Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Mon - Thu 5:30PM - 6:00PM 9:00PM - 9:30PM
A total gem. Outstanding food, really. Every dish was perfection. Additionally we received multiple small plates compliments of the chef. The atmosphere was comforting, not stuffy. I have dined all over NYC, I can’t believe I didn’t plan to come here sooner. Will make this my go-to for special occasions. Thank you for the experience!
Best NYC Italian!! We will return , get the raviolo , the best!
This was a perfect choice for our special occasion , the staff could not have been nicer, one of the best !!
We loved this restaurant, went with a friend that is very picky and they said it was one of the best meals they have ever had, we will return again soon
I enjoyed the whole experience. Great atmosphere along with great food.
Service started out shaky but ended on an outstanding note. I definitely recommend this restaurant and would go back again.
Thanks for a great evening of dining.
We had heard many great things about Scalini Fedeli -- and they turned out to be more than true! The occasion was a birthday celebration and the staff did everything they could to make the evening special over and above their delicious food, attentiveness to our needs, and pleasantly quiet environment. We plan to return soon and often!
Extraordinary elegant dining room, quiet, perfect for any occasion. Several free goodies bring an element of surprise to the dining experience. Generous portions, maybe a bit too big as prix fix only menu forces the choice. Price a bit up there, but in line with the setting.
Some food outstanding, some just OK. Menu quite extensive. Service excellent, but otherwise much too fast for a quality restaurant. Lovely ambiance, but a bit noisy on Saturdays. Less so other days. Great value.
Amazing food, large selection in the prix fixe menu, good service. Very good
This is the second time we have visited this location. Definitely one to try for a quiet, romantic meal or to celebrate a special occasion.
The food is delicious, and the staff, very attentive without being obtrusive.
Would defintitely recommend.
Amazing food, white glove service, beautiful surroundings. One of the best meals I have ever had in NYC! A new favorite.
Delightful Italian restaurant in the heart of Tribeca - we walked from the ROXY Hotel! Old style, with beautiful interiors harking back to a by gone age! Excellent food - delicious pasta and we had duck and char topped salmon on crab meat! Absolutely nothing to fault - a memorable dinner!
We selected the tasting menu. The portions were generous with each course and the quality of the food was outstanding. While it is a very expensive restaurant, the quality is outstanding.
Our favorite nyc Italian restaurant , very consistent and they send out xtra little tastings that you didn’t order , extremely gracious!!!
There were 4 of us in the party; and we shared our dishes with each other. All agreed the food here is something very special. Each dish and amuse bouch was perfectly prepared and presented.
Service was attentive yet unobtrusive. We would definitely recommend this restaurant and will be eager to visit again next time we are in NYC!
Drinks and WAY OVERPRICED . 17 to 19 dollars a drink and I was not feeling even a little tipsy. Prifix menu is all they offer . Kinda ok not my favorite kind of dining . My husband and friend ordered the shrimp dinner it was literally 4 medium shrimp in the dish . No side, nothing . That’s not considered a dinner... Ambiance is nice , kind of old, service was good waiter was attentive , the bathroom is downstairs down 15 or more steps and then down the hall . . This place is over priced $750 including tip for dinner and drinks is way to much and when you leave you aren’t stuffed , many more places in NYC to choose from. You would not be missing out if you never dined here ... sorry but it’s the truth
A lovely and gracious dining experience. The food is exquisite.
We celebrated 3 birthdays that night and had a wonderful time. The waiters brought out special desserts for the our 3 birthday people. The food was excellent and so was the service. You will not be disappointed. This was our 2nd time there and I look forward to a 3 time soon!
Delicious and Romantic
You will not be disappointed. The food is fantastic. We were 5 people and we shared so I sampled several dishes and they were really really good (appetizers to dessert). It's quiet and feels intimate. It's not cheap but worth the money spent. Enjoy!!!
Superb service, attentive but not rush. Excellent wine recommendation. Can I recommend a special dish? No- all are just so tasteful, beautifully presented and creative Italian cooking
This was our third visit and will enjoy Scalini Fedeli many more times in the future. Fresh and delicious food - excellent service. This restaurant hits the mark every time. As always, thank you!
Old world Italian with a modern kick. Impeccable service and the meal was probably the best Italian food I have experienced in NYC in ages.
Best Italian place in Manhattan , had the recommendations from the server and all were spot on , dining room is gorgeous as well
The food is fantastic as usual!!# I didn't like the changes to the dining area.
If you are looking for a special evening this is the place
Excellent service, very knowledgeable staff
The food was outstanding!!!
The chef kept sending out things to try, everything was delicious!
Always delicious- alittle disappointed we weren’t offered the chefs tasting menu.
Upon entering we immediately knew we were in for a wonderful meal. The ambiance was very romantic with candle lit tables, soft lighting and sculptured arched ceilings. The outstanding service delivered creative and tasteful foods. The chef sent over a mushroom Ravioi topped with black truffle which was delicious . My first course was an outstanding Fusilli pasta and my main course was a double thick cut veal chop which was also delicious.
I finished with a caramelized banana desert with Vanilla Gelato. finishing off a wonderful evening.
every thing was good except price. thought they are priced beyond what is received.
This is truly a very special place. Everything about it was fantastic. The food, service, ambiance.... everything was perfect.
It was divine!!!!! No clue what to order bc it all looked good.
The food and the service the ambience was fantastic. the only problem Was a couple sitting next to us were Loud and obnoxious.
One of the best fine dining experiences I have enjoyed in NYC. The food was excellent and the service just as excellent. Sebastian, Nick and their colleagues provided an experience on par with Michelin dining experiences.
Exceptional food. The kitchen sent out many gifts from the chef, all of which were delicious. Service was also exceptional. Everything was delicious and a bargain at these prices. Go.
Fantastic evening, wonderful food, great service.
We will be coming back without question next time we visit NYC!
Nick and Rebecca Oddy, Flitwick, England.
Scalini Fedeli is a treat, particularly for a special occasion. Despite the fixed price, the "3-course" dinner is enhanced with so many "amuse bouche" that it really isn't so expensive.
We are always delighted with the service and our experience that, in this elegant and formal-seeming setting, the service is always fun and easy, while providing everything one could possible think of, resulting in a truly satisfying overall experience.
We had an amazing dining experience from soup to nuts! Service was on point! My husband can’t wait to go back for the veal chop he said it’s the best he’s ever had (which says a lot because he has ordered it at many places all over NY atleast once a month)
I liked the ambiance. There are not many restaurants in New York where you can have a quiet conversation. Nice atmosphere and great service. Unfortunately, I can't say the same about food. It's very unimaginative. I have a feeling it was prepared earlier and just heated when you order it. $75 prix fixe menu is definitely overpriced. Even with intermediate "complements of the chief" it's not good quality. Also, the wine list is extensive, but you can hardly find any red wines for less than $150. Wines are also somewhat overpriced.
Second time that we visited, as good, if not better than remembered. Great for a special occasion.