SIDECAR at P.J. Clarke's
Fantastic as usual with superlative service.
Lobster salad was really old frozen and reheated yucky lobster. Don’t order.
Always a great place. Never been disappointed
Always a pleasure to come here. The food is very good and the staff could not be nicer.
I planned this reservation weeks in advance for a special weekend for my husband, parents and in-laws. We were very disappointed. We were the only people in the restaurant on Saturday night so it was nice and quiet in the restaurant. But unfortunately our server was abrupt and aloof and the food was just okay. When we asked for bread, she said “oh we usually don’t bread at this time of night, maybe one piece. Who wants it?” She was very awkward and when ordering things, she seemed confused and gave off a weird vibe. We spent over $450 and agreed it was not worth it.
We loved our experience at PJs sidecar. It’s an adorable place, the food was fantastic and the service was impeccable. I had the Pan seared scallops and my husband had the fillet and Brussel sprouts.
great hidden gem in midtown that i have been to for years
Always perfect from food atmosphere to awesome staff!
Burger... oh my days! Lovely restaurant and good staff.
Upstairs is a welcome peace from the craziness downstairs. Great ambiance, great food, great meal
Love the food and ambience perfect place to catch up with friends
Oysters, lobster, crab cakes, oh my! Dinner was amazing but the atmosphere was even better. It felt like we were transported back to the rat pack days. Dim lighting, dark woods and plush booths made for a comfortable and elegant experience. A definite must while in midtown!!
Wonderful food great ambience and just such a great place to take friends
I recommend Sidecar to everyone I know and when I can I bring them to the restaurant. It is fabulous every time I come. One of the best restaurants in New York City.
Great food great service as always
Was looking for great food nearby our hotel as it was snowing . Great food and atmosphere, walking distance from our hotel
I will brag about Sidecar forever. Everything about the restaurant is fantastic each and every time I visit. I try to tell everyone I know about it. The food is incredible and the entire staff are the nicest people ever.
Love this place! Great
For a business lunch.
Perfect hide away with some one special or just good friends. The staff will take good care of you and have a look out for the chefs special. I will erurn for sure!
Sidecar is easily one of the best restaurants in New York City. The food is always fantastic and the service is spectacular.
Excellent job by manager correctly an issue. Food was very good. Took a bit longer then expected but we weren't in a rush so no issues.
Please bring back the most amazing chicken paillard in NYC :)
We were the only people in the restaurant and wanted to switch tables due to the draft. The hostess moved us but said in a very snotty way that she needed the table in 45 minutes. At this point there was only ONE other table occupied. We ordered the lobster which was well done and uneatable and sent it back. We also had the Filet which was covered in pepper and grease. I would never go back!
Great Food, Service and Atmosphere!
Still one of the best burgers in NYC
Christmas date night! Great atmosphere and great food as always!!
As always, the service was above and beyond. The food was perfect. A great way to celebrate the holidays.
Our waiter, Phil, was phenomenal. Recommended several great appetizers to us and made our meal very enjoyable.
Nice Christmas decor and good food. Second round of drinks never came.
Go to a nearby Steakhouse if you want a steak, not worth it here. Also, the burgers used to be amazing, but have become overrated as competition has set higher standards in close vicinity to this restaurant. Used to be a fan, but I'll pass on this option in the future outside of an occasional burger a PJ Clarkes (below Sidecar and same owner/food).
Everything about Sidecar is fantastic. Excellent staff and amazing food and atmosphere. I tell friends and try to visit as often as possible.
Enjoyed it! Great fish and chips and lovely service. Good value.
Most of the food and service was good. Giving 2 stars because we ordered a steak medium rare that came medium to medium-well. We sent it back. The second time around it came back completely rare. When we sent it back the manager gave us attitude. We asked if she could describe medium rare to us and she said “that’s what you got the first time”. Our server and the rest of the staff were very understanding and extremely friendly.
We had been to The Sidecar several years ago and remember it as an great place especially for a steak with out the noise of a larger steakhouse. The server was very nice. It was odd that there was no bread offered to start and
The service is always good, but the food and cocktails (for the high price tag), could be much better.
Have been here many times - a great little secret place, great vibe, fresh food, excellent service. This time was an experience that was diametrically opposed. Very abbreviated menu, heavily oiled 'fresh' salmon, service staff that was very nice but also very confused, and then I had a gastrointestinal illness during the middle of the night after the meal that lasted for most of the next day. I have a cast-iron disposition when it comes to food - something must have been really 'off' about whatever they served that night.
Will chalk it up to anomaly for now but it has left a bad taste - may go back if the taste fades.
Low level of food. The rips were full of salse.. I couldn’t fell the real taste of the meat. The same for the steak. The hamburger was the only good plate.
No dessert because we didn’t have time to order it: we booked at 21;00 And at 21:45 the kitchen closes.
I’m a regular. The food and service is consistently outstanding.
Amazing, quiet, upscale but comfortable ambiance!!! The food was five star service impeccable!
The staff the service and the atmosphere is just what is needed. Wonderful to have a conversation and have great food. A great rarity for NYC. I will return and return. Shhhhhhhhhh!
We were visiting from Pittsburgh and stayed at a hotel nearby.