The food was fantastic the service was great and the atmosphere was unique and comfortable
As usual, nice selection of food,Good,attentive service. Wine was very good , apps ,also. Risotta not that good. Scallops and sauce very good, it was the rice itself not up to par. Crème brulee something special
Great food and great service. Molly is an excellent server.
Lovely restaurant, beautifully appointed, clean, great service, very good food, French flair adds to the ambiance...needs work on the entrance area which belies the cleanliness and excellence within...needs some work on that front door which is, of course, the first impression.
The restaurant was decorated to the nines for Valentines Day, the weekend after, which made it a nice surprise. Pocketed sections make for a quiet experience. The server, Mike, was outstanding. The food was quite delicious, from appetizer to dessert! Thus restaurant is worth the price point!
Romantic and fun, excellent food and service. Great secluded tables.
I took my wife there for Valentine's day dinner.It was Fantastic! This is my wife's fav restaurant.
First time here! The scenery is amazing!!! Food was great!!! Loved it!
One of the most romantic best places I’ve ever been to, service was excellent ,food was excellent .
haven't been there in years it was great surprise. even better than i remembered. highly recommend it
Love Scarborough Fair! Great ambiance, food, service!
Lovely ambiance for Valentine's Day. Specials were good. A nice menu.
The service is excellent. Well informed staff. The restaurant is keeping up with the times, updating its menu creatively. I recommend it to people who have never been there. The décor is seasonal and delightful.
Took very long to get the bottle of wine we ordered. The appetizer (Crab Meat) was awful. It was tiny round pieces (certainly no lump crab) it seemed like imitation or fake, fishy and mushy....
Dinner was very good! Lobster special and filet mignon. Service was great, place is beautiful. Would give it another try.
Love Scarborough Fair! Went for my wife's birthday. (She was born on Valentine's Day). The restaurant is decorated beautifully for the holiday! Our table was even decorated for her birthday! The service is exceptional, never rushed, and the food is delicious! I would highly recommend this restaurant!
We love this restaurant for the ambience. The service is impeccable and the dinners are reasonably priced. I do wish they would bring back the autumn salad with the butternut squash, however. The salad we had while dining this time was very disappointing. It was not much more than a bunch of greens for $9. My husband loves the steak and orders it cajun style. There was only one occasion where the chef made it truly cajun style. I do not blame the restaurant since it is not offered on the menu. The restaurant also allows you to substitute one side with another. This is important to me. My family and I will continue coming back to this restaurant especially when celebrating a special occasion. They really went all out with their Valentine's Day decorations.
We came here last year while visiting a friend in New Jersey. I loved it so much I had to come back this year.
We dined here in the early part of February so the restaurant was decked out for Valentines Day. It was so beautifully decorated. For those looking for a special place for Valentines Day you will not beat this romantic place!! The ambiance and food is amazing!
Best lamb chops I've ever had.
There is a little cottage on the property that is a candy store. Both times that I have dinned here it has been closed. I think it is only open on the weekends. Looks amazing too
Scarborough Fair has become our area restaurant of choice, and we have tried them all. It's quiet with occasional live music, comfortable, and romantic. The staff is attentive, and professional. My last meal was wild boar. It was a dinner to die for. Thank you, Chef.
Between the friendly service, incredible food, and out of this world atmosphere, this was by far, a truly romantic experience. The work and effort put in with all the Valentine decorations helped transport you to another world. Bravo!
very average for an expensive meal
First time here and it did not disappoint. It was our anniversary and the hostess and waiter went out of their way to make us feel special. Beautiful atmosphere, cozy and romantic. Definitely will be back!
My wife and I went to Scarborough Fair on our 40th anniversary. She had never heard of the place, and I took her there as a surprise. She was blown away. It was all decked out for Valentine's day already. The food and service were superb. Very romantic.
Mat made anniversary diner special. he was excellent and the food was excellent . We will be returning
Fantastic restaurant and experience from start to finish. The ambiance is second to none. Great dining experience with delicious food.
We've been here a number of times, from "justus" to "us, and the kids, and the grandkids".
It's always a special experience and we have never been disappointed. Not the least expensive place you can find, but worth every penny. The value is definitely there.
