I thoroughly enjoyed Scollay Square - everything from the food to the great service we received from our waitress Wendy. I will definitely go back as there are many other items I would like to try. Best of all, food and drink prices are very reasonable - especially for Boston. The only drawback is parking - I wish they had a valet.
I went here for my birthday with a group of my girls, and it was fantastic. There was something for everyone on the menu, I was able to get a tuna appetizer and my friends were able to get awesome-looking burgers. The deserts were even better than the meal, we split cheesecake and red velvet cake, they were both phenomenal. The drinks were eclectic and well made. The service staff was very accommodating. My only criticism would be that the chairs were uncomfortable and the tables are too close together, but since it wasn't crowded it didn't matter much.
Great all around experience. Awesome portions, great bloody mary, perfect for our group and kid friendly. Exactly what we were looking for.
I liked Scollay. Went with my family and all really enjoyed the Philly egg rolls, different Mac and cheese dishes. The tuna filet was great.
Me and my friedn came for dinner. The Pan Roasted Haddock was tender and satisfying without being heavy. The rice was perfect. The Martini glasses were a decent size and my drink was above average (pear martini). My friend tried the Buffalo Chicken with Mac & Cheese and it was fairly good, mildly spicy. The service was prompt and courteous. It was a Friday evcening and not very crowded surprisingly. The prices were resonable. I would definitely go back, very cute place.
I was in town on business and liked this place so much that after having dinner there with a client, I also went there for lunch on my own too.
So surprised when the restaurant called me the next day and asked my review. In all my years of traveling and eating out this was a first. Totally surprised.....a return for sure.
I've had dinner at Scollay Square several times in the past couple of months. Good food and attentive service at reasonable prices keep me coming back.
On my most recent visit, I had the special: tenderloin steak. And it definitely was special — fork tender, with a tasty sauce, mashed potatoes, and sauteed baby spinach. And service was as attentive as ever.
Food was good. Internet menu is not up to date. Tuna with wasabi mashed potatoes good.
Great central location, quality "comfort food," attentive service, relaxed scene, and reasonable prices.