Great Roman classic dishes with accents of Tuscan fare.
Our waiter did a fabulous job.
Our food came nice and hot..
I really liked this restaurant. Food was generally excellent ( except for one comment later on). Excellent ambiance and service. Large portions of well executed Italian cuisine and very authentic. Recently returned from Rome and the food here is very authentic. Drinks and wine were excellent. My only issue was with my appetizer. I was supposed to have carpaccio with truffles. It was served without truffles and the chef knew he did not have any, but did not convey this to the waiter. This was disclosed to me when I asked the waiter why the appetizer was not as represented. To the waiter's credit, he did comp my table with after dinner drinks, but the chef should have been forthcoming and I would have ordered a different appetizer. I will return to this restaurant the next time I go to the theatre in NYC.
excellent food and service. perfect for pre theater.
The food is always very good here. Great for before or after show. Service is fast.
A surprise and a delight. Has been on my radar for some time and will definitely return. There's a lovely old school feel. Food and service delightful. Eggplant parm is listed as an appetizer but is large enough for a main course. Mushroom pasta excellent, as was the skirt steak. Tasted better than it looked. Pear and gorgonzola salad was delicious. Actually quiet enough to have and adult conversation--really rare these days and tremendously appreciated. Server asked if there were any allergies or diet restrictions. Wonderful experience from start to finish.
This is our favorite restaurant when we come in from CT to see a play on Broadway, usually by the Roundabout Theater.
I’ve traveled a bit in Italy and always hope that being here will bring back wonderful memories
Scarlotto never disappoints! It is an absolute must stop every time I’m in Midtown. The lasagna is the best I’ve ever had anywhere. Great wine selection. Delicious desserts. Do yourself a favor...GO TO SCARLOTTO!!!!
Took my friend for her bday. The bottle of wine was so good and only 38! The food was amazing g. Finished everything...so good. Waiter was so handsome and attentive but not annoying. Highly recommended!!
Food was delicious!
Excellent service !
Raspberry Bellini’s were amazing!
The food is amazing, the staff very nice, just a great overall dining experience. Will definitely go back.
The food was fair to good.
Sadly, the noise level and proximity of tables made dining uncomfortable.
Scarlotto's was perfect for a pre-theater dinner. Food was good and reasonably priced. Would definitely recommend and would definitely return.
Wonderful meal, great service!
My favorite place in NYC. Divine!
Brought my wife the wrong food order,so she ate by herself.Appys were good but entrees were just ok.
We had a 6pm pre-theater reservation and were not seated until 6:25. Another couple who came in after us had the same experience. Seating is very tight when the restaurant is full. Beyond that the food is good and reasonably priced.
Pre-theatre dinner. Pushed the food. Spilled the wine. Ordered Salmon cooked through and when it arrived barely cooked seemed insulted that we asked to have them take it back and cook through.
Good food, good and quick service without being/feeling rushed. A solid good place to go when in the Times Sq area.
Muy buena atención, la comida es excelente! Cocina italiana de primera, pasamos una víspera de Año Nuevo en familia muy bien atendidos, gracias!
Tasty food, reasonable price, rushed service, noisy.
Scarlatto's exceeded my expectations, it was wonderful! My boyfriend and I went for a meal before seeing the tree and roaming around Times Square. We were pleasantly surprised, because some restaurants near that area can be a bit overrated or just not the best with food. The service was fantastic, the environment was fun and it was a great family oriented restaurant. The food was amazing. We got the calamari for an appetizer which was delicious with a bottle of Merlot and for dinner we both got the chicken parmesan. Let's just say I never finish a full plate of food especially after the appetizer, but my plate was completely cleaned. Would highly recommend and we'll be sure to go back!
We had an outstanding experience this past Saturday. We arrived 50 minutes before our 7 pm reservation and they seated us within 5 minutes. The service and food were outstanding.
Had been to Scarlatto at their other location and had delicious dinners. Same great service, same great food. Dining room a little tight but that’s NYC. Perfect restaurant before or after a show.
We come to Scarletto before the theatre all the time. Great fItalian food. One of our favorite is the Tricolore salad with mozzarella, tomato & avocado. Simple and delicious. Gnocchi is the best around.
Nice, quiet dinner location. The food, drink, and dessert was great. The service was friendly and the atmosphere was fabulous for an anniversary dinner. Only a few blocks away from Times Square - nice venue before or after a show. Highly recommend.
New favorite find. Love it.
The Grilled Octopus appetizer and the Branzino were delicious
The food and service were outstanding and the location is perfect for attending Broadway shows.
Great service and great food... excellent for all occasions recommended
Food was excellent. Pasta and fish was great. All of our plates were spotless after eating. very pleasantly surprised. Would go back in a heartbeat
We visited recently and felt that the overall food quality was poor and the wine extremely overpriced. The house wine ( Dark Horse Cabernet ) at 44.00 per bottle sells for 8.00 in the local wine stores . The food was average if not a bit below average . The atmosphere although very cramped was fine except that we were by the front door which was left open or held open quite often making for a chilly evening . The service was sparse and we were multiple orders of some of our appetizers which we had to return .
All in all we had a great day in the city , however there are much better options in the area
Your food was good. However we had a 25 percent off card and you would not honor it against our whole meal. Not cool...
Great pre-theater spot, good food, but noisy
Food was ok. Hot and crowded.
Everything was wonderful as always. They really understand what is 7pm curtain means!
I went before seeing a broadway show and this restaurant is one of those hidden gems. The price was very reasonable. We were seated right upon entry and the food didn't take long to come out. Would definitely recommend if going with some friends or a significant other.
Lovely restaurant. I've been here a few times. The food is consistently good as well as the service. Highly recommend.
All elements of the meal nicely timed. We weren’t rushed and enjoyed the experience.
Service was amazingly quick. Food was hot and delicious and not too expensive considering it is in NYC.