Skip to main content

Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Key West / Florida Keys

OpenTable

Updated September 05, 2024

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Key West / Florida Keys? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

A photo of Plaza Grill restaurant

5.0

5 (79)

$50 and over

Steakhouse

Marathon

About the restaurant

Plaza Grill offers a sophisticated, friendly, relaxing atmosphere, a cozy bar, comfortable chairs, attentive service, an award-winning wine list, and an unparalleled menu.
Get a selective glass of wine 25% off from 5:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m.

Top review

A

Alinevip

Dined on Aug 30, 2024

Best steak in town . Service is phenomenal. Great ambience

A photo of Cafe Sole - Key West restaurant

Cafe Sole - Key West

4.9

4.9 (3412)

$50 and over

French

Key West

About the restaurant

Café Solé has captured the hearts and palates of locals and visitors lucky enough to discover this culinary gem off the beaten path. By combining his French mastery of sauces with fresh locally caught seafood, John has created a menu unlike any on the island, where every dish is bursting with indescribable flavors. Mutton snapper in pesto and champagne, yellowtail in a beurre blanc of lobster or a rare hog snapper with red pepper zabaglione top a list of nightly specials. As for the classics, the Duck a L'Orange, Rack of Lamb with herb de Province and Lobster Bouillaise are as authentic as you will find this side of Paris. Chef Correa combines the best of both of his worlds, European and Caribbean to win the People's Choice and Best Entree awards at a recent Master Chefs Classic

Top review

J

joe

Dined 3 days ago

My “go to” whenever I visit Key West. Our experience Friday night was so good, we are returning again on Sunday for another dinner. The hogfish was fabulous, the conch carpaccio appetizer was excellent, and loved my dessert as always.

Discover more

A photo of Key Lime Pie of a restaurant

A photo of Caesar Salad of a restaurant

A photo of Hog Snapper Sole' of a restaurant

Hog Snapper Sole'

A photo of Little Pearl restaurant

4.9

4.9 (2720)

$50 and over

Seafood

Key West

About the restaurant

We are OPEN 6 nights a week with 3 seating times
Monday-Saturday 5pm/7pm/9pm
Offering Chef’s Tasting Menu only. Unfortunately, our regular menu is unavailable at this time. Follow our website, Facebook, or IG for most current menu offerings... or just give us a call!
Please contact the restaurant with ALL dietary restrictions 24 hours before reservation for us to accommodate.
Thank you for your support during these unprecedented times! Looking forward to seeing you again!

Nestled in the heart of Old Town and away from the bustling downtown streets of Key West, Florida, sits an excellent spot for fresh local catch and innovative cuisine with a tropical twist.
Reservations are recommended!! Please call us for parties larger than 4 people.

Top review

M

Marinavip

Dined 4 days ago

Always delicious! We had oysters, lobster vichyssoise, octodogs, ceviche, salmon and the delicious panna cotta. Love the creativity of the dishes and the service is always excellent. Thank you, Dan!

A photo of Red Shoe Island Bistro restaurant

Red Shoe Island Bistro

4.9

4.9 (1184)

$31 to $50

American

Key West

About the restaurant

Key West seafood restaurant in the heart of old town on Petronia. The menu is kept small so that everything is nice and fresh for you. Yellowtail snapper, fish of the day, Key West pink shrimp, and seafood medley highlight the menu.
Deviled Eggs topped with Scallops, Shrimp Mango Toast and Crispy Pork Belly Croustinis tantalize the pallet. Beef stroganoff made with certified black angus beef is a favorite.

Relaxing, unpretentious, and romantic.
Seating is very limited.
24 Hour Cancellation window.
For the consideration of our guests, we do not accept parties over the size of six (6).
We offer a 6 pm and an 8 pm seating.
BEER AND WINE AVAILABLE.
No Children's menu available.

Top review

C

Chris

Dined 7 days ago

Had the most amazing time. The server John was amazing the host Suzy was fantastic. Food came out quickly and was hot and delicious. I recommend this restaurant to everyone. This is how it should be done.

Discover more

A photo of Seared Scallops of a restaurant

Seared Scallops

A photo of Yellowtail Snapper of a restaurant

Yellowtail Snapper

A photo of Beef Stroganoff of a restaurant

Beef Stroganoff

A photo of White Street Pizza restaurant

White Street Pizza

4.9

4.9 (15)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Key West

About the restaurant

Chef Marek is inspired by the pizzerias of New York, and he is bringing that inspiration to you to enjoy in the heart of the local scene in Key West, the White Street District. We also have a selection of unique TAPAS s to enjoy. So please join us for a special evening of relaxation with cold beer, fine wine, and friends old and new enjoying great pizza, unique small plates, and salads. A casual experience with gourmet food in a century old house that some say may have a ghost or two. Please make a reservation as space is limited and we want everyone to enjoy Key West's latest addition to the dining scene. Rock n roll fans step to the front with your munchies.

