Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Staten Island

OpenTable

Updated July 05, 2025

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Staten Island? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Bocelli Ristorante

4.9

4.9 (681)

$31 to $50

Italian

Concord

About the restaurant

For almost two decades, Bocelli Ristorante has been providing the most authentic Italian cuisine in Staten Island and New York City. Voted the Best Italian Restaurant in both 2014 and 2015, and named one of the 2017 Top 10 best Italian Restaurants in NYC, we pride ourselves on using the finest ingredients to make delicious dishes all served in an atmosphere that will place you on a sunny hillside in Italy. Whether seeking an intimate dinner with a loved one, a family get-together or a larger special occasion in our private party room, there are few restaurants that can cater to your senses like Bocelli Ristorante.
See you soon!

Top review

LukeVIP

Dined on Jun 28, 2025

This was the best Italian restaurant I’ve been to in my 8 years of living in NYC

Deluca's Restaurant - Amboy Rd.

4.9

4.9 (56)

$31 to $50

Italian

Tottenville

About the restaurant

Staten Island's premier fine dining destination. Specializing in fine Italian Food, Superior Service, with an Elegant yet comfortable atmosphere. Recipes passed down from generation to generation.

Top review

Moe

Dined on Jun 6, 2025

From the bread they serve in the beginning to the appetizers, to the entrees, everything was great! Amazing food and even better staff!

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Tottenville

4.9

4.9 (47)

$31 to $50

Pizzeria

Tottenville

About the restaurant

Specializing in authentic coal-fired Italian pizza, antipasto and other traditional Italian dishes. We use only the freshest and finest ingredients. We also make our own mozzarella daily by hand and have a full bar!

Top review

Jeanine

Dined on Jun 22, 2025

Loved it! Beautiful space, music was not too loud, service was perfect and the food was delicious. Dinner For four of us was $200 including tip (we ordered four entrees, with one appetizer, one glass of wine and shared one dessert)

DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake

4.9

4.9 (26)

$31 to $50

American

Clifton

About the restaurant

Established in 2016, DOUGH by Licastri offers the finest pizza and breads, crafted from an almost 100-year-old family recipe perfected by the late Stephen Licastri. Combining traditional techniques with modern methods, our dough features the best ingredients, including all-natural sourdough starter, locally sourced wheat flour, and Fleur de Sel sea salt, culminating in a three-day rise process. Our Silver Lake location on Staten Island provides a unique dining experience with a full bar and outdoor seating, perfect for any occasion. At DOUGH, we are dedicated to delighting customers with fresh, made-to-order food and exceptional ambiance, embodying our motto: “It’s all about the DOUGH!”

Top review

Marie

Dined on Jun 14, 2025

Great service and atmosphere! Can’t wait to eat outside when weather is nice Restaurant was very accommodating - couple extra people came & we had some people with food allergies/restrictions Grandma’s Pizza was amazing as was clam pizza All the food and drinks were very good Will return and highly recommend

J's On The Bay

4.8

4.8 (86)

$31 to $50

Contemporary American

Shore Acres

About the restaurant

Welcome to J’s on the Bay, owned and operated by proprietor Chef Joe Salimeni, award-winning graduate of French Culinary Institute and self made owner of this establishment as well as J’s Meal Prep. J’s On the Bay offers Meal Prep for busy customers on the go. From quinoa salads to truffled chicken lettuce wraps, turkey chili and everything in between. They offer weekly delivery to all five boroughs and soon, nationwide distribution.
J’s offers its customers a unique dining experience with its off the cuff combinations of classic ingredients and their unexpected marriages Chef Joe constructs. J’s was first opened in 2014 has evolved over the last 7 years from a homely neighborhood diner to the fine dining restaurant it is today. Through hard work, uninterrupted and meticulous care, and constantly working to push himself and his menu, Joe has turned his restaurant dreams into a reality.

