See availability for bonus point tables
Mon - Thu 5:30PM - 6:00PM 9:00PM - 9:30PM
The food was spectacular! The chef’s compliments to the table were very much appreciated , and so delicious. The service was impeccable. Can’t wait to go back
As always, the food, wine list and servce is excellent. Michael is one of the great chefs!
Never disappointed. You get what you pay for, so if you are looking to save a buck, lok somewhere else. jag
Best Italian in NYC.
This is a restaurant that really serves some of the best italian food in manhattan but yet they are still very accommodating without the attitude!!!! we will come back every time visiting NYC!
Everything was amazing including their recommendations for wine and entrees. Each dish got better and better as the night progressed and the amuse Bouches were a delightful surprise.
Cozy, delightful restaurant in TriBeCa. The food is delicious. Can get louder as the evening unfolds and wine flows. Is there any restaurant in NYC that understands/adjusts size of individual portions based on number of courses delivered? Less is always better - as long as it is enough. No great restaurant should ever serve more than enough as determined by the amount of food delivered to each diner over the course of the meal.
This restaurant is a "shadow" of it's former self. The "death rattle" of the place is palpable. While the service was very good, the food was terrible. The duck leg was "mush" with sauce sloshed over it to cover the taste. The duck breast was gristle. The lamb was OK, sauce mundane. Worse of all, the experience was extremely expensive. The wine was excellent, but for the price, that was the expectation. Sorry to have to write this, but our visit was extremely disappointing. We wish this restaurant well, but we will not return.
A wonderful meal and evening. The staff were knowledgable and very attentive. Overall a great experience and I would recommend the restaurant with no hesitation.
Every time I eat here, I encounter dishes that are simply memorable. The amuse bouche of a mushroom filled ravioli with a light cream sauce starts your dining adventure off right! The NY strip competed with all the great steak house choices in the city, perfectly prepared and seasoned. It doesn't matter whether you go fish, meat or pasta, your senses of taste and smell will be satiated beyond measure. The service is wonderful, with a clear ethos within the organization to smile and treat people with warmth and care. I am grateful for this fine restaurant!
We have been many times to Scalini and have always had an excellent meal , possibly our favorite in NYC , the artic char and the soft egg raviolo are both incredible, service is friendly yet professional!!
Excellent food, old world charm, and as classy a restaurant as you'll find in New York City. I highly recommend dining at Scalini Fedeli the next time you want a truly enjoyable, sophisticated dining experience.
Over rated ! Food is not upto the Mark.. Except for the restaurant manager, not many in the place understand fine dining !
I have been coming here for over 10 years and the service & food has always been outstanding. I love this place.
Beautiful setup. The service was amazing as well as the food.
The food, wine, and service was amazing!
Great for special occasions such as anniversaries and birthdays.
Had an incredible meal here at Scalini, from start to finish everything was perfect , beautiful vaulted ceilings , friendly and professional servers, the food was truly memorable, each course was excellent !!!! looking forward to returning soon.
Had the 7 course tasting menu with wine pairing. Was good but no dishes blew us away and a couple were mediocre at best. Wines were good but overpriced. Nice room but overall disappointing as a premier experience.
Our favorite Italian restaurant in Manhattan ! Every time we dine here we are blown away , get the egg ravioli and the duck , both are incredible!!!
Restaurant was still decorated for Valentines Day so it made the setting extra romantic. The service was very professional and attentive and the waiter had good knowledge of the menu and took time to nicely explain his favorites which we followed and every dish was superior quality and exceeded our expectations. We have dined around at the best and Scalini Fedeli did not disappoint.
The food, service and atmosphere were top notch. One of the best dining experiences we've had in ages. Will definitely return!
Perfect place for Valentines Day
Our experience was unfortunate. We waited 30 minutes for our “reserved” table, then when we were seated it was at a little table at the very entrance of the dining room. Our waiter was pushy and inattentive, It definitely was not the service we expected given the reviews . I cannot lie and say the food was bad, the food was okay, but not worth a 400$ meal. This was a very special occasion; not just Valentine’s Day but the first birthday my husband and I celebrate as a married couple. We will not be going back.
This was an amazing experience as was the previous time we dined there. A romantic setting and even wrote on our plates for our anniversary. Such warm and inviting staff and can’t forget about the food; delicious!
We really enjoyed some very creative and authentic tasting Italian dishes. There quite a variety so it’s not the same old Italian menu you usually see. On the expensive side, especially the wine bottles, but worth it. My only knock would be inflexibility. Our waiter wasn’t receptive to even the slightest change in the dish as presented in the menu.
It remains my favourite restaurant in NYC, and they never disappoint. Superb food and personalised service
Scalini to Heaven!
My colleagues and I were impressed by this Tribeca gem. My colleagues were late to our meeting, but the Maitre'D was a great host and entertained me at the bar, walking me through the "wine-map" of Italy...what a wine tasting! The food was a step above what you would find at other Italian restaurants in NYC; starting with the complimentary first course, wild mushroom ravioli, and finishing with the dessert (very creative!). Piero and Julius helped my guests with all their questions and their recommendations were spot-on. We will be back!
Everything was perfect. Great food, comfortable setting, attentive and knowledgeable staff.
The experience starts with walking through the door. The lighting, high ceiling, ambience, beautiful dinning room . Unique and elegant atmosphere that feels warm, and luxurious. The food was exceptional every course perfectly cooked and seasoned . Nicola was great !
Excellent food and wonderful service but very noisy, noisier than hoped.
One of the best restaurants in the city! Been here a number of times and always want to come back.
as always, this restaurant never fails to impress me..the menu includes way enough selections to fill anyone's needs..and one is better than the other..just perfect!!
Every time I dine here I ask myself why I don’t go more often. Some of the finest dining in New York. The chef is a genius. Gorgeous dining room, elegant service and the food is exceptional.
We are usually blown away by the butternut squash agnolotti. It seems the recipe may have changed and there was a side salad served on the plate that had onions and was awful for the dish. Go back to the original please!!!!!
Fantastic restaurant , has been one of our favorites for years , true attention to detail and not stuffy !!!
Great meal. We were on vacation. Attentive staff.
The food was so so. Definitely way over priced for the quality of food you would expect.
Incredible food. Would definitely go back to try the other items on the menu.
Old world waiters in tuxedos with the best of New World Italian cuisine. Just a thoroughly exceptional restaurant. Maybe our favorite dining experience in New York. Great service and delicious, innovative new Italian flavors,