Not much choices for vegetarian people, otherwise a wonderful place for special occasions and romantic date!!!
Absolutely fabulous. The ambiance was and always is amazing. Highly recommended
Tonight was their (annual?) chateaubriand special, which we ordered. The meat was tender and flavorful and perfectly done; the potatoes were delicious and the bearnaise butter was fine. The vegetables seemed a bit odd, but there was so much food, it didn't matter - we ended up taking some of the meat home . The salads that came as part of the meal were good, deeper green than we happen to like (boring iceberg fans that we are) but beautifully dressed, with vinaigrette and walnuts. We also split a very substantial shrimp cocktail-- only three shrimp, but fresh and crisp, and more than enough for two; bonus points for allowing us to split as an app. Selection of wines by the glass adequate but unremarkable. Our server was charming and efficient. One of the Valentine's Day decorations in the alcove next to us came crashing down (harmlessly) and was righted promptly when we pointed it out, cheerfully and gracefully-- well done! A good dining experience all around.
Fine dining at its best, food is always top shelf. Great for a romantic dinner, special occasion and holidays.
I came here with my husband for my birthday. They decorated the table with come birthday confetti and made it feel really special. The service was fast and very friendly. The food was absolutely delicious. Their menu has a lot of diverse options and their specials are great. I had a chicken dish and my husband had the duck. We were both very happy with our meals! The ambience is great and the interior is absolutely beautiful. It is the perfect place for a special occasion.
We were originally scheduled to celebrate our anniversary in January 2017 at the Scarborough Fair, however plans changed last minute and we had to cancel. My wife loves restaurants with private dining, so we decided to book for January 2018. We went on a Sunday night at 6:30 pm and it was amazing. They knew it was our anniversary and put something nice on the table to celebrate the occasion. A few staff members even wished us a happy anniversary which was very nice and thoughtful. The private dining was excellent, the setting and mood were perfect. There were tables seated to the left and right of us and it was still very private and quiet. The interior decorating was amazing and the waiter we had was excellent. I usually do not write reviews for restaurants, however my wife specifically asked me to write one because of how amazed and happy she was with the Scarborough Fair. I would definitely recommend this restaurant - a quiet, romantic setting with excellent staff and an atmosphere that is unmatched. And before I forget to mention, the best part was the food. The price is well worth it for the food that is served. We ordered steak and salmon and both were prepared exactly as we ordered with excellent taste. The plates were displayed perfectly and the food came out right on time. An amazing night that we will always remember, and we plan on coming back! Thank you!
Good restaurant, not fabulous, but good. We had reservations, and were seated without waiting. Our server, Hannah did a very nice job. The food came out hot and timely. We had the shrimp cocktail, which were huge, served with ketchup-y cocktail sauce, no lemon & a big dollop of sour cream... yes, sour cream. We also had mozzarella caprese appy, which was ok, smushy tomatoes, just ok. The cowboy steak and lamb were both tasty, both were ordered medium, the steak was under and the lamb was over temperature. The flavor was there, but again, not fab, just ok. The flourless chocolate cake was decadent.
Doubt we will go back.
First day of the New Year!
Excellent food, beautiful ambiance, and service was attentive ! Made my birthday dinner very special
We have been here one other time and loved this place. On this particular evening we were seated in a room that held a large party of couples and three other 2 seat tables. Unfortunately, the large party was VERY loud and it was hard to hear each other speak. It was just a quiet night out (so we thought) for us and it turned out to be a rushed dinner so we could get out of there due to the noise level. My advice would be to NOT seat couples in a room with a large party. Couples normally are out for a nice date or quiet dinner, not to shout to each other.
I really love Scarborough Fair, it never disappoints! Great food, great service and so enjoyable.
I liked the place. The food was good but I thought a little over priced.Very romantic and quiet, good for conversation.
30 years going to this restaurant. Never had a bad meal or service. Today was far from the best but certainly not in the gutter. Service was disappointing and hurried. The meal was unusually small. Not worth going into detail. I look at it as slightly disappointing but grateful that it is a rare occurrence here.
Scarborough fair never disappoints was very enjoyable dinner !