I had a bad dining experience at Scrimshaw this past summer, but decided to give them a second try. My mistake. Never again. The only redeeming thing about this place is the gorgeous view of Greenport Harbor. That's it. The food was not good. The service was atrocious. Two strikes they are out.
This was our first visit to Scrimshaw and we'll be going back. The duck spring rolls were great....and we liked the variety of the main courses.
Simply delicious. Small but refined menu. Imaginative chef.
Very nice service.
Best restaurant in Greenport. Consistent andcreative. We are never disappointed.
Friendly, staff..don't miss it!
Terrible uninformed untrained unprofessional inattentive inexcusably bad slow spaced out and just apathetic service.
Decent food, but served late. In shifts. Some meals arrived. Others didn't. It was a mess for the 4 of us.
No bread offered. No water offered. No salt n pepper offered. We had to ask...and it all took an unreasonably long time to appear...in a half empty restaurant.
The topper in this not inexpensive restaurant, as the used appetizer plates were finally being taken away the server/busser asked one of us to hand her a plate. I don't think I have ever heard a server ask that....not in a diner, a coffee shop, a cafe, nor a sandwhich place. "Can you hand me that plate?"
Great food, great atmosphere.
The oysters were fresh and the mignonette was down well. The cocktails were great as well.
Filet mignon was cooked to specification and the lobster tail over pasta was fabulous.
Would've liked to see more variety on the menu, but what was there was exceptional.
The food was really super! From the Salmon poke , Octopus and then each Main dish was just a treat, wonderful cook.
Could have used a candle on the table to see my food better. Dining outside on the pier was great , a special night.
As we entered an empty restaurant on a busy Saturday night in town, a couple leaving said 'what a disappointment', and I must say I am in full agreement. We expected a wonderful evening with wonderful food and service and unfortunately ended up with a one star experience but with four star Manhattan prices. I'm hoping things improve.
Fantastic..great service - great food and great ambience!
It was an unfortunate dining experience because the our food was bland and extremely overpriced. The spicy Thai salad and a simple mixed salad and nothing more. Although the tuna was edible, it was also very tasteless.
I would also recommend that the staff consider vacuuming from the previous days' diners.
We were disappointed overall.
Love Scrimshaw...excellent Negroni on the dock at sunset...lobster and corn were divine. Always memorable.
Wonderful place the meal and the view were memorable.
Beautiful dinning on dock
Great coconut curry bouillabaisse
Scrimshaw remains far and away the best restaurant on the North Fork. Other Greenport restaurants have more hype around them, but Scrimshaw consistently delivers. The food and the location are just heavenly. I've eaten there numerous times and never had anything from the menu that was less than absolutely delicious. A magical place that exemplifies the best of North Fork living.