Outstanding bagels and smoked salmon. Do not miss this when in NY!

Love Sadelle's! <3 It always hits the spot! Keep it up!

Really overrated and overpriced.

Great food! Great service! Definately will come back.

Our favorite neighborhood restaurant with the best bagel and lox in the city!

Love the hostess, staff and food always!

It was an OK experience. The food was very heavy, the lack of espresso was a bummer and the tea was just mediocre. The server was nice and they made an effort for my friend’s birthday. But I’m not going back. I use to like it years back but I feel there are other places that provide more and better in an elevated ambiance for that prices.

Heather was the best server we have ever had in NYC. She took her time with us and heard we were celebrating a birthday and surprised us with a candle. We are locals and it was not too touristy. Can’t believe we haven’t been here earlier. Definitely going back and definitely requesting Heather!

Loved sadelles!! Food and service was outstanding ! Can’t wait to go back!

Everything perfection service decor food noise level very very cozy atmosphere perfect for brunch and lunch

Loved it! Best brunch

Heater at Sadelle’s did not work on a 16 degree morning. Everyone inside was freezing cold and required wearing a jacket inside

The restaurant was freezing. Our service was not great, we changed table because of how cold it was so maybe that was part of the issue. Great restaurant, but no apologies on how cold the restaurant was. If there waa

The ambience at night with the candles is very amazing, definitely going again

Sadelle's special Valentine's Day menu was great. We had the foie gras mousse as well as the porterhouse steak. Everything was cooked well and service was very good. The candlelight atmosphere was super cute. I think I'll come back for the regular brunch some time.

Food was average I expected better from its reputation.

Loved this great little authentic bagel place. So yummy and fresh and great service. Will rec to friends.

Sadelle's is a classic. We last went on a weekday morning which was great -- on the weekends it's always jammed. It's pretty expensive for bagels and lox, but the food is very good and it's a fun place to be.

I love Sadelle’s - house salmon is so good and it comes on a little tower with a bunch of ingredients that you can put together on your bagels. It’s fun to make your own. I would highly recommend this for brunch with friends !

Best bagels!

I enjoy going to Sadelle’s and the food is very good. It seems the prices have really increased, $18 for 3 very small pastries. Bill for 2 with no drinks was $90 including tip. When we arrived the place was empty and after checking in, (we had a reservation), the hostess asked us to move to the side. Wow, that was very rude, she acted as if we were an inconvenience.

The waitress was excellent and I won’t base my returning on one employee out of 50, but someone should explain to her about being courteous and respectful to customers.

I loved everything about my experience at Sadelle's and look forward to returning! The food (french toast) was DELICIOUS. The waitstaff was efficient and friendly. The hostess was outstanding, she made me feel welcome and checked in on me throughout the meal. Ambiance was elevated yet comfortable. Only complaint were the children sitting next to me who were running around like a playground, but that is NOT a reflection of the restaurant. Otherwise it was a flawless experience and I can't wait to return. Thanks!!

Ordered the $18 sticky bun, only to get three very small cold ones. Was disappointed.

Good for yummy food with friends and pretty restaurant. Have gone many times. If you’re allergic to gluten or have Celiac Disease, you need to tell them you’re Celiac because they flag your order in the kitchen. If you just say gluten allergy to the waiter, they’ll mess up.

A go to for me!

Waitress refused to provide hot milk for coffee

Wonderful, as always!

I had a great time and would go back again soon

Muy bueno como siempre

Absolutely the BEST breakfast/brunch ever!! A must when you visit NY! Service was wonderful and food exceptional! Must have a reservation though to get in. Will always go back here when in NY!

I’ve been to Sadelle’s several times now, and feels like the service is only getting worse. The waiters just don’t seem to pay enough attention.

Great food and service

Great waiter great food

Brunch at Sadelle’s is always a good option when you have friends visiting and they want an instagrammable option. In my opinion is a bit too expensive for what is served, but consistently good all the time

Great place, great food

Went last Sunday. Reservation at 5pm that we had to guarantee. Ordered quickly. Then went to change order they told us kitchen was closed at 515. The order came out wrong. They ran out of bagels and coffee. Waiter even acknowledged it doesn’t make sense for them to take reservations at 5pm when kitchen closes at 515. There won’t be a next time.

Customer service has room for improvement. Table wait staff was almost non existent. No one cleared any plates even though we had finished eating several courses.

Our brunch at Sadelle’s was a last minute reservation that really capped off our trip to the city. The bagels were fantastic- served slightly toasted and warm! My friend had the tuna melt on the recommendation of our server, and she raves about it. We enjoyed mimosas and the pickles brought with our meal. Highly recommend sitting where you can watch them making the bagels and pastries. Great meal and great service!

Outstanding

Great service and food

Yummmmmmmmmm😎 on all levels