Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Scalini Fedeli - Chatham
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
Thinly Sliced Breast of Duck in a Port and Truffle Reduction
with a potato puree and caramelized endive
sautéed in a sherry wine and garlic sauce over a pecorino and sweet pea puree surrounded by crispy fried eggplant
with mushrooms and petit peas from Provence with crispy zucchini
Food was disappointing! Nothing to special to comment on. We were 6 and everyone felt the same. The bread was awful, the salad was limp, the Veal Chop was overly breaded and tasteless, the Risotto was good and the spaghetti as only fair. Dessert was alright Berries we’re fresh and donuts were also very good. This is a very honest review and I am sorry to say we will most likely not return
food was very tasty and nicely presented. Prices were very reasonable and service was very pleasant and efficient. Ambiance and decor also very nice.
Great as always!
I have eaten in the Tribeca location many times but this was my first experience in Chatham. It was equally wonderful and the food, service and ambiance made it a very special evening. Thank you Scalini Fedeli we will be back
We have been diners at Scalini Fedeli for many years. The food was very good as usual, the service prompt and courteous and the staff was efficient. My only overall criticism is that we felt a bit rushed (i.e., we were not asked if we wanted tea or coffee at the end), probably due to the fact that it was a Saturday night and the restaurant was quite busy. The potato crusted red snapper and veal scallopini were excellent, tasty with wonderful sauces. I would not recommend the banana tort for dessert but the mascarpone/ricotta torta was delish. The roasted beet and goat cheese salad could have used more beets and goat cheese and less greens. The spaghetti Arrabiata was very good and had a hint of heat. The primi piccolo of shrimp in mustard sauce was very tasty.
The egg yolk ravioli was amazing! And the wine selection is great
It was absolutely wonderful, and we look forward to our next dining experience! By far our favorite NJ Restaurant!!
Simply Exquisite !
This is the finest place to eat in NJ. Food was spectacular, service was impeccable, ambiance was special. And, the prix fixe was very reasonable. It was our 51 st anniversary and the experience was amazing. Do NOT hesitate to visit as you will rarely if ever match every wonderful aspect of this restaurant.
From the very first bite through all the wonderful courses, the meal was outstanding.
Service was professional without being intrusive.
Definitely will return again soon.
Great food, very nice presentation, attentive service.
Always my best bet when it comes to dining out.
Pork chops are cooked to perfection.
All the food is very good.
Amazingly great food excellent service relaxing ambience
Our four course meal was outstanding. The attention to detail was most appreciated. I’m usually disappointed when I go to a high end restaurant. This restaurant was an exception.
Consistently very good
We had an amazing experience for our 20th wedding anniversary.
This place is a “10” all around
Awesome food…decor is dated but you don’t go for the ambiance…go for the meal!
Great place for special occasions! Great food and service in a beautiful setting !
Always the best service at Scalini paired with deliciously crafted food! Thank you Scalini for always contributing to our special occasions!
Thank you Andres and team, for such great service last night!
Went in to this dinner with very high expectations. Dinner was amazing, specifically the pasta....maybe the best I have ever had. Cocktails pre-dinner were ok, not great.
Waitress was not as good as I am used to with a fine dining experience. Any special request we were treated as if I was asking for a free ride to the moon.
Bottom line I would go for sure as the food is killer but I wouldn't expect anything outside the box from a service perspective.
YOUR HOSTESS AND OR MANAGER NEEDS TO SMILE AND GREET PEOPLE AS IF SHE WANTS THEM THERE. A SIMPLE SMILE AND GREETING GOES A LONG WAY.
We were celebrating my granddaughters high school graduation and Father's Day. The wait staff were knowledgeable and friendly. They answered the questions that my grandchildren had. Food was delicious and paced very well.
What we appreciated was that no plates were removed until all of us finished a course. Three of us had duck for a main course. It was fantastic. The waiter even gave the sauce to take home. And I had my favorite dessert- zabaglione. But, our waiter separated the fruit from the custard. Wonderful!
Thank you for a very memorable experience.
Always a great dining experience with exceptional food and service.
While the wait staff was very friendly, they brought my husband the wrong entree and there was a significant delay between the appetizer and main course round and no explanation or apology was offered. The soft egg yolk ravioli was undercooked (not just al dente) and the ambiance in the outdoor space was lacking. Overall it was a disappointing experience for an anniversary dinner.
Great restaurant. Food out of this world. My wife said of the soft egg yolk ravioli “life changing”service outstanding
All the entrees were memorable! The veal was delicious, the porcini ravioli melted in my mouth, the duck was nice & tender, and my son loved the pasta with vodka sauce!
The deserts we ordered were heavenly-- The tart was nice & crisp and not overly sweet.
The double chocolate cake was devilishly rich and tasty (according to my son) and my other son loved the berries & cream!
The appetizers were alright. We found them a tad pricey.
Overall, a great experience and a suitable restaurant to celebrate a special occasion. In our case an intimate graduation lunch with family.
Old world ambiance. You’ll feel as if you’re in Europe.
Great place to eat for any occasion. Service great and so was the food. We will be back.
Wonderful lunch! Service, food and ambiance was all great! Can’t wait to retun!
It was a pleasure being able to go back..The food has always been, and remains wonderful..The consistency remains top notch..Simply, the BEST!!
Great experience overall. Loves all our dishes and service as fantastic. Will definitely be going back soon!
fixed price luxury Italian in Chatham. Beautiful room, fit for an occasion. The menu is not quite as extensive as it was pre-covid but still plenty of excellent choices. The food was superb. Two problems- no more valet parking and it was difficult to find a space in the lot; also there was a long gap between the appetizer and the main course, like the break at a Dead concert.
I’m rarely left speechless about ala dining experience but this restaurant was incredible. I don’t want to be speechless because I want to shout out how fantastic every aspect of the food, ambiance and service is for any occasion! The price for the prix fix dinner was set in 1964 and hasn’t changed ! Incredible! I can’t wait to go back again and again. I’m worried if I tell too many people I will never be able to book a reservation. Our waiter was the best and Isabella the owner made us feel like family. Wow! No words can do justice you have to go and experience. Plan a special occasion and you won’t be disappointed.
From the moment we entered, the staff at Scalini Fedeli was top notch. The menu offered something for everyone in our party. The food was excellent!
Terrific. Wait staff great.
Always excellent serice and food.
Food and service, as always, was outstanding. Knowledgeable and pleasant staff makes our dining experience superb every time. Food is top notch. Thank you for making my wife’s birthday a pleasant and memorable one.
Excellent food! Great service! Heard a lot about this place over the years, but went first time. Definitely coming back!
Went for my daughter’s 16th birthday! Everything went perfectly. The prix fixe menu had many options and accordingly all were great. The thought behind the menu was perfect. The mushroom risotto and porcini mushroom ravioli special with truffle appetizers were great. I had the short rib which was perfectly cooked and marinated. The Bronzino and duck made my daughters very happy. The chocolate soufflé cake topped the meal. Service was very attentive and very considerate. Could not have asked for more. Had high expectations and they were all met. Made the night very special. Thank you Scalini Fedeli
Scalini Fedeli - Chatham offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 701-9200.
Scalini Fedeli - Chatham is rated 4.8 stars by 1818 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.