Diners' Choice - Long Island / Hamptons

Best Italian Restaurants

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Long Island / Hamptons? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Top ​10 Diners' Choice Winners in Long Island / Hamptons

photo of the trattoria restaurant
9.6
Exceptional
(723)
96% 96% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian St. James
Hurry, we only have 2 timeslots left!
photo of trattoria dimeo restaurant
9.4
Awesome
(300)
91% 91% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Roslyn
photo of la ginestra - ny restaurant
9.6
Exceptional
(166)
93% 93% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Glen Cove
photo of king umberto restaurant restaurant
9.6
Exceptional
(688)
98% 98% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Elmont
photo of 18 bay restaurant
9.4
Awesome
(397)
96% 96% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Shelter Island
Find next available

At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM. Have another time in mind?

photo of il luogo ristorante restaurant
9.4
Awesome
(688)
94% 94% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Rockville Centre
photo of molto bene restaurant
8.8
Excellent
(105)
88% 88% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Merrick
photo of vincent's clam bar restaurant
9.2
Awesome
(40)
93% 93% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Carle Place
  • Previous
  • Next