Diver Sea Scallops Over a Celery Root Puree
in a prosecco and black truffle sauce with crispy leeks
Porcini Mushroom Ravioli - Piemonte
Chicken Liver and Pancetta Ravioli in a Boscaiola Sauce
with toasted Sicilian pistachio
It was great to be back at the restaurant after so long. The food was fabulous and the staff and service was excellent. Can't wait to get back here again and bring some friends/relatives.
It was a delight to return to our favorite Tribeca spot and to see that tables are filling. The food is always delicious, as are the little surprises sent along the way. Wonderful pastas, scallops, salmon and desserts come with gracious service.
The staff was excellent. I never had to ask for anything they were always there. The food was everything I heard and better.
We come here quite often, the food is always delicious!
Still a classic, romantic, outstanding experience.
I have been in the NYC restaurant scene for 25 years and I come from a family of restaurant owners with a very keen eye for service, value, ambience, and of course food quality. My wife and I went to celebrate our anniversary. We hadn't been for about 10 years but wanted to dine here again for nostalgic reasons first, but we also remember how fond we were of the "old school charm", super-attentive service, warmth of the staff, and outstanding food. I'm so happy to report that not much has changed. It is still a beautiful, romantic room with a classic Italian decor. The food was even better than I recall, now with more ambitious and modern offerings on the menu. We were greeted with free champagne when we sat down. This was a very special night. We'll be back for sure. Thank you!!
Great food, awesome service and amazing value! We love this place and have been back many times, (and will be back more!)
Great place for anniversary dinner. So appreciate the Prosecco and moscato. And “happy anniversary” plate decoration. Third time here for celebration, all the way from Oklahoma. Hope to be back for more. Great food and service.
Excellent food excellent service. Come hungry! Highly recommended!
Great experience at this Tribeca Italian, the food and service were as good as it gets , ever dish was spectacular!
Scalini Fedeli was always one of our favorite restaurants for a special occasion and hadn’t been since the pandemic started. Upon our return last night we fell back in love with this restaurant. Everything about our experience was wonderful but especially the food. We hope their business continues to grow because it is a real gem in lower Manhattan.
This was one of our favorite restaurants. Had been there perhaps six weeks ago, but this time it was a totally different experience.
Although there was a mix up in the kitchen regarding my food allergy, Chef/ Owner Michael and Manager Nick did absolutely everything that they could to make it up to me, including both of them calling me personally to apologize the following day.
I was really touched with how much they cared about their customer's experience and how they wanted to make it up to me.
Scalini Fedeli is a top notch restaurant in Manhattan with a beautiful dining room and excellent food. Sometimes things can go wrong, but it takes an even greater restaurateur to know how to deal with an issue when it happens genuinely and graciously. So for that I am grateful. Can't wait to try their new location in New Jersey.
Everyone else is correct -what else can you say except it's an outstanding all around dining experience
As always the place did not disappoint. I love going here
Great dinner and service. A++
A really enjoyable special date night meal -- you will not leave hungry or dissatisfied.
A delightful experience that will keep us returning to this gem of an Italian restaurant !
Fabulous meal, Impeccable service!! It is one of my favorite places!!!
Wonderful dinner. Beautiful setting. Service impeccable.
Excellent service, superb food, beautiful ambiance
A lovely experience. Have been here many times and it is consistently excellent.
This was my third solo visit in a four week period, and I cant wait to share this exceptional dining experience with friends and family. First, the food is exquisite and the service is exceptional. The setting is elegant without being stuffy--a rare combination. Every course at each meal has been memorable, from start to finish. I am especially taken by the delicate and flavorful sauces, whether on pasta, fish or meat. This place is a gem.
Consistently excellent food, ambiance and service. Not a “scene”, but the quality of the food, presentation, ambiance service is excellent every single time. Also great for functions/large groups (they have private rooms downstairs). Been coming here off and on for about 15 years, and have never seen a drop in quality. Consistently excellent. Will be back again!
Top quality food. Extremely satisfying meal. Also, the quantity they give you is surprising. The food never seemed to end.
Flawless service and even better food. This is our go-to spot for a romantic dinner. We know that everything will be perfect!
From the moment you walk through the door it is a dining experience that is beyond my 5 star rating
Food, service, ambiance ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I always look forward to our dinners at Scalini
Can’t wait for our next reservation
Goodbye Covid, Welcome back Scalini Fideli!!
We had a superb birthday celebration. Scalini Fideli is consistently wonderful.
It was our son’s first time eating here. The joyful expression on his face while he was eating his meal might have been enough, however he asked if he could try our dishes (and ultimately finish our dishes) which had never happened. The egg yolk raviolo is probably the most amazing dish on the menu . It’s something that you will dream about. Everything about tonight was perfect. And let’s not forget the bitter chocolate soufflé.
To me, this is one of the few restaurants that has never disappointed us. The food is utterly delicious, you never feel rushed, and you can tell that the people who work there really understand how to make each guest feel special.
In one word fabulous! Every dish was scrumptiously delicious. And let’s not forget St. Daniel wine.
You must be prepared to EAT!
We LOVE it. Host Nick is amazing and so accommodating! He’s a keeper! We’ll be back next week with our boys, then again with friends, and then when my parents come to NYC!
The pork chop is a must-have.
Fabulous Restaurant with amazing food and great service in the Old Bouley Space.
Had a wonderful dining experience last night. I particularly enjoyed the pasta bolognese and the scallops. I highly recommend It.
Mother’s Day dinner with my boys in NYC. Great food and ambience!
Food was delicious! Service could have been a bit more attentive, but did not impact our overall opinion. Highly recommend!
This restaurant is by far one of the best places I've eaten. Very professional and the food is FANTASTIC. Great for date night!!
Always a great restaurant. Excellent food and service. We have never gone wrong at this restaurant.
Selected Scalini Fedeli based on prior reviews & it did not disappoint!! Service, food and ambiance was all exceptional!! We would highly recommend it for a fabulous dinner or a special celebration!
I enjoyed my dinner after waiting so long to get out in the world again. The ambiance was great and it was not too noisy and the food was good. That being said, my husbands chicken was chewy(but tasty) and my veal chop wasn’t as good as I was hoping considering all the great reviews. My pasta with figs and marscapone as well as the dessert were out of this world. The waitstaff wasn’t intrusive and the maitre d was pleasant although he promptly seated us at the table nearest the kitchen, even though I had requested a nice table away from the kitchen on my reservation. Obviously someone needs to sit there, but considering it was a special request and there were plenty of empty tables, I was a little turned off by that. He did show us two other tables so that was good. I would definately go back as it was all around a special evening thanks to the atmosphere and food. I will try a different entree next time.
Our favorite restaurant to celebrate life's occasions. The food is incomparable and beautifully presented. The service and ambience are exemplary and Nick is a gracious and accommodating host. As always, our most recent dining experience was excellent. My girlfriend and I are so happy that Scalini Fedeli has weathered the pandemic and is back, and we are looking forward to returning soon.
Glad to see a NYC favorite gem of a restaurant open again. The food is still excellent and the service first class. We’ll definitely be going back.
Scalini Fedeli is rated 4.9 stars by 2650 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.