I had the seafood risotto and it was excellent! The dip they have for the bread is also delicious!
Waiter was excellent. Food was delicious and fresh. Dim lighting was great.
The location may have changed, but the food is still consistently GOOD! Scarlatto is my go-to Italian restaurant in Midtown.
The food was great. The waiter was great. Can’t wait to come back.
Scarlatto recently moved to a new location. The new space is charming. We loved our meal and the service was excellent.
I saw it on WCBS channel 2 and decided to try it before a play. My wife and I enjoyed the experience and will come back.
I had been to Scarlato's Restaurant before at their other location and their new location is equally beautiful. Reservation time was spot on. Food and service excellent. Would highly recommend this restaurant.
Great value Great Food
We enjoyed ourselves for my Birthday lunch! The service, food, ambiance and waiter were excellent!
Excellent Italian for pre-theatre dining. Definitely reserve - it was quite busy at 5:30 (our show was at 7PM). Very good food. Excellent service. Prices moderate. No bar to sit and sip before hand, however, there is a "bar" if you wanted a cocktail. My husband's rack of lamb was cooked to perfection ($38). I had a lovely risotto special ($28) with shrimp and artichokes. Carpaccio the way I like it. I like their new location - nice ambiance. Decent wine list & prices. I appreciated our waiter's suggestion to go with a Sangiovese which was $10 less expensive than another Sangiovese. There is a reason Scarlatto's continually gets good ratings.
We were given a table in an area I requested. Service was good and the food was also. I’d recommend it.
Meal was very tasty (bass with chickpeas and the salmon), portions were good (by that I mean decent sizes) and service was good. Decor not memorable but overall a very nice dining experience for pre theater. Got out in good time to make the curtain despite ordering a bit later than we had planned.
The soup was delicious but both main courses were so salty that we sent them back and had salads instead. The service was fine and the waiter was understanding, but there are so many dining options in the area that we will not be going back here anytime soon.
We could not have had a more pleasant pre-theater lunch! The wait staff were friendly and the food was interesting and very, very good. A superb choice in the theater district.
The food was delicious, prices were reasonable and the staff was very friendly. I would go back and recommend this restaurant.
Everything was wonderful. It was our farewell to New York until next time.
Pre theater dinner
Food was very good. Eggplant appetizer was excellent. Chicken dish was a little too dry but tasty. Would recommend. Pasta looked great but didn't have any
Great choice for theatre district. New location is nice, modest. One room, but not too loud. Food is very good, solid. Service is also good. And the prices are moderate. I'll be back.
Excellent experience all around!