This restaurant just gets better and better. My wife and I had two different starters (carpacio of scallops and pappardelle) and two different mains (red snapper and pork chop). We are foodies and rated all four dishes A+, and also the semisweet flourless chocolate cake with pistachio gellato for dessert. The service was relaxed and friendly, and the ambiance very pleasant. A past criticism for someone like me who eats fish but not meat - overdoing the sausage and other meats in seafood dishes - was less apparent this time. The only fault we had was with the bread, which was slightly stale and not special. We think this is the best restaurant in NJ.

The finest restaurant in Morris County. Incredible selection, preparation and flavors. Service by Bernard and staff and food was superb. Top of our short list.

My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our anniversary dinner. The courses were expertly prepared and the service was impeccable. Long live Scalini Fedeli!

not enough servers long lags between course especially dessert... Had ravioli very thick dough not a very good ravioli.. and pork shank was a mess

A real gem in Chatham with excellent food and service.

It was my Mom’s 70th Birthday dinner. We had a party of 9. Had to wait for our table for about 20 min. The waiter was not very pleasant. When I asked if their pre- fixed menu can be adjusted for a picky eater, his first response was no adjustments. When I explained that my son would only eat plain pasta they agreed but we ended up paying full price of the pre-fixed dinner($59). A bit pricey for pasta. Overall the food was tasty. The atmosphere is a bit outdated. For the amount we spent there you can have a better meal elsewhere.

Outstanding. High end quality for reasonable price.

A little beneath my usual experience at Scalini Fedeli which is one of my top restaurants. A new appetizer Linguini alla carbonara failed to wow like the food there usually does. My veal chop was a little heavy on the gristle and I had to dig beneath the crevices of a large piece of bone to get the meat out. My wife enjoyed her meal very much and the service and bar service were outstanding. Will go back.

Very pleasant. Will certainly return.

So many choices! Egg yolk ravioli was delicious, but a bit over-sauced. Pounded pork chop also delicious. However, although I am a salt lover and find most restaurant dishes under-seasoned, thought both dishes a bit too salty. A great value was had because there was no corkage fee (at least that evening-I would call and check). Brought a bottle that would have cost around $200 on a restaurant wine list, so saved big!

A great restaurant for a special occasion. Great food, service and ambiance.

This is the best of the best! No other menu could possibly compare. Every morsel bursts with unique flavor that you can’t find elsewhere. Highly recommended for any special occasion.

Excellent from start to finish. Setting is a renovated farmhouse loathe living room. Service was exceptional especially Bernard who suggested must haves. My wife

The food never disappoints. Outstanding! The prix fixe is a good value. Bring your appetite. Especially enjoy the ecuadorian shrimp appetizer.

Food is great as n uou are treated so nicely.
Always a great experience, which is why we come back so often.

Dinner with my mother on Mother's Day. The service was polite and friendly. Atmosphere was romantic. Food was amazing and unlike any Italian cuisine we have had before. Fresh, delicious and unique.

This was our first visit to the restaurant. The staff was attentive and helpful! The food was terrific and served at a wonderful pace. The only problem we had was friends had ordered wine to be served with our dinner as a surprise but it was never delivered. This did not take away from the evening but was embarrassing for us when asked by our friends how we enjoyed the wine they had picked out for our special occasion.

We have been to Scalini many, many times over the years. The menu is varied and inovative and we have never been disappointed. I have read reviews in NJ Magazines that Scalini needs to "push the culinary envelope". What needs to be pushed when every dish is outstanding? Yes fine dining is loosing popularity, but Scalini proves fine dining doesn't equate with stuffy. Don't miss the gem.

Celebrated a birthday with 6 total adults. Food was outstanding.

From the street view this place is very cozy and reminds you of Cape May. Once inside it’s a very relaxing environment with a superb staff. The food was absolutely great and one of the best desserts I’ve ever had!

It was a great experience and the food was out of this world!! Pound for pound, Scalini Fedeli is one of the best around. The ambience, staff and presentation were enough to make you feel as if you were on vacation for at least a few hours.

Great food, service without being obtrusive, interesting decoration

Our anniversary celebration on a early Thursday evening was just what we expected. Lobster tail and filet mignon were excellent. Service excellent. We were next to a large table and the noise level was higher than we would have liked. Enjoyable we will return.

We had a wonderful meal on my wife's birthday. The food was great and the service by Bernard was perfect.

Exquisite food. Delicious from start to finish. Great service and beautiful atmosphere.

The food and service was exceptional. Would recommend for anyone in the area.

First time visiting, dinner was delicious, service vey good. We will certainly return.

Amazing food and service. Takes both to a new level. HIGHLY recommend

Great good great service

Very creative menu and prepared to order. Romantic setting with absolutely fabulous service. A must for special occasions, this is now one of our favorites.

Ate here to celebrate my aunt's birthday. Food, service, and ambiance were all outstanding!! Will definitely be returning for a romantic anniversary dinner or cozy family gathering!! Loved it!!

Wonderful.
Excellent food, ambience and great and courteous service

Continues to be an excellent restaurant. Service was a bit slower than usual. Main dishes (fish) were terrific, but the appetizers were not superlative. Overall was a very enjoyable evening but the restaurant wasn't the "wow" we have experienced in the past.

Everyone enjoyed their meals tremendously! So good!

You were given the best attention ever , between the waiter, water boy and manager everyone came over to ensure your experience was perfect.

This restaurant is always fabulous and never fails to impress me

Daughters 18ty birthday

Two couples celebrating their anniversary, could have not been more pleased with the outstanding service and fine food.

Absolutely amazing foods, fantastic service. Highly, highly recommended! Probably our favorite special occasion spot.

Excellent as always...menu, Food, service, atmosphere. Thank you.