Everything from the second we walked in was excellent. Will definitely return.

By far, one of the finest meals we have ever had! Awesome anniversary meal. We will be back for another special night sometime soon!

A lovely dining experience!

Excellent experience. Food was outstanding as it always is.

Love it there!

Fantastic Valentine’s Day dinner! The food the setting the service it was beyond my expectations!!

What a fantastic Valentines Day 5 fix prix dinner..... All the food complimented one another.... The Chef is the owner and puts much love into the preparation of the food. Rory, our head lead attendant was incredibly attentive and superb manners. Overall experience was above excellent.... Will certainly make Scalini Fedeli one of our GO-TO eating establishments.

Food and service was excellent! Minor adjustment: single large ice cube instead of smaller cubes would make my whiskey drink even more enjoyable.
Also, $45 cork fee is a little steep, but all in all a terrific experience.
Love Scalini Fedeli and look forward to my next meal there!

Valentines

Wonderful food and service as always. Never disappoints!

We had a fantastic valentines dinner here. Food was impeccable! Safety and spacing of tables was in accordance with local recommendations and ambiance was tasteful and romantic.

Had a nice night. Food and drinks were very good. Service was great as well. Since we dined the night before Valentine’s Day, all we could get was an early reservation (530) and we felt a little rushed. Food kept coming super quickly. The prefixe menu was good but not worth the nearly $300 we wound up spending... The biggest issue was leaving. It took the valet nearly 30mins to get our car and almost forgot about it. We were stuck in an overcrowded waiting room, which was just annoying and frustrating. We would go back, but not for another holiday.

Early Valentine’s Day Dinner

Always consist and delicious

Amazing food and service.

Dinner for 8 was exceptional. Highlights were the carbonara pasta, braised short rib, and salmon.

We have been to the NYC restaurant a few times and with no indoor dining we decided to see what the Chatham restaurant had to offer. Unfortunately there was an issue with our table so the hostess was extremely professional and accommodating and explained the problem and made our short wait tolerable.

Waiter was funny and on top of his game. Didn't hound us or push us but was always available at the right time. Bar was a little backed up but the tasty drinks made up for the wait.

Food was amazing. Specials were very interesting and I went for the double cut pork chop lightly fried. I couldn't finish it was very filling. Others at the table had the skillet ny strip special and duck. Everyone was very pleased.

Upon leaving we were again greeted by the wonderful hostess. She was extremely friendly and filled us in on the NYC status but honestly because of the great staff we will be returning to Chatham.

Best restaurant in New Jersey! Amazing quality, selection, service, and experience. Delicious food!

Great food. Wayyyy too many people

When pulling in I was forced to valet my car which was not happy with. More to come with that later. During covid restaurants are supposed to be at 25% occupancy and 6 feet apart, 6 feet was done but there was not an open table in the restaurant. Easily had to be 60 people in at the same time. Lobby full w waiting diners to come in. No way that restaurant normally seats 240. I do t personally care but if you are concerned with covid this establishment does not follow. Portions extremely small and expensive. Our server got busy and was not as attentive after entrees were delivered. Now the valet. He brings us the wrong car similar but wrong car. He also used a numbering system and still screwed up. Once I told him I said give me my keys I see my car and I will get it myself. He argued with me followed me to my car because he needed the paper ticket he put in the car. As I gave it to him he said something under his breathe. I asked him what he said, he walked away with more words under his breathe. It was freezing out I would have gone back in to complain but I just chalked it up to terrible valet

Best restaurant in NJ

one of our favorite place to fo. food is always fantastic, service is flawless.

Food is and was amazing..always a treat at any of Chef Michael Cetrulo's Ristorante's! Can't wait to go back!

Start to finish the meal was superb! The staff was attentive and Alex went above and beyond! It was a great evening out. Highly recommend.

Elegant and pricey, but worth it. Try the salmon or the breaded pork chop, or anything you want. You will not be diisappointed.

We were recommended this restaurant by family members. It was one of the best meals we have ever had. You will not regret it! The service is top notch, the drinks are fabulous, the food is unbelievable and it was one of our best meals to date. Alex's service, kindness and personality made the evening as well. You do not want to miss out! Make a reservation, you will not be sorry.

The best italian food in NJ, hands down its not even close.

Wonderful dinner. Fantastic service.

Food and service is incredible. Highly recommend.

Fine dining at its finest. The food is always outstanding as is the service. Since the COVID outbreak fine dining has changed drastically, not at Scalini Fedeli. Top notch. Looking forward to our next meal at SF.

Service was great food was outstanding. The pork chop was to die for

My wife and I had lunch at Scalini Fedeli to celebrate her 65th Birthday. The restaurant was empty. We were the only one's having lunch. While it was nice to have the place to ourselves. It still felt strange.

The food was very good. We shaved the shrimp appetizer. My wife had duck for her main course and I had the pork chop.

We always enjoy going to this restaurant, but haven't because of the pandemic.

OUTSTANDING.

Not my first rodeo with Scalini, but first time during COVID....went to a Prefixe menu, but was all quite outstanding....brought my own wine, but preceded with a cocktail from their bar...excellent. Mad props to the staff and chef.

Cheers,

Food and service were excellent. Haven't been in years and it continues to be a great restaurant!

Still the best restaurant in the area! The environment was perfect, very safe, food and service fabulous.

Incredible food and outstanding service. Wonderful New Years Eve experience.

Wonderful safe experience

Christmas Eve.

Incredible ! Can’t wait to go back.

Celebrated our anniversary. The service was impeccable. The food was amazing. Truly one of the best dining experiences I have ever had