Sarento's Italian Restaurant
Prepared traditional style
Fried Steak Calamari
Tender calamari strips, deep-fried and served with marinara
Lightly breaded chicken breast, sautéed & baked with marinara sauce, topped with mozzarella over linguini
Our table wasn’t ready for our reservation. The one blonde bartender was very nice the other female bartender (had an accent) was somewhat rude & very impatient when she was dealing with our party. Our server was nice but very rushed & didn’t come back to us in a timely manner to check in on us. My dinner was inedible ($18) & she did not even seem to care when I shared that & we were ready to almost leave when she finally asked. She did not even respond with a comment & did not even make eye contact. VERY disappointed & VERY expensive. We won’t go back. Very pricey for mediocre service.
Food and service were great. We went on a Sunday evening and it was not crowded. We had not requested a quieter area but didn’t realize there was a choice between the dining room and the bar area. We were seated in the bar area and we would not do that again.
We were on a family vacation, and decided to treat the family to a nicer dinner as a treat. Excellent food, nice ambiance, and good service!
Worst service I’ve had in a long time. If you hate being a waitress so much, maybe find a new job.
Been going to Sarento’s for years as we visit Wis. Dells. Unfortunately, this time will mark the last time. The sauces tasted like it was from a can. The scallops were very fishy. The calamari was waaay over-cooked and the oil it was fried in tasted old. The Service staff was very attentive and helpful, and was the best part of the meal.
Best friend’s Birthday!
Everyone was very satisfied with the food they ordered. The lasagna could have been made with pasta that was a little bit thicker. Prices were reasonable, service was great. Will definitely be going back.
One of the best italian restaurants around . The interior had a amazing artist put some amazing finishes..and who could ever say it more perfect on the menu ...in regards to the steak temperatures ...all n all food atmosphere service all top notch....
first visit for Valentine's Day! it was wonderful all the way around. Food was outstanding and definitely home made. Great service and a nice atmosphere.
Absolutely wonderful! The seafood trio is by far one of the best things ive had.
This was a last minute plan for us. Our dinner was absolutely amazing. We wish we didn't live so far away. We highly recommend Sarento's.
The bolognese was fabulous!! There was live music with a woman singing and a guy with a guitar and they were really good. It was nice to have the music in the background while having dinner.
Vinyl table cloths
A great place to bump into old friends.
coffee and water needed to be filled more often
music was wonderful
Salad was amazing
eggplant seemed like a from scratch recipe
Friday fish fry. Everything was excellent. Will be back.
Too expensive for the quality of service. Wrong side dish was served, no desert was offered.
Super service always at Sarento’s. It’s what keeps us coming back along with the amazing food.
The food was very very delicious, the only complaint I have is our waitress never came to check on us when we got our food and it took 25 minutes to get our bill once we were done eating
Have enjoyed dining at sarentos many times while visiting the dells area. The food is excellent, service prompt, and reasonable menu prices. It's a special place.
We requested to sit in a booth in the bar to take advantage of the live music which is why the higher level of noise, The dining room is always quite. Hard to find good veal at many restaurants and the veal dishes are our favorites this time of year.
A great experience. First time here for a dinner before a concert and show in the area and everything was absolutely fantastic from the table, service, drinks and meal perspective. We will definitely be back. Cheers!
We were in the area for another activity and thought we’d give it a try. To us, a restaurant is a three legged experience: the scenery, the food and the service. If any leg is short the stool falls over. Sarento’s stood tall.
We walked in and noticed right away the place is cute. Cozy lighting, dark woods and warm atmosphere. It was busy but not nuts. We were sat right away.
Morgan, and the rest of our servers, were prompt, warm and professional. We didn’t have to wait around at anytime for anything, they timed the courses well and checked on us regularly.
The food was good. It tasted pretty authentic. The presentations were simple and clean. We’d take a bath in the balsamic, and the spaghetti meat sauce.
We’ll be back again when we are in the area. We’d recommend this property to anyone who wants a nice Italian meal.
Good family restaurant with kids menu. Not a date night or quiet evening place. Pizza and sandwiches to keep costs down if you need to or have a large group.
The food was excellent and we had great service. I would highly recommend this Italian restaurant!
We were impressed by the outstanding service. It has a warm, cozy and friendly atmosphere. The food is very delicious. We drive 2 1/2 hours one way just for dinner
Typical Italian fare, a little pricey. Attentive staff.
Everything was excellent. The food was delicious, especially the Lasagna, and the Hazelnut chocolate cake for desert. The waiters were very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was relaxing and cozy with a fireplace. My wife and I came here for my birthday, at my request. I love this place!
Food delicious. Service prompt and attentive. Live Music by the bar was nice touch.
The service and food was fantastic!! We would definitely eat here again.
Our server took for ever to come. When she did she took our order and the other lady who was really nice with the accent served us our food.
Perfect table to enjoy my husband’s retirement! My salmon salad w/shrimp was sooo delicious. My husband loved his blackened salmon too...done just right!
Food was appetizing. I had the lasagna and my husband the chicken parm. Ambiance was great, just felt prices are a little high.
We had the most amazing dinner at Sarento's after our vows renewal in the Dells. Our waitress was beyond spectacular. She made the night extra special for us. She had wonderful suggestions for meals and was nice as can be. We sat in the same room that we had our dinner in the night of our wedding five years ago and it made the evening even more special. Can't wait to come back again! Thank you!
Awesome pizza, and fried calamari for appetizer was fantastic!! Our new favorite go-to in the Dells!!
Great service, wonderful food. We were taken there, so not sure of the price, but on the menu the prices appeared to be comperative with better restaurants of similar quality and ambiance. We will definitely go back!
The atmosphere was nice, staff great . Not impressed with the food, it was okay. May go back and try other menu items or maybe they were having an off night
Amazing romatic date in the bar/lounge with live music. Food, impectable!
Nice place good food. Will recommend and come again
Aniversario de boda
Sarento's Italian Restaurant offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 253-3300.
Sarento's Italian Restaurant is rated 4.3 stars by 169 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.