Porcini Mushroom Ravioli - Piemonte
Soft Egg Yolk Raviolo
with ricotta and spinach covered with truffle butter
Flourless Chocolate Soufflé
with cappuccino gelato and caramelized orange peel $4 supp
If I could give Scalini Fedeli 10 stars, I would. It was an unparalleled dining experience. The staff are attentive but unobtrusive, making sure you are 100% satisfied with every aspect of your meal. You won’t feel rushed, as if they’re trying to turn tables over quickly. The food was beyond fantastic, I could go on and on. If Italian is what you’re in the mood for, as well as a simply wonderful evening out, you can’t go wrong here.
The food and service were both excellent. We did the tasting menu with the wine pairing, which I highly recommend. For dessert, we got the donuts, chocolate souffle, and a peanut brittle type desser. I would recommend the souffle of the three.
It was a return visit for a special occasion. Staff and Maitre d' were exceptional as was the food and wine. Old world setting and service. A must.
Tasting menu was incredible, beautiful room , can’t wait to return
Had a fantastic meal at this Itaian restaurant in Tribeca !! food and service were top-notch , not many places left with this type of elegance
Food excellent, Service excellent nice atmosphere for a date.
Lovely dinner while staying in Soho. A few of the dinner items were fantastic, with just the right amount of salt, fat, rich balance. It's a prix fixe menu. First course being a trio of crostini. The flavors were nice, but it wasn't particularly sophisticated - the crostini bread itself was only so-so, which was a surprise considering how delicious the table bread was, along with a special bread presented at the outset with sweet caramelized onions on top.
First course, mainly pasta options, were good. Porcini ravioli with black truffle was incredibly rich, with generous truffle accents and flavor. Sauce could have a been a bit lighter. Spaghettini "Arrabiatta" was very flavorful, but, also, would have benefited from a lighter red sauce.
Second course was as good as it gets. Ecuadorian shrimp were beautifully presented, as fresh as I have tasted, and a perfect meld of flavor. The same can be said for the filet of sole.
Desserts also were memorable and drool worthy. The apple tart with ice cream - well, sounds basic, but there was perfection to the flaky crust, spiced warm apple, and creamy ice cream. Italian donuts - need I say more.
Very reasonably priced, for both the food and drink. Attentive service. Quiet atmosphere allowing for great conversation.
We did have a show to get to, and communicated up front our time table. They were a little late in meeting this restriction.
scalini fedeli is consistently delicious, with a cozy, romantic ambiance and great service. nick the manager makes you feel at home. it's one of the best spots to go to for a special occasion, or any night out you just want to feel special! highly recommend!!
Great food with attentive wait staff. Shrimp was sublime and the chocolate souffle has to be the dessert of choice.
This was our second visit to this restaurant. The food and service are both terrific. The “bites “ offered during the course of the meal are an added surprise. I had the scallops again and they were great. Husband had duck. Waiters go above and beyond to make sure everyone is pleased.
This restaurant is a little hard to find if you don’t know where you are going and it was difficult to find a cab after dinner.
Ordered as many items from the menu as physically possible and they were all great! Keep in mind, we ordered a lot of food!!!
Great service too!
Excellent food and ambiance which was ideal for a client dinner.
Everything was perfect, as always. Food is DELICIOUS, the restaurant is BEAUTIFUL, and the service is attentive and friendly. Our favorite.
Excellent, unbelievably delicious food. Great chef. Very nice service. Sat outside and it was a real treat.
Outstanding food & service! Quiet midweek night, unrushed, will be back.
So glad this neighborhood restaurant has survived. The staff was attentive and gracious and every dish was well prepared and delicious. We have always had good experiences here through the years.
Terrific atmosphere and service. Food was amazing. By the glass wine selection was outstanding.
Amazing food. Spectacular service. They keep bringing amuse Boches throughout the meal. Just a wonderful gem of a restaurant doing the small things just as good as the big things. I’ll be back for sure. Salmon rare was done perfect. Pasta is homemade and fresh. Can’t think of one thing they didn’t nail perfectly. Staff is attentive but not intrusive. Consider this a rave review. You will not go wrong here.
Wonderful dining experience for our group of 6. The service , many courses of food, and ambiance — all excellent. Well done !
Wonderful food and service.
The wait staff was on top of us in the beginning. I think New York requires 2 hour in restaurant dinning during during the pandemic. So I felt very rushed for the first 45 minutes. At one point during our first course, I thought a member of the wait staff was going to take my plate away before I could finish.
The food was great! It has an old school vibe in there, which we appreciated.
Definitely worth checking out!
Reunion with beautiful young lady
The food was delicious
The problem with the service was it was to quick. We did not have the ability to savor the food
Our experience couldn’t have been better. Everyone at Scalini welcomed my party of (5) with sincere hospitality & warmth that I haven’t experienced in NYC or elsewhere in a long time. The setting was classic/ romantic New York Italian, cozy & beautiful. Dinner was outstanding from appetizers through dessert. The egg yolk ravioli was amazing as was the butternut agnolotti. Decadent entrees and how better to end than with their warm chocolate soufflé?
Go and make any occasion feel special!
I took my fiancé here the night I proposed to her. We both loved it. The food, the service, the ambiance - all of it was terrific. Highly recommend!
Love dining at Scalini Fideli.
We had another fabulous dinner at Scalini Fedeli. The food ,service and ambiance are just wonderful and the restaurant never disappoints.
Everything and everyone was fantastic. Food was out of this world snd so much.
Scalini Fedeli is my favorite restaurant in New York City! It is everything you could possibly want in a restaurant. It’s romantic, beautifully decorated, and the food and service are unsurpassed. Everything in the restaurant that we ate was extraordinary! We sat there trying to figure out what the ingredients were to no avail! Everything was just so unique, tasty and delicious. I know that I will probably have dreams about the raviolis. They were that good. I HIGHLY recommend Scalini Fedeli for any occasion. Yummmmmmmmmm!
Outstanding white glove service with outstanding food, the chefs creativity really comes through.
Loved the view of the Freedom Tower from our table.
Food was great and reasonably priced but wine expensive.
Service friendly and excellent.
My wife and I loved the romantic ambience, the excellent service and especially the wonderful food ( the antipasti were heavenly ).
Our meal at Scalini Fedeli was fantastic. Everything we had was delicious. The menu was prix fixe, but there were so many little extra bites, that by the end we could not fit another thing in. Would definitely recommend
Absolutely amazing service snd delicious food. Don’t eat lunch.
The food is consistently delicious and well presented.
Our meal was an amazing experience of service, taste and ambiance. The staff are attentive and anticipate any need. The food was as delicious as any Michelin star restaurant, but also punctuated by surprise morsels from the kitchen. This was a special experience, that made a non eventful day, memorable and celebratory. Go and enjoy a meal so delicious, my Venetian grandmother would be envious.
Excellent food, service and ambience. Highly recommend.
Food was very tasty, drinks were great, ambience is always
Romantic and the setting is beautifully done.
I feel transported to one of my favorite restaurants in Europe each time I eat at Scalini Fedeli. The ambiance is both cozy and elegant, without being overly formal. The menu has a modern flair without compromising the integrity of traditional European cooking. The most recent menu includes a white bean soup with octopus, which is one of the best soups I have ever eaten. The veal chop that followed was as perfectly prepared. It was a great dinner!
Scalini Fedeli is rated 4.9 stars by 2663 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.