Continues to be an excellent restaurant. Service was a bit slower than usual. Main dishes (fish) were terrific, but the appetizers were not superlative. Overall was a very enjoyable evening but the restaurant wasn't the "wow" we have experienced in the past.
Everyone enjoyed their meals tremendously! So good!
You were given the best attention ever , between the waiter, water boy and manager everyone came over to ensure your experience was perfect.
This restaurant is always fabulous and never fails to impress me
Daughters 18ty birthday
Two couples celebrating their anniversary, could have not been more pleased with the outstanding service and fine food.
Absolutely amazing foods, fantastic service. Highly, highly recommended! Probably our favorite special occasion spot.
Excellent as always...menu, Food, service, atmosphere. Thank you.
Was husband 60 th birthday wrote in comments and told hostess but no candle or special message on dessert
This was our first Scalini experience but definitely not our last. We had such a wonderful evening. Food was exceptional and service was wonderful.
Food is consistently excellent. The 5-course prix fixe is a lot of food and not inexpensive.
Beautiful room and attentive service.
Great dining experience
Lovely atmosphere with space between tables. Our waiter was very knowledgeable and attentive. I knew there was a pre-fixe menu, but not that there were appetizer, dessert, sorbet, and coffee/cookie courses in addition to the first and second plates on the website. No corkage fee Mon-Fri was also a pleasant surprise. Best restaurant we've been to since moving to the area and perfect for a special occasion. We will definitely be back.
Everything was great; food, staff and ambiance!
Perfect spot, with great service.
We came to celebrate a special birthday. The food and service was quite good. Since we were a table for four it wasn’t expected to have to raise our voices to be heard. Tables were too close together. A more intimate setting would have been nicer.
Place has a nice old school feel. It's also dressed up like you are walking into a restaurant in Tuscany. Service was great. The meal was unbelievable. I shared the mushroom ravioli appetizer with my wife as well as a light mozzarella salad. For dinner I had the 18 oz. Pork chop. Hands down best pork chop I've ever had in my life. So good I left bone on the plate with nothing else attached. Bottom line I had a great time, the staff was great, and the food was amazing.
Food was amazing!!! One of the best dinners I have had in some time. Our waiter was not very friendly not very helpful..... disappointing since this was not a cheap night out. Did not feel welcome.... not sure I will return.
This is the first time I'm giving 5`s across the board ! What an amazing dining experience. The food is uniquely outstanding with a lot of complexity. Can't wait to return!
Had an exceptional meal in tranquil surroundings. Great place to enjoy fine dining and also conversation with friends.
The service, as always, is wonderful. The menu is slightly changed but not in any substantial way, which is one of the reasons we don't go as often as we used to. For those new to it, it will be excellent.
Heard rave reviews but I think people are living in the past when they talk about scalini. It was just ok the raviolo app was good my wife's pasta was very undercooked very hard, main courses were s big disappointment I order lamb and the description had no signs of balsamic vinegar but the sauce was loaded with it, my wife's veal chop ordered medium came rare and also very difficult to eat it's s tbone veal chop which Took over the entire plate, believe in a restaurant like this should come pre sliced we couldn't even cut it without making a mess. Just not up to par with what you hear about it, I really don't think we will be back just not a good first impression especially the fact there was only 3 tables in the restaurant. I hate to leave a negative review but I think the owner needs to know what is going on. Such a landmark for many years would hate to see it go down hill for minor mistakes that can be fixed.
Small portion on fish entree for the prices charged.
Excellent, from start to finish.
Celebrated our anniversary. Everything was perfect; food, service, ambience. Perfect.
Spectacular in every respect. Exceptional food, romantic ambience, and extremely pleasant and accommodative wait staff. Scalini Fedeli never lets us down. Can’t wait to be back!
Excellent. Lived up to the hype
The food was fantastic and the service was great. I would recommend this restaurant for any occasion.
Sorry, but not that impressed, food was mediocre (duck was chewy and the pork chop was flavorless), felt rushed, and over priced by about $100. We really wanted to make a memory but couldn't really enjoy the time we had there for what was supposed to be a romantic dinner.
One of the best meals we ever had. Food was out of this world. It was pricey, but I don't mind paying up for quality. Delicious!!!
Food is always excellent and service was exceptional. Would be nice if they could figure out how to create some bar seating to make use of when you are waiting.
Wonderful and romantic! Great food and service!
For a pre-fix menu where the restaurant knew exactly what was to be served, the service was miserably slow. Almost had to ask for wine list after being seated and every course was slow. When the food came it was great but the extremely slow service and lack of attention made the Valentines experience quite diminished. Would have to think twice about visiting again.
Excellent food. Would love to know the recipes. The only issue encountered: my husband ordered Hennessy XO, but was served VSOP.
An excellent upscale Italian restuarant with lots of charm, warm ambience and excellent food. It was a great romantic place for my birthday and Valentine's Day. Also the chocolate dessert menu was to die for.....just awesome!!!!!
Thank you for a wonderful dining experience. Warren our waiter was wonderful and attentive and we even got him to smile a little bit! The food was exceptional I thoroughly enjoyed the porcini mushroom raviolis we did upgrade a few of our items well worth it. the food and the service or impeccable I would definitely return
Scalini Fedeli is a long-time favorite! Had lunch here to celebrate an anniversary. Service was excellent! Our waiter was attentive, and paced our meal perfectly for a leisurely lunch. He even lit a candle in our dessert, much to our surprise. One comment: I have had the mushroom ravioli previously as an appetizer and enjoyed it. Today I ordered it as a main course. It is better as an appetizer, too much, too rich as a main course (my opinion, obviously).
This is the best restaurant I’ve been to in New Jersey !! Food and whole experience is just fantastic !!