Top review

DebraVIP

Dined on Jun 24, 2025

i was here once before for lunch, but came back for dinner with a friend and it was just as good, our server George was the best, he was very sweet and personable and efficient, we loved him, the spicy coconut margarita was delicious and we shared the 4 cheese gnocchi OMG it was ridiculous, i will definitely be back soon

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Eltingville

4.8

4.8 (65)

$30 and under

Pizza Bar

Huguenot

About the restaurant

Campania Coal Fired Pizza specializes in exactly what its name implies: delicious pizza cooked in a coal oven to produce a unique smoky texture to the crust and toppings. This special method of cooking pizza imparts certain flavors that simply can't be replicated by using a wood burning stove or other method of heating. Diners simply need to taste for themselves the difference Campania's incredibly hot coal-fired grill makes Campania's pizza menu comes with a build-your-own pizza option as well as several signature house recipes. Some of the delicious pizzas diners can try out are the Margherita, Buffalo Chicken and the Calabrese with tomato sauce, hot soppressata, mozzarella, pecorino romano and basil. If guests aren't in the mood for pizza they can also order one of the sandwiches like the chicken parmigiana or the Napoli with grilled chicken, mozzarella and a made-from-scratch pesto sauce.

Top review

Jessica

Dined on Jun 28, 2025

Great atmosphere, delicious food, attentive servers. Couldn't ask for more! Love it.

Blue

4.7

4.7 (215)

$30 and under

Mediterranean

Randall Manor

About the restaurant

Blue blends the cuisines from the cultures adjacent to the Mediterranean Sea.

Top review

BeverlyVIP

Dined on Jun 27, 2025

A delightful lunch experience all around. The water view of the marine traffic through Kill Van Kull adds a special dimension to the friendly, responsive service at Blue. We had an excellent luncheon experience. I especially enjoyed the zucchini soup that was served along with my stuffed flounder entree. The dessert selection was wonderful. We look forward to a return visit.

Patrizia's Taverna

4.7

4.7 (21)

$30 and under

Italian

New Dorp

About the restaurant

Authentic family owned & operated Italian restaurant offering homemade pastas, breads, desserts, seafood, meats, and cheeses.
Patrizia's Taverna - Where Guests Become Family!

Top review

AliciaVIP

Dined on Jun 28, 2025

Always greeted by the best hosts. Restaurant is clean and well appointed. Menu selection is like home cooking. Accommodates a wide variety of palates. Always delicious and fresh

Millie's of Staten Island

4.5

4.5 (30)

$31 to $50

Italian

Charleston

About the restaurant

The team behind Millie’s is passionate about pizza, both the coal-fired and the Neapolitan styles. Thanks to “dueling ovens”, pies from both varieties are offered. Inspired by childhood visits to Totonno’s, the legendary Coney Island pizzeria, the coal oven burns over 650+ degrees and can produce pies in five minutes. The signature Millie’s pie combines sautéed tomatoes with fresh mozzarella and a sprinkling of parmesan. The Neapolitan wood oven, hand-built by Italy’s celebrated Ferrara family, and imported from Naples, cooks pizzas, such as the Margherita, in just 90 seconds thanks to the intense 800+ degree heat.

Evoking memories of bountiful “Sunday Suppers” where families gathered around the table to share recipes passed down from generation to generation, Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza is bringing that same convivial feeling of a close knit Italian family to everyone.

Top review

Humberto

Dined on Jun 25, 2025

Ava our waitress was absolutely amazing. She made sure we were good throughout our whole experience.

Serena Bistro

4.4

4.4 (43)

$30 and under

Sports Bar

Pleasant Plains

About the restaurant

In the vibrant heart of Staten Island, New York, a unique concept has emerged that beautifully combines the thrill of sports with the elegance of fine dining: a sophisticated sports lounge and bar. This establishment has been thoughtfully designed to cater to discerning patrons who appreciate not only the excitement of athletic events but also the finer aspects of gourmet cuisines and upscale ambiance.

With its commitment to quality, community, and the pure joy of sports, this fine dining sports lounge and bar in Staten Island promises an experience that is as thrilling as the games on screen. Whether you are gathering for a major sporting event or seeking a luxurious dining experience, this venue expertly caters to all, making it a must-visit destination in the heart of Staten Island.

Top review

MaryAnn

Dined on Jun 21, 2025

This was our first time at Serena. When we walked in the place was empty. I didn’t think that was a good sign. The place was beautiful so I was confused as to why there was no one there. We ordered a charcuterie board which was beautiful and the meats and cheeses were great. I ordered the Sea bass which is as amazing and my husband ordered a hamburger was over cooked. I had a mojito and my husband had 2 Heineken. When we got the bill the Heinekens were priced to be $9 but on the menu they were priced to be $7. When my husband questioned the waiter he didn’t change the bill.we thought that was terrible. We spent a good amount of money there and I thought they should honor it but they did t so we won’t be going back.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Staten Island

Explore more Diners' Choice lists

Italian