the holiday, the food was excellent.
Our favorite. We’ll try other places but always end up back here for the food and best staff ever!
Amazing as always !!! Great and accommodating to gluten allergies and making substitutions on the entire menu. Service is exceptional and make you feel like the only guest in the room. Highly recommend !
Amazing every time I have come. Highly recommended
Pork was absolutely fantastic. Neat retro/ classy vibe with the age of the building. Bread was really good. Pricing is expensive but on par with similar places. If it wasn’t so far away I’d be back soon.
Very nice place with good food, felt that it was a bit overpriced
1st time at Sidney's and will be back! Everything was delicious and well prepared. Favorite little detail was that there were no salt or pepper shakers on the table!! Great food doesn't need it! Will be back.
Sydney has a chef with imagination. Good at harmonizing meats, starches, garnishes, and sauces. Good wine list. Good service. Been good for 10 -15 years, still is.
Service was slow because it was Valentines Day. Most of the Food was great Some items were good but not great.
Had great dinner on Valentine's Day. The ambiance was very romantic and as always the food was excellent. The staff was very friendly and polite. My only critique was it took a long time to get our main course. I would still recommend it for any special occasion.
Excellent food. Nice ambience. Decent service.
It was Valentine's, so we got as close to pearls as possible with the incredible oysters. That followed, of course, the always amazing oysters - as advertised, sweet and fresh.
Very excellent steak with wine sauce. The cod in pastry was excellent also. The noise level in the front dining room was very acceptable (quiet conversation was possible). A great dinner for a pre Valentines celebration.
I wrongly assumed that a tavern style restaurant would have a more relaxed atmosphere. The food was very good. I just wasn't anticipating the formal dining experience.
Great menu choices and absolutely fabulous preparation! Everything we ordered was so well made and delicious! Bravo Sidney’s! We had eaten here years ago and were so pleasantly surprised at how wonderful the food was this time. Better selection and outstanding delivery.
Both Sidney restaurants are on our favorite go-to list. They have never disappointed -- food is creative not pretentious. Great use of seasonal and local foods. Their specialty drinks are also a lot of fun. The tavern in East Berlin is a great cold winter night place, while the terrace at Sidney's Willougby Run is a perfect summer spot.
Fabulous as always! Such amazing flavor profiles and beautiful food creations. Culinary works of art! Fine food, wonderful atmosphere, great service. I'm never disappointed. My all-time favorite restaurant. Someone needs to text me when there is duck on the menu again and I'll be there in a heartbeat! Chef Neal does amazing things with duck!
We always enjoy Sidney. Salads are tasty and the choices are all good. We like to dine in the Tavern side so you can order off either menu. Good selection on the wine list too.
Another amazing birthday spent at my favorite restaurant. Food was amazing. Table beside the fireplace was warm, cozy, and romantic. Wait staff and chef made us feel extra special.
Excellent oasis of food and ambiance located in the quaint town of East Berlin. Definitely should be on your list of culinary destinations. It favorably competes with restaurants in DC and Baltimore.
Good food, pleasant venue, reasonably priced but not the finest of dining experience
A great restaurant for many years. Never disappoints me. A creative menu and wine list which is unusual for this area, and the new wine dinner series holds great promise as well - something badly needed in this part of the world.