Top review

S

Sarah

Dined 5 days ago

Very friendly and extremely clean. The pizza was amazing! We will definitely be back

A photo of Azur restaurant

4.8

4.8 (2814)

$30 and under

Mediterranean

Key West

About the restaurant

Conveniently located in the heart of old Key West, AZUR Restaurant is the locals' and visitors' favorite for creative, Mediterranean cuisine. Whether you choose our shaded terrace or the cool blue dining room, please join us for a hearty breakfast featuring a few new twists, an al fresco lunch by the waterfall, or an intimate dinner with offerings including old favorites and new creations. AZUR is within walking distance of most guest houses and hotels, and also has free parking. For a completely unique dining experience in Old Town, AZUR is a must on your list of innovative-chef restaurants in Key West.

Top review

J

Jon

Dined 7 days ago

10 out of 10 for the entire experience. The pork chop medallions and roasted potatoes were amazing! And the service was great!

Discover more

A photo of Pulpo of a restaurant

A photo of Key Lime French Toast of a restaurant

Key Lime French Toast

A photo of Confit Duck Leg of a restaurant

Confit Duck Leg

A photo of Santiago's Bodega Key West restaurant

Santiago's Bodega Key West

4.8

4.8 (2048)

$31 to $50

Tapas / Small Plates

Key West

About the restaurant

Since 2003, Santiago's Bodega Key West in Bahama Village has been serving globally inspired small plates in a vibrant, inviting atmosphere. We offer indoor and outdoor seating. For parties of 6 or more, please call the restaurant to reserve. We are a neighborhood gem. Reservations are highly recommended.

Open daily from 11:00am-10:00pm. We offer Happy Hour seven days a week from 3:00pm-6:00pm featuring half-priced sangria, wine by the glass, draft beer, and select $6 tapa specials. We look forward to welcoming you!

Top review

C

christine

Dined today

Great night - sat at the bar - fun night! It had been 10 years but I don’t know why it’s been so long

Discover more

A photo of Beef Tenderloin of a restaurant

Beef Tenderloin

A photo of Spicy Shrimp Bisque of a restaurant

Spicy Shrimp Bisque

A photo of Puff Pastry of a restaurant

A photo of Seven Fish restaurant

4.7

4.7 (2968)

$31 to $50

Seafood

Key West

About the restaurant

Simple. Good. Food.

From humble beginnings over 20 years ago, Seven Fish has earned its place as a Key West Classic.

Serving the freshest local fish in a casual, contemporary bistro setting, it is the perfect finish to your Key West day.

Unpretentious dishes, with a commitment to only the finest ingredients, and made from scratch every day, it is the meal you don’t want to end.

Try our house specialty, Thai Curry Snapper, or any of our fresh fish dishes, or maybe the Banana Chicken or even the locals’ favorite, 7 Fish Meatloaf. There is something for everyone, lovingly prepared to exceed your expectations, including our specialty drinks and inspiring wine menu. Be sure to save room for one of our home made, classic desserts.

You will love our beautiful new building, enjoy our warm, friendly staff and come back again and again for the remarkable food.

Top review

K

Katvip

Dined on Sep 2, 2024

Food is always consistently good and fresh. Service is exceptional. A must go-to in Key West.

Discover more

A photo of Seafood Ceviche of a restaurant

Seafood Ceviche

A photo of Thai Curry Yellowtail Snapper of a restaurant

Thai Curry Yellowtail Snapper

A photo of TUNA of a restaurant

A photo of Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar restaurant

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

4.6

4.6 (2006)

$31 to $50

Seafood

Marathon

About the restaurant

We offer casual waterfront indoor and outdoor dining at the islands oldest restaurant. Beautifully remodeled in 2007, our full service menu features Seafood, Sushi, Steaks, a full liquor bar and 32 Beers on tap. We were recently featured on Guy Fieris Diners, Drive-ins and Dives so make dinner reservations a day or two in advance if you can. We serve breakfast lunch and dinner and highly recommend making dinner reservations. We do not accept reservations until 4 pm but we are open all day everyday except Tuesday and Wednesday and welcome walk-ins anytime.

Top review

L

Laurenvip

Dined 6 days ago

Always a great experience. We come every year when we visit from Ohio

Discover more

A photo of Hogfish of a restaurant

A photo of Toasted Coconut Key Lime Pie of a restaurant

Toasted Coconut Key Lime Pie

A photo of Lobster Enchiladas of a restaurant

Lobster Enchiladas

A photo of Rams Head Southernmost restaurant

Rams Head Southernmost

4.2

4.2 (139)

$30 and under

American

Key West

About the restaurant

FOOD, FUN + BEER
RAMS HEAD WAS FOUNDED IN ANNAPOLIS, MARYLAND AND HAS BEEN FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED SINCE 1989. WITH ROOTS IN KEY WEST, RAMS HEAD IS PROUD TO BE PART OF THE LOCAL COMMUNITY AND IS COMMITTED TO PROVIDING THE BEST IN FOOD, FUN, AND BEER.

Top review

R

Razor

Dined on Jul 25, 2024

Average food, average service and high prices. This place has been around for a while, but really is just average.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Key West / Florida Keys

Best Overall

Best Food

Best Service

Best Ambiance

Best Value

Explore more Diners' Choice lists

Discover

OpenTable

About Us
Blog
Careers
Press

More

OpenTable for iOS
OpenTable for Android
Affiliate Program
Contact Us

Our sites

Businesses

Restaurant reservation software
Industry insights
Hospitality resources
Marketing resources
Operation resources
How to open a restaurant
For restaurants
For restaurant groups

Join us on

Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
Cookie Preferences

Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.

OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.